The discussion paper raises two main concerns:

The main objective of our paper was to investigate the fluid property effects on fault-rock seal. We made a deliberate choice to demonstrate the uncertainty effects due to fluid properties, separate from the overall uncertainty of structural interpretations. The aim was therefore to show the working, which could be reapplied in other localities, rather than provide a comprehensive geological description of these already well-studied fields. However, the considerations suggested by the authors do not change the overall interpretation of our model.

The data used for this study principally consist of historic well logs...

You do not currently have access to this article.