A Landau free energy expansion has been developed in a first attempt to describe the Pm3̅m ↔ I4/mcm octahedral tilting transition in perovskite across a complete binary solid solution, CaTiO3− SrTiO3 (CST). Only two parameters, the critical temperature and the coefficient, λ4, for coupling between the order parameter and the tetragonal strain are given a composition-dependence. The best match between observed and calculated variations of the tetragonal strain as a function of temperature in CaTiO3 (CST0) and as a function of composition at room temperature is found for a model of the solid solution in which the transition is close to tricritical for the composition range CST0 to ~CST90. The change in transition character from second order (246 potential) to tricritical is accounted for by an increase in |λ4| between SrTiO3 (CST100) and ~CST90. The Landau potential is used to calculate the variations of single-crystal and bulk elastic constants through the Pm3̅m ↔ I4/mcm transition as functions of both pressure and composition. This model for the CST solid solution permits the classical softening effects of strain/order parameter coupling to be separated quantitatively from the much larger superelastic softening observed for twinned crystals of tetragonal SrTiO3 and CST. Data from the literature for relative changes of elastic properties measured at low frequencies have been rescaled to absolute values for comparison with calculated values of Young’s modulus. These appear to show that, below the temperature for domain wall pinning, some 5–10% of softening of the isotropic Young’s modulus could still be due to the effects of twin wall movements.