Mount Carlton is a Paleozoic high-sulfidation epithermal deposit located in the northern segment of the Bowen Basin, northeast Queensland, Australia. The deposit is hosted in Early Permian volcanic and sedimentary rocks, and an open-pit mining operation includes the Au-rich V2 pit in the northeast and the Ag-rich A39 pit in the southwest. Mineralization at Mt. Carlton occurred during active rifting, partly contemporaneously with the deposition of volcanic sediments in localized half-graben and graben basins. Steep normal faults and fracture networks related to the rifting acted as fluid conduits and localized cores of silicic alteration. The silicic cores transition outward to zones of quartz-alunite alteration, which are, in turn, enveloped by a zone of quartz-dickite-kaolinite alteration. Epithermal mineralization at Mt. Carlton developed in three stages: Cu-Au-Ag mineralization dominated by enargite was overprinted by Zn-Pb-Au-Ag mineralization dominated by sphalerite, which, in turn, was overprinted by Cu-Au-Ag mineralization dominated by tennantite. Proximal Au-Cu mineralization in the V2 pit occurs in networks of steep faults associated with veins and hydrothermal breccias within a massive rhyodacite porphyry. Three distinct ore zones (Eastern, Western, and Link) are aligned, en echelon, along a broadly E trending corridor. The Western ore zone continues along ~600-m strike length to the southwest into the A39 pit, and it shows a metal zonation, from proximal to distal, of Au-Cu → Cu-Zn-Pb-Ag → Ag-Pb-(Cu) → Ag. Distal Ag mineralization in the A39 pit is concentrated in a volcanolacustrine sedimentary sequence that overlies the rhyodacite porphyry. It occurs in a stratabound position oriented parallel to primary sedimentary layering and locally exhibits synsedimentary ore textures. Such textures are interpreted to have formed as mineralizing fluids discharged into what most likely were lakes developed within localized rift basins, at the same time that the volcanolacustrine sediments were deposited. At depth, equivalent ore textures were produced within open spaces in the structural roots of the rift basins. 40Ar/39Ar dating of hydrothermal alunite yielded an age range of 284 ± 7 to 277 ± 7 Ma, which links the formation of the Mt. Carlton deposit to the Early Permian back-arc rifting stage in the Bowen Basin. Prolonged extension provided rapid burial of the deposit beneath a postmineralization, volcanosedimentary cover, which was essential for the exceptional preservation of Mt. Carlton. The same extension caused displacement of the rock pile along a series of shallowly dipping detachment faults and segmentation and rotation of the ore zones across steeply dipping normal faults. This deformation would have displaced any underlying porphyry mineralization relative to the current location of Mt. Carlton.
High-sulfidation epithermal deposits are typically found in andesitic to dacitic volcanic arcs subjected to variable regional stress regimes, ranging from mildly extensional to compressional (Sillitoe, 1993, 2010; Cooke and Simmons, 2000; Tosdal and Richards, 2001; Sillitoe and Hedenquist, 2003). These deposits are believed to form in magmatic-hydrothermal environments similar to those that occur beneath modern volcanic fumaroles and crater lakes (Hedenquist et al., 1993). They are mined predominantly for their Au content, while other metals (chiefly Ag and Cu) may be economically important in individual deposits (Arribas, 1995a; Singer, 1995). Mineralization in high-sulfidation deposits may occur in contact with or only a few meters beneath the paleosurface, but, more commonly, it is separated from the paleosurface by up to several hundred meters (Sillitoe, 2015). Mineralization styles include hydrothermal breccias, veins, stockworks, and disseminations or replacements (Arribas, 1995a). The high-grade ore commonly occurs within cores of silicic alteration, locally exhibiting a vuggy texture, which reflect the leaching effects of highly acidic (pH ≈ 1; Stoffregen, 1987) magmatic vapor condensates injected into the epithermal environment. The silicic cores, which typically are no more than a few tens of meters wide, have halos of advanced argillic minerals (e.g., alunite, dickite, kaolinite, pyrophyllite, diaspore, and pyrite) that may have areal extents up to several square kilometers (Steven and Ratté, 1960; Stoffregen, 1987; Arribas, 1995a; Sillitoe, 1995). High-sulfidation epithermal deposits typically have structurally controlled feeders (e.g., local subvertical faults and fractures), with silicic-advanced argillic alteration possibly forming horizontal to subhorizontal lithocaps along specific horizons, such as unconformities and permeable rock layers (Arribas, 1995a; Sillitoe, 1999, 2010; Hedenquist et al., 2000; Chang et al., 2011). These deposits and their associated lithocaps can be considered as the top parts of larger intrusion-driven hydrothermal mineralizing systems, centered on porphyry intrusions that may be enriched in Cu, Au, and/or Mo (Arribas et al., 1995b; Hedenquist et al., 1998; Sillitoe, 2010; Chang et al., 2011).
Queensland, Australia, has an abundance of mineral deposits related to Carboniferous and Permian magmatism, which formed inboard of an active continental margin (Henderson, 1980; Champion and Mackenzie, 1994; Blevin et al., 1996; Bain and Draper, 1997; Champion and Bultitude, 2013). Clusters of porphyry and epithermal Cu-Au deposits and prospects occur in the northern segment of the Bowen Basin in northeast Queensland (Fig. 1). Mineralization in the northern Bowen Basin is predominantly hosted in Early Permian volcanic rocks that were deposited within a back-arc rift environment (Donchak et al., 2013). The most significant, and the only deposit currently in production, is the Mt. Carlton high-sulfidation deposit. Mt. Carlton was discovered in 2006 and has estimated resources (indicated + inferred) of 10.42 million tonnes (Mt) averaging 2.92 g/t Au, 30.60 g/t Ag, and 0.47% Cu, containing ~1 Moz Au (as of December 2016; M. Obiri-Yeboah, pers. commun., 2017). With respect to its average Au grade, Mt. Carlton is comparable to medium-grade and unoxidized high-sulfidation deposits such as Lepanto, Rodalquilar, Chelopech, Chinkuashih, Pierina, and Pueblo Viejo (Fig. 2). Mt. Carlton differs from most of these deposits in that it is mined using open-pit methods. This includes the larger and Au-rich V2 pit in the northeast and the smaller and Ag-rich A39 pit in the southwest (Fig. 3).
Due to high erosion rates in most volcanic arcs, the preservation potential of high-sulfidation deposits in older terranes is generally poor (e.g., Kesler and Wilkinson, 2006). Mt. Carlton is, therefore, of particular interest as it is one of only few known economic, pre-Neogene, high-sulfidation deposits in the world. In this study, we document the geologic setting, hydrothermal alteration, mineralization, mineral chemistry, and 40Ar/39Ar geochronology of the Mt. Carlton deposit. This study contributes to the understanding of the characteristics, formation, preservation, and tectonic modification of shallow high-sulfidation deposits in extensional settings. This information can, in turn, be useful when exploring for epithermal and porphyry deposits in similar geologic terranes elsewhere.
The Bowen Basin is an NNW-trending, elongate, and asymmetrical sedimentary basin covering an area of ~200,000 km2 in eastern Queensland. It formed as part of the New England Orogen during the Early Permian to Middle Triassic and is the northern part of a larger basin system that also includes the Gunnedah and Sydney basins in New South Wales (Donchak et al., 2013). The Bowen Basin shows evidence of a complex and polyphase tectonic evolution, divided into back-arc extension, thermal relaxation, and foreland basin stages. The Bowen Basin was initiated in the Early Permian by extension of the back-arc continental crust inland of the Connors arc, causing rifting (Esterle et al., 2002; Korsch et al., 2009). This produced a series of isolated NNW-trending graben and half-graben basins, which were infilled by volcanic and sedimentary rocks (Murray, 1990; Hutton et al., 1999; Esterle et al., 2002; Korsch et al., 2009). The Lizzie Creek Volcanic Group was deposited during this time and comprises calc-alkaline, andesitic to rhyolitic volcanic rocks, and minor terrestrial sediments, which host most of the mineralization in the northern Bowen Basin (Paine et al., 1974; I. Corral, unpub. data, 2018). The back-arc rifting stage was followed by a period of thermal relaxation and subsidence in the Middle Permian, which led to flooding of the Bowen Basin and deposition of marine and coastal plain sedimentary units (Malone et al., 1969; Esterle et al., 2002; Allen and Fielding, 2007; Korsch and Totterdell, 2009). The thermal relaxation stage was abruptly terminated in the Late Permian, due to the onset of the ~265 to 235 Ma Hunter-Bowen Orogeny (Donchak et al., 2013). This led to foreland loading, tectonic inversion, and development of a foreland basin. Terrestrial sediments deposited in the foreland basin make up the bulk of the Bowen Basin infill, and they contain several economically important coal deposits (Fielding et al., 1990; Fergusson, 1991; Holcombe et al., 1997; Esterle et al., 2002).
Geology of the Mt. Carlton Deposit
The basement unit at Mt. Carlton is a granite belonging to the Urannah batholith (~302–296 Ma; I. Corral, unpub. data, 2018). The batholith contains several high-temperature, I-type granites (Allen et al., 1998; Donchak et al., 2013). The granite at Mt. Carlton is a fine-to medium-grained monzogranite, containing equigranular quartz, alkali feldspar, plagioclase, biotite, and hornblende (unit 1; Figs. 4, 5, 6A, 7A). The granite basement unit is overlain by a volcanosedimentary sequence belonging to the Lizzie Creek Volcanic Group (units 2–8, Fig. 4; ~288–275 Ma; I. Corral, unpub. data, 2018).
Near the Mt. Carlton mine, the basal unit of the Lizzie Creek sequence is a ~300-m thick andesite unit (unit 2; Figs. 4, 7). The rocks comprise fine-grained plagioclase-pyroxene ± hornblende phyric andesite, and minor monomict autoclastic andesite breccia.
Overlying unit 2 is up to 200 m of massive and locally flow banded quartz-feldspar phyric rhyodacite, and minor monomict autoclastic quartz-feldspar phyric rhyodacite breccia (unit 3; Figs. 4, 5, 6B, C, 7). Unit 3 is affected by silicic and quartz-alunite alteration and hosts mineralization in the V2 pit.
An up to 100-m-thick unit of dacitic to rhyodacitic tuffs and sediments (unit 4; Figs. 4, 5, 7) overlies unit 3. Unit 4 has been subdivided into a lower unit (unit 4A) and an upper unit (unit 4B). Unit 4A comprises well-bedded, fragmental rhyodacite lapilli tuffs with interbedded carbonaceous lacustrine sediments, locally containing fossilized wood (Figs. 4, 5, 6D, 7). This unit occurs in both pits and hosts mineralization in the A39 pit. Unit 4B overlies unit 4A in the V2 pit and comprises massively bedded dacitic tuffs (Figs. 4, 5, 7).
Overlying unit 4 is a unit, up to 150 m thick, that contains dacitic and andesitic volcaniclastic rocks (unit 5; Figs. 4, 5, 7). These rocks show variable facies throughout the two pits and include dacitic ignimbrite (unit 5A), coarse volcanic conglomerate (unit 5B), and fragmental dacite breccia (unit 5C; Fig. 6E).
Unit 7 is an up to 150-m-thick sequence of volcanosedimentary rocks that overlies unit 6 (Figs. 4, 5, 6F, 7). The rocks comprise andesitic to dacitic volcaniclastic breccias and volcanic sediments. The latter include water-laid, graded sandstone-silt-stone beds, coal-bearing laminated mudstones with tuffaceous interbeds, and moderately to well-sorted, monomict to polymict fluvial conglomerates that locally contain clasts of hydrothermally altered granite and volcanic rocks (Fig. 6G). Porphyritic andesitic to dacitic lavas are locally present within unit 7 and occur in the northwest wall of the A39 pit (Figs. 4, 5, 7).
The youngest stratigraphic unit in the Mt. Carlton area, unit 8, comprises flow-banded rhyolites that conformably overlie units 1 to 7 throughout the district (Coughlin, 1995). The rocks contain aligned phenocrysts of lath-shaped plagioclase and alkali feldspar, and rare quartz, within an aphanitic, burgundy-red groundmass (Fig. 4). Unit 8 is exposed as a semihorizontal sheet along the hilltops to the south of the open pits.
In the north wall of the V2 pit, unit 3 is crosscut by a younger dacitic to rhyodacitic volcanic vent (~25 m wide; Figs. 4, 5, 6C). This unit, here called unit 9, exhibits at least two distinct vent facies, including porphyritic, rhyodacitic lava with well-developed columnar jointing in the center and weakly layered, boulder-rich, tuffaceous, dacitic rocks along the margins.
A deformation sequence for the Mt. Carlton deposit has been established by structural mapping of the open pits and regional outcrops, coupled with analysis of drill core structural data. The Mt. Carlton deposit has undergone seven stages of extensional deformation and dike emplacement (herein called D1-D7), while no evidence for compressional deformation has been observed. The spatial distribution of stratigraphic units, hydrothermal alteration, and mineralization at Mt. Carlton is intimately linked to this deformation sequence, which can be summarized as follows:
D1: The D1 event constituted rifting and associated high-angle normal faulting in response to both E-W and N-S extension. The D1 rifting event was initiated during the deposition of unit 2, was most intense during the deposition of units 3 and 4, and was waning during the deposition of the younger stratigraphic units (units 5–8). The D1 normal faults exposed in the pits facilitated displacements on the order of tens of meters and include synsedimentary growth faults that were active during the deposition of volcanic sediments in localized half-graben and graben basins. Locally, such half-grabens infilled with Lizzie Creek volcanic rocks are bounded by D1 faults that also host mineralization (Fig. 8A, B). Hydrothermal enargite, pyrite, and dickite that grew along such faults define mineral lineations that record a normal component of shear (Fig. 8C, D). Hydrothermal alteration and epithermal mineralization, thus, occurred partly contemporaneously with rifting and deposition of volcanic sediments during the earlier stages of D1, with rifting and sedimentation outlasting mineralization.
D2: Continued E-W extension resulted in the development of 1-to 5-m-wide, low-angle (and locally layer-parallel) fault zones and associated, high-angle antithetic normal faults (Figs. 5, 6F, 7). Within the pit area, the D2 low-angle faults accommodated a top-to-the-east displacement along a broadly E-W axis, and they have truncated the stratigraphy, the hydrothermal alteration halo, and the ore zones (Figs. 5, 6F, 7). Major throughgoing D2 structures, with potential displacements of hundreds of meters, appear to be restricted to the younger stratigraphic units (i.e., unit 6 and above) that blanket the regional horst-and-graben topography created during D1. Where the D2 low-angle faults affect the lower parts of the stratigraphy, as can be seen in drill core, including the mineralized units 3 and 4A, the faults are relatively narrow (<0.8 m), and correlations between drill core indicate that displacements along these structures are smaller and more localized. The volcanic vent, unit 9, crosscuts D2 faults in the V2 pit.
D3: The D3 event involved high-angle normal faulting in response to N-S extension, with partial reactivation of D1 and D2 faults. Based on the regional distribution of lithological units in the area (with basement granite to the north and a progressively thicker volcanosedimentary pile to the south), the overall sense of movement related to D3 faults around the V2 and A39 pits was probably south-down, resulting in a shallow, southerly tilt of the layering.
D4: The D4 event comprised block rotation of kilometer-scale lithological domains across steep, NNW-trending normal faults and ENE-trending cross faults. An NNW-trending D4 normal fault cuts across the entire stratigraphic pile and passes between the V2 and A39 pits (Fig. 5). This has caused segmentation of the stratigraphy and the ore zones within the Mt. Carlton deposit, as well as a reorientation of primary layering and mineralization. Bedding planes in the northeast fault block, which includes the V2 pit, have remained nearhorizontal after the D4 event. In contrast, bedding planes in the southwest fault block, which includes the A39 pit, have been rotated in a west-southwest direction by ~32° (Fig. 5B).
D5: The D5 event constituted the emplacement of basaltic dikes along high-angle D1, D3, and D4 faults and, to a lesser degree, along low-angle D2 faults (Fig. 6H). The dikes associated with the D5 event contain fine-grained plagioclase, pyroxene, and hornblende phenocrysts in a tan to dark green groundmass, showing a distinct “salt and pepper” texture.
D6: The D6 event involved strike-slip faulting along the margins of D5 dikes (Fig. 6H). The movement was dominantly dextral, but sinistral movement has also been observed, indicating a long and multistaged history of unknown age. The amount of displacement in the pit area during D6 events was minor (less than 20 m).
D7: The D7 event comprised the emplacement of WNW-trending basaltic dikes. The D7 dikes exhibit a black aphanitic groundmass containing medium-grained plagioclase phenocrysts and quartz amygdales.
The mineralogy and zonation of alteration at Mt. Carlton was studied by drill core logging, open-pit mapping, transmitted polarized light microscopy, short-wave infrared (SWIR) spectroscopy, and powder X-ray diffraction (XRD). The SWIR analyses were made in situ on surface and drill core samples using a portable infrared mineral analyzer (PIMA) device, and data processing was done using the software “The Spectral Geologist” (TSG). The SWIR data collected in this study was complemented with an existing database of drill core SWIR data provided by Evolution Mining. This data was obtained using an ASD TerraSpec instrument and processed using TSG. The XRD analyses were performed using a PANalytical X’pert PRO automated diffractometer housed at the Swedish Museum of Natural History in Stockholm, and mineral identification was done using the Highscore Plus software. These studies have resulted in the identification of five distinct alteration zones.
Silicic alteration zone
Silicic alteration occurs as multiple cores (~10–100 m wide) that formed in and around D1 high-angle structures in units 3 and 4A (Fig. 7). The silicic alteration zones are characterized by almost complete replacement of the original rock by microcrystalline quartz, which has produced a very hard residual rock. Silicic alteration has largely destroyed primary volcanic and sedimentary textures, such that, in general, only quartz phenocrysts are preserved. The texture of silicic alteration is predominantly massive, but vuggy textures and silicic hydrothermal breccias are developed locally. The silicic alteration zones contain small amounts of alunite, pyrite, dickite, kaolinite, aluminum-phosphate-sulfate (APS) minerals, and pyrophyllite (Fig. 9). Pyrite occurs as disseminations in the quartz groundmass, while the sulfate and clay minerals are mainly developed in vugs or as infill in hydrothermal breccia (Fig. 10A). The presence of pyrophyllite was only identifiable using SWIR and XRD techniques. The silicic alteration zones locally contain aggregates of tabular anhydrite, which are developed within small fractures (Fig. 10B). Most of the anhydrite has been dissolved, which has left behind a prominent cast texture in the rock (Fig. 10C). The silicic alteration zones also locally contain alunite veins (Fig. 9). These veins are up to ~20 cm wide and made up of banded, plumose alunite without sulfides (Fig. 10D). Based on textural observations in thin section, some alunite veins are synchronous with silicic alteration, whereas others postdate it. The presence of alunite veins is largely concentrated to the V2 pit; however, they have been observed locally in the A39 pit too. Many alunite veins were reopened by later mineralized veins (Fig. 10D).
Quartz-alunite alteration zone
A quartz-alunite alteration zone defines a ~100- to 300-m-wide envelope to the silicic alteration zones in units 3 and 4A, with a gradational transition between the two zones (Fig. 7). Quartz-alunite alteration is not as pervasively developed as the silicic alteration, such that primary rock textures are generally preserved. A groundmass of microcrystalline quartz contains disseminated alunite and locally pyrite, dickite, and kaolinite, and, more rarely, barite and rutile (Figs. 9, 10E). Alunite and clay minerals have also replaced preexisting feldspar crystals (Fig. 10E).
Quartz-dickite-kaolinite alteration zone
A quartz-dickite-kaolinite alteration zone occurs as a laterally extensive (>1-km-wide) halo to the silicic and quartz-alunite alteration zones in units 3 and 4A (Fig. 7). Quartz-dickite-kaolinite alteration produced a whitish- to gray-colored rock that typically preserves primary volcanic and sedimentary textures. A groundmass of microcrystalline quartz contains disseminated dickite, kaolinite and, locally, pyrite (Fig. 9). Dickite and kaolinite have also replaced preexisting feldspar crystals (Fig. 10F). The amount of quartz decreases away from the controlling structures, such that dickite-kaolinite altered rocks are relatively soft and friable in distal locations. Kaolinite-pyrite alteration is also locally present within unit 9 (Fig. 6C).
Illite-montmorillonite alteration zone
The zoned alteration halo developed in unit 3 and unit 4A (silicic → quartz-alunite → quartz-dickite-kaolinite) shows sharp transitions with respect to mineralogy across sheared (D2) contacts to the units overlying and underlying it, which include units 2, 5, and 6 and parts of unit 4 (Fig. 7). Illite-montmorillonite alteration is pervasive in rocks above and below the fault-bounded ore zones (Figs. 7, 9, 10G). These peripheral rocks are very friable and poorly preserved, due to the swelling properties of the clay minerals. In addition to illite and montmorillonite, these distal rocks locally exhibit red hematite dusting. Syntectonic gypsum veins with well-developed shear fabrics occur near the major D2 faults within the illite-montmorillonite alteration zones.
Chlorite-illite alteration zone
The illite-montmorillonite alteration zone transitions downward to a chlorite-illite alteration zone (Figs. 7A, 9). This transition is sharp and is again controlled by a D2 fault along the contact between unit 2 and the granite basement. Chlorite-illite alteration occurs as green veinlets that crosscut the primary granitic texture (Fig. 10H). Chlorite and illite have also replaced preexisting feldspar, hornblende, and biotite crystals.
Timing of the alteration assemblages
The zoned alteration halo present within unit 3 and unit 4A (silicic → quartz-alunite → quartz-dickite-kaolinite) is interpreted to be directly linked to the mineralizing hydrothermal event at Mt. Carlton, based on its close spatial relationship with mineralization, and also based on comparisons to other high-sulfidation deposits (e.g., Steven and Ratté, 1960; Stoffregen, 1987; Arribas, 1995a; Hedenquist et al., 2000). In contrast, the illite-montmorillonite alteration is partly developed in units that were deposited after mineralization (Figs. 7, 8) and shows no obvious zonation. Therefore, we interpret this alteration assemblage to have developed regionally during D2 deformation. Chlorite-illite alteration of the granite basement was most likely related to the mineralizing hydrothermal event. This is based on the presence of chlorite-illite altered granite clasts in conglomerates within unit 7, which predates D2 deformation.
The presence of pyrite together with kaolinite in unit 9 implies a hypogene origin for kaolinite alteration. Because unit 9 crosscuts both the primary hydrothermal alteration halo and D2 faults in unit 3, a later hydrothermal alteration event (likely occurring concomitantly with the emplacement of the volcanic vent itself) is inferred to have overprinted the earlier alteration halo in unit 3. This late-stage alteration appears to be confined to within and proximal to unit 9 (Fig. 6C).
The ore geometry, metal zonation, and mineral paragenesis at Mt. Carlton was studied by open-pit mapping, drill core logging, modeling of drill core assay data using Leapfrog, whole-rock geochemical analyses, reflected polarized light microscopy, and reconnaissance scanning electron microscopy with an energy dispersive scanning system (SEM-EDS).
Ore geometry and metal zonation
On a local scale (1–10 m), proximal Au-Cu mineralization in the V2 pit occurs in moderately to steeply (~60°–90°) dipping D1 fracture networks within the rhyodacite porphyry (unit 3). The mineralized fractures have a predominantly northeast to north-northeast trend, with NW-to E-trending fractures being secondary. Hydrothermal breccias infilled with ore minerals are locally developed along intersection lines between mineralized fractures (Fig. 11A). At a scale of hundreds of meters, three distinct ore zones can be identified in the V2 pit (Western, Eastern, and Link ore zones; Fig. 3). These ore zones line up in an en echelon fashion along a broadly E trending corridor, and all have grade envelopes that trend southwest. The Eastern and Link ore zones terminate in the V2 pit, while the Western ore zone extends to the southwest and can be traced into the A39 pit across a D4 fault. Along strike of the ~600 m of known mineralization, the Western ore zone shows a distinct metal zonation, from proximal to distal, of Au-Cu → Cu-Zn-Pb-Ag → Ag-Pb-(Cu) → Ag (Figs. 3, 7). Distal Ag mineralization is concentrated in the A39 pit, where it occurs in the volcanolacustrine sediments (unit 4A) that overlie the rhyodacite porphyry. Pit mapping in combination with the analysis of structural and stratigraphic data in drill core reveal that mineralization in A39 occurs in a stratabound position oriented parallel to primary sedimentary layering. Furthermore, mineralization in A39 is distributed parallel to the lineation defined by the intersection between the sedimentary bedding planes in unit 4A and the mineralized feeder structures in the underlying unit 3.
The high-grade ore and associated hydrothermal alteration halo within the Western ore zone has been dismembered by an NNW-trending D4 normal fault that is positioned between the two open pits (Figs. 3, 5B, 7A). Due to the rotation of the southwest fault block that contains A39, the originally subhorizontal Ag ore in A39 now plunges to the southwest (Figs. 3, 5B, 7A). The feeder system in V2 occurs essentially in its original, steep orientation, since the rotation of the northeast fault block was negligible (Fig. 5B).
The zoned hydrothermal alteration assemblages in units 3 and 4A (stage 1; Fig. 9) are crosscut by three stages of epithermal mineralization (stages 2A-C). The ores were, in turn, overprinted by a late stage of dickite and pyrite void fill (stage 3). Following D2 deformation and associated alteration (stage 4), a final stage of supergene oxidation (stage 5) locally overprinted the mineralized rocks. Because the paragenetic sequence is identical in V2 and A39, we infer that the now segmented Western ore zone originally formed as a single hydrothermal system. Both stage 2A and stage 2B mineralization contain high-grade Au (locally >600 ppm; Table 1) and Ag, as well as variable amounts of base metals (e.g., Cu, Zn, and Pb) and rare metals (e.g., Ge, Ga, In, Te, Se, Sn). The deposit-scale metal zonation shown in Figure 3 is caused in part by the temporal zonation of metals through stages 2A to C (Fig. 9), and in part by the spatial zonation of metals within each individual stage (Table 1).
Cu-Au-Ag mineralization (stage 2A)
Stage 2A was the initial and most voluminous mineralization event at Mt. Carlton and developed in all three ore zones. It produced a high-sulfidation-state ore mineral assemblage dominated by massive enargite, and mineralization was associated with silicic alteration of the wall rocks (Figs. 9, 11A). The first minerals to crystallize in the stage 2A assemblage were tetrahedrite-group minerals. These occur as up to ~100-μm-diameter, subhedral crystals that are zoned in backscattered electron (BSE) images (Fig. 12A). The tetrahedrite-group minerals are overprinted by silver minerals (Fig. 12A), which include minerals of the pearceite-polybasite group ([Ag9CuS4] [(Ag,Cu)6(As,Sb)2S7]-[Ag9CuS4][(Ag,Cu)6(Sb,As)2S7]) and Ag4TeSe—a not fully characterized analogue to aguilarite (Ag4SeS) and cervelleite (Ag4TeS). The tetrahedrite-group minerals and silver minerals were, in turn, overprinted by the main enargite assemblage, which includes pyrite and luzonite and, to a lesser degree, electrum, sphalerite, galena, chalcopyrite, bornite, and argyrodite (Ag8GeS6; Figs. 9, 12A-C). The electrum occurs as up to ~100-μm-diameter, anhedral to subhedral grains intergrown with massive enargite and quartz (Fig. 12C). Barite is a common gangue mineral in the stage 2A assemblage, and it is predominantly concentrated in the distal parts of the deposit (A39 pit). This is similar to barite documented at the Lepanto high-sulfidation deposit (Mankayan, Philippines; Gonzalez, 1959).
Zn-Pb-Au-Ag mineralization (stage 2B)
Stage 2B ore mainly occurs in veins that cut across stage 2A mineralization, predominantly within the Western ore zone (Fig. 11B). The textures of stage 2B veins range from massive to colloform, and the mineral assemblages are dominated by Fe-poor sphalerite. Subordinate minerals include galena and pyrite and, to a lesser degree, electrum, tetrahedrite-group minerals, chalcopyrite, bornite, an uncharacterized Zn-In mineral (ideally CuZn2[In,Ga]S4; Sahlström et al., 2017b), and barite (Fig. 9). Electrum in stage 2B occurs as up to ~75-μm-diameter, anhedral grains intergrown with massive sphalerite, pyrite, and bornite (Fig. 12D). Two types of tetrahedrite-group minerals are present in this stage. The first type occurs as up to ~10-μm-diameter segregations within galena (Fig. 12E). The second type occurs as up to ~100-μm-diameter, subhedral crystals intergrown with pyrite, sphalerite, and galena. These crystals are zoned in BSE images, with BSE-bright cores that also contain fine inclusions of galena and oscillatory-zoned rims of BSE-darker material (Fig. 12F).
Cu-Au-Ag mineralization (stage 2C)
Stage 2C was a minor event that overprinted stage 2B mineralization. Evidence for it has only been observed at a microscopic scale within the Western ore zone (Fig. 12G, H). The mineral assemblage is dominated by massive tennantite, recognized by a greenish color and abundant red internal reflections under the optical microscope. The massive tennantite hosts a variety of subordinate minerals, including luzonite, chalcopyrite, and galena and, to a lesser degree, electrum and aggregates of intergrown hessite (Ag2Te) and petzite (Ag3AuTe2; Fig. 9).
Hydrothermal void fill (stage 3)
Supergene oxidation (stage 5)
Minor supergene oxidation affected the upper ~50 m of the present-day deposit, with an irregular distribution. Indeed, the discovery outcrop of the Mt. Carlton deposit (Silver Hill) was a gossan developed on veins of stage 2A sulfosalt mineralization containing over 1,000 g/t Ag (M. Obiri-Yeboah, pers. commun., 2017). Secondary covellite, chalcocite, and malachite are locally developed on Cu-bearing minerals such as enargite, luzonite, and bornite, particularly along fractures in the minerals (Figs. 11D, 12E). Supergene oxidation is limited at Mt. Carlton (~1–5 % of total ore), and the vast majority of the metals are hosted in primary and refractory ores.
Sedimentary ore textures
The structurally controlled veins and hydrothermal breccias that host proximal Au-Cu mineralization in the V2 pit (Fig. 11A, B) are texturally distinct from the distal, stratabound Ag mineralization that occurs in the A39 pit and in the southwest corner of the V2 pit. A selection of ore textures from A39 are shown in Figure 13. In Figure 13A, a D1-related fracture that first developed within a silicic altered rhyodacite tuff (unit 4A) has been infilled with hydrothermal sediments made up of finely laminated quartz. Fine particles of pyrite occur within the siliceous sediments, which are interlayered with massive layers of stage 3 dickite and pyrite. Soft-sediment deformation textures were produced as breccia fragments of the wall rock dropped into the open fracture zone as it was being infilled.
Figure 13B shows a similar fracture within unit 4A that has been infilled with a complex sequence of detrital sediments. The sediments preserve graded bedding and comprise beds of finely laminated siltstone, as well as coarser sandstone beds that are made up of igneous quartz crystals, rhyodacite fragments, and pyrite. Several steep, synsedimentary normal faults can be observed within the laminated siltstone in the lower part of the fracture opening. Soft-sediment deformation textures were produced by coarse fragments of the rhyodacite wall rock that dropped into the open fracture during infill. The sedimentary sequence was at one point infiltrated by a hydrothermal fluid, and the paleofluid channel can be seen cutting across the laminated sediments in the lower part of the fracture cavity. The hydrothermal fluid migrated vertically through the sediments, likely within one of the steep normal faults, and then dispersed laterally when it intersected a thick layer of sandstone. The fluid disturbed this sandstone layer as well as the overlying siltstone beds, which created a distinct topography within the fracture. Some quartz and pyrite crystals in the sandstone layer can be seen to have dropped down through the fluid channel and accumulated at the base of the open fracture. Subsequently, younger beds of siltstone and sandstone progressively draped the topography that was created by the hydrothermal fluid, as the open cavity along the fracture was infilled with sediment.
The fracture shown in Figure 13C contains three distinct sedimentary domains. The basal infill within the fracture is predominantly made up of stage 2A enargite mineralization, along with minor amounts of quartz. The enargite-rich layer is overlain by light-colored siliceous sediments, which exhibit intricate cross-laminations. Soft-sediment deformation textures are visible along the contact between the two layers. The laminated siliceous sediments are, in turn, overlain by darker-colored quartz sediments that lack laminations. Clasts of enargite ore have been remobilized into these sediments, and the entire sedimentary sequence was subsequently crosscut and brecciated by younger veinlets of stage 3 dickite and pyrite.
Figure 13D shows coarse-grained spherules, made up of concentric rings of fibrous and radial stage 3 pyrite and dickite, which form layers within a volcanolacustrine sediment (unit 4A). Equivalent but finer-grained pyrite-dickite spherules have been observed occurring as infill within restricted open spaces in fractures.
Overall, the four examples shown in Figure 13 highlight how metal deposition in A39 occurred partly contemporaneously with sedimentation and deformation. The significance of these sedimentary textures with respect to the potential of the hydrothermal system to reach the paleosurface at the time of mineralization is discussed below.
The major element compositions of Cu sulfosalts, electrum, alunite, and APS minerals were analyzed by wavelength dispersive X-ray spectrometry (WDS). The analyses were carried out using a JEOL JXA8200 Superprobe housed at the Advanced Analytical Centre (AAC) at James Cook University (see Digital Appendix 1 for details on analytical conditions).
Analysis of the SWIR spectra of alunite provides an alternative method to estimate the composition of the mineral (Chang et al., 2011). Specifically, the wavelength position of the absorption peak at ~1,480 nm (range 1,478–1,495 nm) in the alunite SWIR spectra will vary depending on the Na/(Ka + Na) mole ratio. An increasing Na/(Ka + Na) ratio in alunite will shift the peak to the higher wavelength positions (Chang et al., 2011). For quantitative analysis of SWIR spectra of alunite from Mt. Carlton, only data from the Evolution database (TerraSpec) were used. This was to avoid potential interinstrument variability between the TerraSpec and PIMA devices (Chang and Yang, 2012). It should be noted that the TerraSpec data do not differentiate between disseminated alunite and vein alunite.
Enargite and luzonite
Enargite (orthorhombic) and luzonite (tetragonal) are dimorphs with the ideal formula Cu3AsS4. Luzonite forms a complete solid solution series with famatinite (tetragonal Cu3SbS4), whereas enargite generally only incorporates up to 20 mole % Sb (Springer, 1969). Analyzed enargite grains from stage 2A contain up to 18 mole % Sb (Fig. 14A, Table 2). Luzonite from the same stage contains up to 49 mole % Sb—evidence for extensive solid solution toward famatinite. Luzonite from stage 2C has a narrower compositional range and contains up to 30 mole % Sb. Enargite and luzonite carry significant amounts of Ag, with a maximum content of 1.07 wt % Ag for stage 2A enargite, 0.27 wt % Ag for stage 2A luzonite, and 0.16 wt % Ag for stage 2C luzonite (Table 2).
The tetrahedrite-group minerals have a simplified isometric formula of A12D4X13, where A = Cu, Ag, Zn, Fe, Cd, Mn, Hg; D = As, Sb, Te, Bi; and X = S, Se (Johnson et al., 1986). The analyzed compositions from Mt. Carlton predominantly vary between the end-members tennantite (Cu10[Fe,Zn]2As4S13), tetrahedrite (Cu10[Fe,Zn]2Sb4S13), and goldfieldite (Cu10Te4S13; Fig. 14B, Table 2).
The zoned crystals in the stage 2A assemblage (Fig. 12A) have bimodal compositions. The BSE-bright bands have goldfieldite-dominated compositions, whereas the BSE-dark bands have compositions intermediate between tennantite and tetrahedrite (Fig. 14B, Table 2). The two types of tetrahedrite-group minerals in the stage 2B assemblage show distinct chemical compositions. The first type, which occurs as segregations in galena (Fig. 12E), has compositions corresponding to Te-rich tennantite (Fig. 14B, Table 2). In the zoned crystals (Fig. 12F), the cores have goldfieldite-dominated compositions, whereas the oscillatory-zoned rims have variable compositions ranging from tetrahedrite to Te-rich tennantite (Fig. 14B, Table 2). The optical identification of tennantite in the stage 2C assemblage has been confirmed by WDS analyses that show tennantite-dominated compositions for this mineral (Fig. 14B, Table 2). Tennantite and tetrahedrite from Mt. Carlton have a high Zn content in the A site (up to 8.03, 8.21, and 10.73 wt % Zn for stage 2A, 2B, and 2C, respectively). Owing to stoichiometry, the Zn content in goldfieldite is much lower. The maximum Ag content in tetrahedrite-group minerals from Mt. Carlton correspond to 1.18, 0.93, and 1.17 wt % Ag for stage 2A, 2B, and 2C mineralization, respectively (Table 2).
Electrum (Au-Ag alloy) from Mt. Carlton shows similar compositions in all three ore stages (Fig. 14C, Table 2). The electrum is Au dominated, with Au contents in the ranges of 74 to 89, 66 to 96, and 72 to 73 mole % for stage 2A, 2B, and 2C mineralization, respectively. The abundance of electrum throughout the paragenetic sequence, combined with the high Au content in the mineral, suggest that it is an important Au carrier in the ores at Mt. Carlton. However, laser ablation-inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS) trace element analyses have revealed that significant Au concentrations also occur in common sulfide and sulfosalt minerals such as pyrite (up to 367 ppm), enargite (up to 62 ppm), and sphalerite (up to 75 ppm; Sahlström et al., 2017a). As of September 2017, about 18% of the total Au at Mt. Carlton is recovered in a gravity circuit, with the remainder being recovered via flotation techniques (M. Obiri-Yeboah, pers. commun., 2017).
Alunite and APS minerals
Disseminated alunite at Mt. Carlton occurs as platy euhedral crystals up to ~300 μm long, typically in aggregates (Fig. 15A-C). In BSE images the alunite crystals generally appear homogeneous (Fig. 15A) or have a patchy to oscillatory zonation (Fig. 15B, C); the latter is mainly due to variations in Na and K content. Some alunite grains from V2 contain cores of APS minerals (Fig. 15A), which were not observed in alunite grains from A39. The vein alunite shows a distinct saw-tooth compositional banding oriented parallel to the vein orientation in BSE images (Fig. 15D), again mainly due to variations in Na and K content.
Analyzed disseminated alunite and vein alunite both exhibit compositions within the alunite-natroalunite solid solution (trigonal KAl3[SO4]2[OH]6 - NaAl3[SO4]2[OH]6), and they are low in Ca (Ca/[K + Na + Ca] < 0.1; Fig. 15E). Many analyses are dominated by K, with only a minority of the analyses plotting in the natroalunite field (Fig. 15E). Since WDS analysis of alunite-group minerals requires a large beam size (e.g., 15 μm; Deyell et al., 2005b), we were not able to analyze APS minerals directly. The compositions shown in Figure 15F represent mixed analyses of alunite and APS minerals. The data indicate a trend from alunite/natroalunite toward compositions within the woodhouseite-svanbergite solid solution (trigonal CaAl3[SO4][PO4][OH]6 - SrAl3[SO4][PO4][OH]6), with woodhouseite dominating over svanbergite.
The SWIR data for Mt. Carlton show that the ~1,480-nm absorption peak in alunite spectra occur in the wavelength range of 1,478 to 1,485 nm for most of the data (Fig. 16). This suggests that the alunite has K-dominated compositions, which corroborates the results from the WDS analyses. Furthermore, the SWIR data for alunite show a spatial zonation across the area around the open pits. The ~1,480-nm peak is shifted to the higher-wavelength positions—i.e., the alunite is increasingly Na rich—to the northeast (Fig. 16).
Alunite formed during hydrothermal alteration at Mt. Carlton was dated using 40Ar/39Ar geochronology. Optically pure mineral separates (110–300-μm-diameter crystals) of disseminated alunite (stage 1A; Fig. 9) and vein alunite (stage 1B) from the V2 and A39 pits were handpicked from crushed samples under a stereomicroscope. The alunite separates were irradiated with fast neutrons at the McMaster Nuclear Reactor at McMaster University, Canada, and subsequently analyzed for 40Ar/39Ar at the Argon Geochronology Laboratory at the University of Michigan, USA. The samples were step-heated using a continuous 5-W Ar-ion laser and Ar isotopes were measured in a VG-1200S mass spectrometer, following the procedure described in Frey et al. (2007) and Rooney et al. (2013).
Calculated final ages from 40Ar/39Ar spectra of disseminated alunite (n = 4, using 2σ for error) are 277.4 ± 5.8 Ma for sample HC07RCD300-136, 276.9 ± 6.5 Ma for sample HC09DD023-112, 279.3 ± 6.9 Ma for sample HC14DD1133-178, and 265.1 ± 6.6 for sample MCR024D-177 (Table 3, Appendix 1). Calculated final ages for vein alunite (n = 2) are 284.3 ± 6.0 Ma for sample MCR024D-148 and 284.2 ± 7.0 Ma for sample HC09DD037-34 (Table 3, Appendix 1).
The alteration mineralogy (e.g., alunite, dickite, kaolinite, pyrophyllite, APS minerals) as well as the alteration zonation (silicic core → quartz-alunite → quartz-dickite-kaolinite) at Mt. Carlton are consistent with highly acidic hydrothermal fluids leaching the volcanic host rocks, with decreasing intensity away from the fluid conduits. These features are characteristic of high-sulfidation deposits worldwide (e.g., Steven and Ratté, 1960; Stoffregen, 1987; Arribas, 1995a). The high-sulfidation-state ore mineral assemblage dominated by enargite further supports the interpretation that Mt. Carlton is a high-sulfidation epithermal deposit (e.g., Hedenquist, 1987; Sillitoe, 1993; Hedenquist and Lowenstern, 1994; Arribas, 1995a; Einaudi et al., 2003). This identification has implications for exploration in the district, as Mt. Carlton is likely to have formed as part of a larger magmatic-hydrothermal mineralizing system, centered on an underlying porphyry intrusion that could be mineralized with Cu, Au, and/or Mo (Arribas et al., 1995b; Hedenquist et al., 1998; Sillitoe, 2010; Chang et al., 2011).
Age of the Mt. Carlton deposit
The U-Pb zircon ages of the volcanic rocks that host mineralization (unit 3, 281 ± 4 to 277 ± 3 Ma; I. Corral, unpub. data, 2018) and of those that crosscut mineralization (unit 9; 266 ± 3 Ma; I. Corral, unpub. data, 2018) provide upper and lower constraints on the age of the Mt. Carlton deposit. The age range yielded from 40Ar/39Ar spectra of five out of the dated alunite separates (284 ± 7 to 277 ± 7 Ma; Table 3) overlaps within error with the U-Pb zircon age of unit 3. These results suggest that hydrothermal alteration and epithermal mineralization at Mt. Carlton occurred shortly (no more than 7 m.y.) after the formation of the volcanic host rocks. This is a common feature in many documented high-sulfidation deposits (Arribas, 1995a) and confirms the geologic observations that link the formation of the Mt. Carlton deposit to the Early Permian back-arc rifting stage in the Bowen Basin. The youngest, outlier alunite age at ~265 Ma overlaps within error with the U-Pb zircon age of unit 9, and these two dated samples were collected close to each other (<100 m apart). This may suggest that the emplacement of unit 9 represented a later heating event that formed or reset alunite locally, possibly along veinlets that are not visible in the strongly altered rocks (e.g., Arribas et al., 2011).
Origin of alunite and implications for exploration
For exploration purposes, it is important to determine the origin of advanced argillic alteration in epithermal deposits, as the spatial relationship between precious and base metal mineralization and advanced argillic assemblages varies with the origin of the alteration (Sillitoe, 1993; Hedenquist et al., 2000). As the key mineral for understanding the origin of advanced argillic alteration, a distinction should be made between alunite formed from hypogene vapors and vapor condensates (magmatic-steam alunite and magmatic-hydrothermal alunite, respectively), and alunite formed from near-surface geothermal and secondary oxidation processes (steam-heated alunite and supergene alunite, respectively; Rye et al., 1992).
The coarse grain size, platy crystal habit, local Na enrichment, and presence of inner cores of APS minerals observed for disseminated alunite at Mt. Carlton point toward a magmatic-hydrothermal origin (Stoffregen and Alpers, 1987; Rye et al., 1992; Aoki et al., 1993; Arribas et al., 1995a; Itaya et al., 1996; Deyell et al., 2005a, b; Rye, 2005). Alunite of steam-heated and supergene origins instead tends to occur as porcellaneous masses of fine-grained rhombohedral (pseudocubic) crystals that lack enrichment in Na (Stoffregen and Alpers, 1987; Hedenquist et al., 2000; Deyell et al., 2005a, b). The coarse-grained, plumose, monomineralic, and compositionally banded alunite present in veins at Mt. Carlton shows a close textural resemblance to the type example of magmatic-steam alunite from Marysvale, Utah (Cunningham et al., 1984; Rye et al., 1992; Rye, 2005). The sulfur isotope systematics of disseminated alunite (positive δ34S values in alunite, negative δ34S values in coexisting pyrite; Sahlström et al., 2016) and alunite veins (δ34S values close to the total sulfur composition; Sahlström et al., 2016) further support the identification of magmatic-hydrothermal and magmatic-steam origins, respectively.
Based on the evidence from alunite, acidic hydrothermal solutions formed by the condensation of a long-standing and slowly rising magmatic vapor plume are inferred to have interacted with the volcanic host rocks to produce the laterally extensive alteration halo surrounding the Mt. Carlton deposit (e.g., Rye et al., 1992; Rye, 2005; Hedenquist and Taran, 2013). Pulses of rapidly ascending magmatic steam from the degassing magma sporadically punctuated the deposit, producing veins of magmatic-steam alunite (e.g., Rye et al., 1992; Rye, 2005). At Mt. Carlton, magmatic-steam alunite is largely confined to the high-grade D1 feeder structures. Magmatic-steam alunite has only been documented in a limited number of high-sulfidation deposits globally (Rye, 2005). However, when present, this alteration feature could be a good exploration indicator for close proximity to the paleofluid conduits and potential epithermal mineralization.
The Na content in magmatic-hydrothermal alunite may locally be dependent on variability in the Na content of the host rocks that are being altered (Deyell and Dipple, 2005). However, in most cases where the host rocks are compositionally similar, an increasing Na content in alunite can be linked to higher temperatures of deposition (Stoffregen and Cygan, 1990; Deyell and Dipple, 2005; Chang et al., 2011). In the lithocap environment, the presence of near-end-member natroalunite as well as huangite (Ca0.5Al3[SO4]2[OH]6) generally suggests high formation temperatures and proximity to the causative intrusion (Chang et al., 2011). The mostly K dominated compositions of Mt. Carlton alunite (Figs. 15E, 16), therefore, could indicate relatively low formation temperatures, implying that the Mt. Carlton lithocap formed distal to the causative intrusion. The spatial zonation in the Na content of alunite at Mt. Carlton (Fig. 16) suggests that the formation temperatures were higher in the V2 pit compared to the A39 pit.
Interpreted environment of mineralization at Mt. Carlton
The sedimentary ore textures observed in the A39 pit at Mt. Carlton (Fig. 13) are similar to those described from other high-sulfidation deposits, including Rodalquilar, Spain (Arribas et al., 1995a), Akaiwa, Japan (Arribas, 1995b), Martabe, Indonesia (Sutopo, 2013), Golden Wonder mine, Colorado (Kalliokoski and Rehn, 1987), Los Porfirios, Chile (A. Arribas, unpub. data, 2005), and Mulatos, Mexico (J. Hedenquist, pers. commun., 2017). At the Rodalquilar deposit, acidic hydrothermal fluids have dissolved the volcanic host rocks along steeply dipping fractures, which produced isolated cavities at depth (Arribas et al., 1995a). Such dissolution cavities, which locally can be more than 1 m wide, have subsequently been infilled with subhorizontally layered sediments made up of chalcedony, quartz, and Au-rich sulfides. The siliceous sediments at Rodalquilar locally exhibit intricate cross-laminations and slumping textures, and they are commonly thicker on the bottom than on the sides of the cavities, due to gravitational infilling (Arribas et al., 1995a). These morphological features suggest that the sediments were precipitated from a hydrothermal fluid as amorphous silica, which later recrystallized to chalcedony and quartz (Fournier, 1985; Arribas et al., 1995a). Furthermore, a basal layer of igneous quartz phenocrysts was observed in some of the larger cavities. Such quartz layers were interpreted to have formed after the complete dissolution of all rock components except quartz, which accumulated at the bottom of the cavity (Arribas et al., 1995a). At the Los Porfirios deposit, dissolution cavities are partially infilled with sedimentary layers of quartz intercalated with barite, and silica speleothems (flowstones) were deposited locally along the cavity walls (A. Arribas, unpub. data, 2005). Sedimentary infill in similar cavities at the Akaiwa deposit comprises laminated quartz as well as discrete layers of barite and other hydrothermal minerals (e.g., alunite, kaolinite, dickite, and sulfides; Arribas, 1995b). These cavities were interpreted as pipes that composed the roots of overlying crater lakes (Arribas, 1995b).
At Mt. Carlton, mineralized sediments occur as infill within open spaces such as cavities along fractures (Fig. 13A-C), but they have also been observed in the volcanolacustrine sequence (unit 4A; Fig. 13D) extending at the scale of the A39 pit. The finely laminated siliceous sediments observed at Mt. Carlton (Fig. 13A, C) are similar to the chemical sediments that accumulate in acidic lacustrine environments, such as crater lakes (Sillitoe, 2015). The spherulitic pyrite at Mt. Carlton (Fig. 13D) bears a strong resemblance to that documented in ore deposits forming in and around hydrothermal vents (e.g., Larter et al., 1981; Tufar, 1991; Vearncombe et al., 1995; Scotney et al., 2005; Xu and Scott, 2005; Badrzadeh et al., 2011). In the seafloor environment, spherulitic pyrite is believed to form by rapid crystallization with undercooling, as hot metalliferous vent fluids discharge into cold ambient seawater (Xu and Scott, 2005). The synsedimentary normal faults and breccia-related soft-sediment deformation textures observed within some infilled fracture cavities at Mt. Carlton (Fig. 13A, B) indicate that sedimentation took place during active rifting. Furthermore, the detrital nature of sediments, the graded bedding, and the draping over preexisting topography observed within some fracture fills (Fig. 13B) are inconsistent with sediments having been deposited into isolated cavities at depth (e.g., Rodalquilar; Arribas et al., 1995a). We infer that fractures such as the one shown in Figure 13B must have been open to the paleosurface, which would have allowed detrital sediments to slump into the fractures and deposit from suspension.
Based on the rift-related tectonostratigraphic setting identified at Mt. Carlton, combined with the ore textures observed, the environment of mineralization is interpreted to have included structurally controlled feeder zones of veins and hydrothermal breccias that developed within the deeper rhyodacite porphyry (represented by rocks of the V2 pit). The feeder zones focused ore fluids into an overlying volcanolacustrine sedimentary sequence, which most likely was deposited in lakes developed within localized rift basins (represented by rocks of the A39 pit). In this interpretation, the fluids locally breached the paleosurface and discharged into the lakes at the same time as the volcanolacustrine sediments were deposited, producing the observed stratabound mineralization, laminated siliceous sediments, spherulitic pyrite, and associated synsedimentary ore textures. Sediments were sporadically slumped into the fractures that composed the structural roots of the rift basins, where interaction with the ascending ore fluids produced similar textures within open spaces at depth.
Tectonic setting at Mt. Carlton and implications for exploration
Due to the shallow environment of formation and the high erosion rates in most volcanic arcs, the preservation potential of high-sulfidation deposits is generally poor, such that most known deposits are of Tertiary age or younger (Arribas, 1995a). The Paleozoic age and the exceptional preservation (including what is interpreted as mineralized paleosurface and near-surface features) of Mt. Carlton is, therefore, remarkable.
Throughout the Paleozoic and Mesozoic, the eastern margin of Australia was extensional for long durations of time, caused by rollback of the subducting plate and repeated eastward migration of the subduction system. As a result, the basement rocks in the overriding plate were extended, and back-arc basins (e.g., the Drummond Basin and the Bowen Basin) developed on top of the extending basement (e.g., Donchak et al., 2013). The structural observations at Mt. Carlton indicate that the mineralization formed along the axis of the northern Bowen Basin during the onset of the Early Permian back-arc rifting stage, consistent with the 40Ar/39Ar dating results. Prolonged extension in the Bowen Basin provided rapid burial of the Mt. Carlton deposit beneath postmineralization volcanosedimentary cover. Preservation of epithermal paleosurface features tends to be geographically confined to either extensional (commonly back-arc) regions characterized by semiarid climates and relatively low erosion rates (e.g., the Great Basin, Mexican Altiplano, Deseado Massif, and Drummond Basin) or the highly arid central Andes (Sillitoe, 2015). The preservation of the Mt. Carlton deposit is thus strongly linked to the extensional setting in which it formed.
Postmineralization extension, most notably during D2 and D4, has caused significant tectonic modification of the Mt. Carlton deposit, including rotation and segmentation of the stratigraphy and the ore zones. This deformation also has important implications for exploration for linked porphyry mineralization in the area. Assuming a similar scenario as documented at the coupled Far Southeast porphyry and Lepanto high-sulfidation deposits at Mankayan, Philippines (Arribas et al., 1995b; Hedenquist et al., 1998; Chang et al., 2011), the mineralized feeders at Mt. Carlton should theoretically extend to the causative intrusion. Based on the present-day shape of the ore zones, with mineralization occurring in predominantly NE to NNE trending fractures, and the vectors defined by the metal zonation (distal Ag-Pb-Zn to proximal Au-Cu, from southwest to northeast; Fig. 3), alunite composition (increasing Na content to the northeast; Fig. 16), and ore textures (shallow stratabound ore in the southwest, mineralized feeders in the northeast) within the Mt. Carlton deposit, the simplest assumption would be that more proximal mineralization should occur to the northeast of the current V2 pit. However, drilling and induced polarization (IP) geophysical surveys conducted at Mt. Carlton have so far been unsuccessful in detecting any high-grade extensions to the immediate northeast of the V2 pit (M. Obiri-Yeboah, pers. commun., 2017). Most likely, the low-angle normal faults that developed during D2 have cut the feeders at deeper levels (e.g., at the contacts between units 2 and 3, and between unit 2 and the granite basement). This scenario would be similar to the postmineralization detachment faulting described at the Paradise Peak high-sulfidation deposit in Nevada (Sillitoe and Lorson, 1994). The deeper parts of the feeder system as well as potential linked porphyry mineralization should, therefore, be displaced relative to the currently mined Mt. Carlton deposit. Based on the kinematics of D2 faults observed in the open pits, this displacement is expected to be to the west of Mt. Carlton. Since mineralization occurs in the deeper parts of the stratigraphy, where D2 faults are poorly developed, the amount of such displacement is most likely relatively small (e.g., on the order of tens to hundreds of meters). NNW-trending D4 normal faults, similar to the one that passes between the two open pits, also occur to the northeast of the V2 pit and to the southwest of the A39 pit, respectively. The potentially major displacement across such structures and associated block rotation add an extra layer of complexity to the development of exploration vectors in the Mt. Carlton district.
The study of the Mt. Carlton deposit highlights that shallow-level high-sulfidation epithermal mineralization can be preserved in Paleozoic settings under appropriate geodynamic conditions. We suggest that extensional segments of volcanic arcs, such as back-arc rifts, are particularly prospective for this type of mineralization. The study also highlights the need to understand the postmineralization tectonic modification of the porphyry-epithermal system in extensional settings and concerns exploration in the northern Bowen Basin and similar geologic terranes elsewhere.
This study was funded by Evolution Mining and the Geological Survey of Queensland (GSQ). It was performed as part of Fredrik Sahlström’s Ph.D. thesis, and he would like to express his gratitude for a postgraduate research scholarship from James Cook University (JCU) and for a student research grant from the Hugh E. McKinstry Fund awarded by the Society of Economic Geologists (SEG). We thank Evolution Mining for providing access to the Mt. Carlton mine and extensive exploration data sets, and the on-site staff for their assistance and fruitful discussions during field work. Franz Weis is gratefully acknowledged for performing the XRD analyses. This manuscript was significantly improved by thoughtful reviews from David Cooke, José Piquer, and one anonymous reviewer.
Fredrik Sahlström is a Ph.D. student at the Economic Geology Research Centre at James Cook University, Australia. He previously earned his B.Sc. and M.Sc. degrees from Uppsala University, Sweden, and has diverse interests in volcanology, high-temperature geochemistry, mineralogy. and ore deposits. His research has primarily focused on the genesis of the “Bastnäs-type” rare earth element deposits in central Sweden and, more recently, on various aspects of the Mt. Carlton high-sulfidation epithermal deposit in northeastern Australia.