It is UK Government policy to dispose of higher activity radioactive waste through geological disposal into an engineered deep underground geological disposal facility (GDF; DECC, 2014). Those wastes include low-level (LLW) and intermediate-level (ILW) radioactive wastes that are very heterogeneous, containing a range of inorganic and organic materials, the latter including cellulosic items. After closure of the GDF, eventual resaturation with groundwater is expected, resulting in the development of a hyperalkaline environment due to the proposed use of a cementitious backfill. Under these high-pH conditions, cellulose is unstable and will be degraded chemically, forming a range of water-soluble, low molecular weight compounds, of which the most abundant is isosaccharinic acid (ISA). As ISA is known to form stable soluble complexes with a range of radionuclides, thereby increasing the chance of radionuclide transport, the impact of microbial metabolism on this organic substrate was investigated to help determine the role of microorganisms in moderating the transport of radionuclides from a cementitious GDF. Anaerobic biodegradation of ISA has been studied recently in high-pH cementitious ILW systems, but less work has been done under anaerobic conditions at circumneutral conditions, more representative of the geosphere surrounding a GDF. Here we report the fate of ISA in circumneutral microcosms poised under aerobic and anaerobic conditions; the latter with nitrate, Fe(III) or sulfate added as electron acceptors. Data are presented confirming the metabolism of ISA under these conditions, including the direct oxidation of ISA under aerobic and nitrate-reducing conditions and the fermentation of ISA to acetate, propionate and butyrate prior to utilization of these acids during Fe(III) and sulfate reduction. The microbial communities associated with these processes were characterized using 16S rRNA gene pyrosequencing. Methane production was also quantified in these experiments, and the added electron acceptors were shown to play a significant role in minimizing methanogenesis from ISA and its breakdown products.
It is UK Government policy to dispose of LLW and ILW radioactive waste, comprising the largest volume of radioactive waste of the national inventory, into an engineered deep underground geological disposal facility (GDF). The majority of the ILW and a small portion of the LLW containing long-lived radionuclides (DECC, 2014), will be encapsulated in grout within steel drums, and then encased in concrete in vaults excavated into a suitable geological formation. The LLW and ILW vaults will become reducing after closure of the GDF, and a hyperalkaline environment will be created when groundwater penetrates the engineered barrier system of a cement-dominated GDF.
ILW and LLW wastes are very heterogeneous, and contain substantial amounts of cellulosic material, including paper, filters and cotton. These cellulosic compounds are known to be degraded under the anoxic hyperalkaline repository conditions that are expected in situ, leading to the production of a range of soluble organic compounds (Glaus et al., 1999). During this alkaline hydrolysis, glucose units are eliminated from the cellulose chain in a stepwise process, known as a ‘peeling-reaction’ (e.g. Van Loon et al., 1999; Pavasars et al., 2003), which is initiated at the reducing end group (a reactive aldehyde carbonyl). In contrast, the β-1,4 glycosidic linkages are alkalistable and cannot be reduced (Askarieh et al., 2000). The peeling reaction competes with another abiotic reaction, the so-called ‘stopping-reaction’, which is either a chemical transformation taking place at the end of the cellulose molecule or a physical termination which takes place in highly crystalline regions (e.g. Van Loon et al., 1999; Vercammen et al., 1999; Pavasars et al., 2003). Since the reaction can be reinitiated by the so-called ‘midchain scission’, which is a random cleavage of glycosidic bonds within the polysaccharide chain, all cellulose may be degraded over prolonged timescales (Glaus and van Loon, 2008).
In cementitious pore waters, as they are expected in a GDF, isosaccharinic acid (ISA, C6H12O6) has been identified as the main product of the alkaline degradation of cellulosic material (Whistler and BeMiller, 1958; van Loon and Glaus, 1998; Glaus et al., 1999; Knill and Kennedy, 2003), supported by further results from a long-term study by Pavasars et al. (2003) and also by Glaus and van Loon (2008). In the presence of divalent cations, such as Ca2+, common in the cementitious backfill of a GDF where calcium concentrations are expected to be high, ISA binds to calcium ions to form the divalent salt Ca(ISA)2 (Vercammen et al., 1999).
Various studies have shown that ISA can also form stable soluble complexes with metals and radionuclides, including those from the lanthanide and actinide series, particularly Am(III) (Tits et al., 2005), Eu(III) (Vercammen et al., 2001; Tits et al., 2005), Ni(II) (Warwick et al., 2003), Np(IV) (Rai et al., 2003; Gaona et al., 2008), Th(IV) (Vercammen et al., 2001; Tits et al., 2005), and U(IV) (Warwick et al., 2004). Since ISA forms such strong soluble complexes with radionuclides, there is concern that ISA may increase radionuclide migration when the groundwater resaturates the GDF, thereby increasing the likelihood of transport from the engineered barrier system and through the geosphere. Conservative assumptions in modelling estimate that considerable amounts of up to 0.1 M ISA can be produced (Bradbury and Sarott, 1995), which are considered chemically stable under alkaline conditions (Bradbury and Sarott, 1995), and sorption on cement is minor (Bradbury and Sarott, 1995; Van Loon et al., 1997), increasing the interest in the potential biodegradation of ISA by subsurface microorganisms.
Recent studies have demonstrated that the geochemical conditions in a GDF may not be sufficiently harsh to prevent microbial metabolism, with a range of aerobic and anaerobic microorganisms surviving highly alkaline (up to pH 12; Rizoulis et al., 2012; Williamson et al., 2013) and/or radioactive conditions (Booth, 1987; Brown et al., 2014). Therefore microbial metabolism may have the potential to control the mobility of priority radionuclides via a range of mechanisms (reviewed in Lloyd and Macaskie, 2000), moderating their transport after GDF closure. The utilization of ISA by aerobic organisms is well known (Strand et al., 1984; Bailey, 1986), but has not been reported widely under anaerobic conditions, although a recent study has demonstrated that ISA can serve as an electron donor for anaerobic metabolism (e.g. nitrate reduction) under alkaline conditions (pH 10; Bassil et al., 2014). However, if ISA degradation processes are incomplete and ISA should escape from the alkaline near-field of a cementitious GDF, there is little information on its fate in the largely anoxic circumneutral far-field geosphere, dominated in UK groundwaters by the potential electron acceptor sulfate (Bond and Tweed, 1995). It should be noted that at pH 10 and above, sulfate reduction using a range of electron donors (Rizoulis et al., 2012), including ISA (Bassil et al., 2014) is minimal over the extended periods (several months) tested thus far.
In this study an enrichment-cultivation approach was applied to study the fate of ISA under such circumneutral conditions. Sediments from a lime workings site near Buxton (Rizoulis et al., 2012; Williamson et al., 2013) which has areas with elevated pH values and high-Ca concentrations were retrieved, consistent with those of an ILW radioactive waste disposal facility (pH ~12.5, Ca2+ ~20 mM; NDA, 2010), and is known to contain microorganisms able to degrade ISA (Bassil et al., 2014). Microcosms (pH 7) were inoculated with the lime workings site sediments, simulating conditions of the surrounding geosphere of a GDF under different possible redox conditions, using , Fe(III), or CO2 as electron acceptors. A multidisciplinary approach was adopted to elucidate the fate of ISA, including geochemical, microbiological and microscopy techniques.
Material and methods
Surface sediment samples were collected from a depth of ~20 cm, at a site contaminated by legacy lime workings at Harpur Hill, Buxton in Derbyshire, UK. The study site showed a pH ranging from c. 6.5 to 11 with high calcium and silicate concentrations, and for this study samples were collected from a marginal area and a pH of 6.8. The samples were stored in the dark at 4°C until analysis.
Ca(ISA)2 was prepared from α-lactose monohydrate and Ca(OH)2 following the protocol of Vercammen et al. (1999).
Enrichment cultures were grown by incubating a sediment inoculum (1% vol/vol) in a minimal medium containing 30 mM NaHCO3, 4.7 mM NH4Cl, 4.4 mM NaH2PO4·H2O, 1.3 mM KCl, and 0.3 ml of mineral and vitamin stock solutions (Lovley et al., 1984). The pH of the medium was adjusted to 7 with NaOH then de-aerated with a N2/CO2 (80:20) gas mixture for 30 min. Ca(ISA)2 was added to a final concentration of 1.5 mM as sole carbon source and electron donor. The medium was distributed over four different anaerobic experiments using the following terminal electron acceptors (TEAs) either 24 mM NaNO3, Fe(III) oxyhydroxide added as a slurry to a concentration of 20 mmol l−1, 12 mM Na2SO4 or ‘no added electron acceptor’ (CO2 served as the sole electron acceptor in these experiments). For each TEA three different controls were prepared in triplicate, comprising (1) a test control containing ISA, the respective TEA and an active inoculum, (2) a control with no added electron donor (no ISA) and (3) an ‘abiotic’ sterile control that contained ISA and the appropriate TEA, but was autoclaved to kill any active microorganisms. All microcosms were prepared in serum bottles sealed with butyl stoppers that were flushed with an N2/CO2 (80:20) gas mixture for 5 min prior to autoclaving and later inoculation and incubation in the dark at 20°C. Aerobic experiments were also set up the same way, using the same medium (but lacking 30 mM NaHCO3), but here the bottles were closed with a foam bung to facilitate oxygen transfer.
Samples were collected aseptically and frozen immediately at −20°C until further analysis. After microbial activity had reached a steady state, monitored by turbidity and pH, the cultures were re-subcultured into fresh medium, using a 1% (vol/vol) inoculum, and incubated for another incubation period. Data presented were obtained from this subculture of the sediment incubation experiments.
The pH of samples from the microcosms was measured with a calibrated Denver Instrument digital meter (pH 4, 7 and 12). Bacterial growth was monitored over the length of incubation by optical density (OD) measurements at 600 nm compared to a blank, containing only growth medium and Ca(ISA)2. The Ferrozine spectrophotometric assay was used to quantify Fe(II) and total Fe (after reaction with hydroxylamine) by comparison with known standards at a wavelength of 562 nm (Lovley and Phillips, 1987). In addition, light microscopy was performed on key samples to check for microbial growth under both transparent light and fluorescent light using a Zeiss Axioscope Microscope fitted with an 100x ACHROPLAN lens (No: 440081), the latter using Hoechst 33342 nucleic acid stain.
The gases oxygen and methane were analysed in the headspace of the sediment incubation experiments with an Agilent 7890A Gas Chromatograph, fitted with a 7697A headspace autosampler, connected to an Agilent 7890 Thermal Conductivity Detector (TCD). The chromatograph was equipped with a HP Molesieve column (30 m × 25 μm × 0.53 mm). The TCD was heated to 180°C and the split/splitless inlet was heated to 250°C with a backpressure of 1.36 psi and argon as carrier gas was used at a flow rate of 104 ml min−1. For analysis the autosampler was set to a constant injection of 1 ml with pressure equilibration, and a split ratio of 1:100. After injection into a loop of 1 ml volume, the sample was forwarded to the oven in an isothermal run at 50°C which took 12 min. The column flow was of 6 ml min−1 together with a reference flow at 9 ml min−1.
Sulfate, nitrate, nitrite, organic acids and ISA were analysed using ion exclusion high performance liquid chromatography (IE-HPLC), using a Dionex ICS5000 Dual Channel on Chromatograph, fitted with a Dionex AS-AP auto sampler, connected to a CD20 conductivity detector. The chromatograph was equipped with a Dionex Capillary (50 mm× 0.4 mm) AG11-HC 4 μm guard column and Dionex Capillary (250 mm× 0.4 mm) AS11-HC 4 μm analytical column. For background reduction a Dionex ACES300 Chemical Suppressor was used.
For analysis, frozen aliquots were thawed, vortexed, centrifuged and the supernatant transferred to microcentrifuge tubes at a 1:50 sample/DIW ratio. The mobile phase (eluent) comprised a gradient of concentrated KOH which was mixed with high purity water at a flow rate of 0.015 ml/min and a backpressure of 3200 psi. 0.4 μl was injected to a run that started at 1 mM KOH for 10 min, increased then to 38 mM up to minute 25 and then re-equilibrated to the initial value until 40 min.
DNA extraction and pyrosequencing
Bacterial community structure was examined by extraction of DNA from 200 μl of the sediment inoculum for the initial community and subcultured microcosms for the enrichment cultures using the MoBio PowerLyzer™ UltraClean Microbial DNA Isolation Kit (MoBio Laboratories, Inc., Carlsbad, CA, USA). PCR for amplicon pyrosequencing was performed using tagged fusion bacterial primers 27F (Lane, 1991) and 907R (Muyzer et al., 1995), targeting the V1-V5 hypervariable region of the bacterial 16S rRNA gene. Pyrosequencing PCR was performed using Roche's ‘Fast Start High Fidelity PCR system’ as described previously (Bassil et al., 2014, or Williamson et al., 2013). The pyrosequencing run was performed at the University of Manchester sequencing facility, using a Roche 454 Life Sciences GS Junior system. The 454 pyrosequencing reads were analysed using Qiime 1.8.0 release (Caporaso et al., 2010), and denoizing and chimera removal was performed in Qiime during OTU picking (at 97% sequence similarity) with usearch (Edgar, 2010). Taxonomic classification of all reads was performed in Qiime, using the Ribosomal Database Project (RDP) at 90% confidence threshold (Cole et al., 2009), while the closest GenBank match for the OTUs that contained the highest number of reads (the representative sequence for each OTU was used) was identified by Blastn nucleotide search. In addition, Qiime was used to prepare rarefaction curves for the samples.
Results and discussion
Microcosm experiments were conducted to determine the impact of a range of terminal electron accepting processes on the biodegradation of ISA at circumneutral pH as expected in the surrounding geosphere of a GDF. Results presented here focus on data collected from stable enrichment cultures that were prepared from the primary microcosms (i.e. the first subculture), with the exception of the headspace gas results that were obtained from the primary enrichment cultures. The analysis of these subcultured experiments was considered more robust, being separated from the geochemically more complex primary cultures by the biogeochemical selection pressures imposed by the highly selective media used, making the biogeochemical and microbiological data from these experiments easier to interpret. ISA degradation was recorded under all the conditions tested, ranging from the aerobic incubations (Fig. 1) to anaerobic incubations with either nitrate (Fig. 2a–c), Fe(III) (Fig. 2d–f) or sulfate (Fig. 3a–c) as electron acceptor or ‘no added electron acceptor’ (Fig. 3d–e). In all cases, ISA was not degraded in the sterile controls, confirming a microbiological mechanism.
Biodegradation of ISA commenced immediately under aerobic and nitrate-reducing conditions, while there was a time lag of about seven days in the experiments under Fe(III)-reducing and sulfate-reducing conditions. There was also pronounced ISA degradation, again after a lag period, in the ‘no added electron acceptor’ incubation, indicative of fermentation processes, in this case leading to the production of acetate, n-butyrate and minor levels of propionate and formate. After an initial lag phase ISA oxidation was complete within about 21 days under all conditions, apart from incubations with added Fe(III), where ISA was depleted after 28 days.
Under aerobic conditions, the rate of ISA degradation was consistent from the start of the incubation until almost complete depletion of all ISA in the test incubation by 14 days, while concentrations remained stable in the sterile control (Fig. 1). ISA degradation was accompanied by a drop in pH from 7 to 6 and a drop in turbidity from OD600nm = 0.42 to 0.13 (data not shown). The drop in pH is a result of equilibration with the atmosphere, which was possible since the aerobic microcosms were non-sealed. In the IC analysis no organic acids were detected, consistent with complete oxidation of ISA to CO2.
Under nitrate-reducing conditions, rapid ISA degradation was again noted until day 14, and then slowed (Fig. 2a), accompanied by a decrease in the rate of nitrate reduction, which was converted to nitrite (Fig. 2b). During this time period, about 82% of both the ISA and nitrate were removed, while only an additional 6% of these substrates were removed over the next 28 days. Incomplete ISA degradation indicated toxication due to elevated nitrite concentrations, which are considered to inhibit microbial metabolism (e.g. Shen et al., 2003). Only low amounts of the degradation product acetate were detected, along with very minor amounts of n-butyrate and propionate (Fig. 2c), indicating that ISA was degraded via denitrification to CO2 and another denitrification end-point, for example nitrogen. The pH in the denitrifying cultures remained stable, no methane was produced (Fig. 4) and, similar to the aerobic experiment, a drop in turbidity from 0.58 to 0.18 over 42 days of incubation was measured.
In the Fe(III)-reducing enrichment cultures, ISA degradation commenced after a lag phase of seven days and accelerated from day 14. Concomitantly with a decline in ISA, spectrophotometric monitoring showed Fe(II) ingrowth, without production of VFAs, indicating that Fe(III) oxyhydroxide may have been used as TEA during the first stage of oxidation of ISA (Fig. 2d and e). The pH remained stable over the whole incubation period, whilst the turbidity could not be analysed because of interference from the added Fe(III) oxyhydroxide. After c. 28 days, almost all of the ISA added had been metabolized, and ~50% of the carbon (7.2 mM of the 15.7 mM C added) was accounted for as acetate, n-butyrate and propionate (Fig. 2f), possibly reflecting fermentative pathways. However, Fe(III) was continually reduced throughout the extended time course, even when ISA was depleted, and therefore Fe(III) reduction could have been coupled to either (1) the direct oxidation of ISA (especially early on in the incubation when a slow rate of Fe(III) reduction was linked to modest ISA degradation) or (2) to the oxidation of fermentation products that formed from this substrate and were detected after 21 days of incubation, when Fe(III) reduction was maximal. A minor fraction of the carbon removed was recovered in the gas phase as methane after ISA depletion, which increased steadily to c. 14% of the headspace volume after an prolonged incubation time of 200 days (Fig. 4). The missing c. 8.1 mM C (c. 52%) may have been transformed into other carbon products and/or resulted in biomass production, which could not be detected in our analyses.
Under sulfate-reducing conditions, ISA degradation started after a lag phase of three to seven days and then continued quickly until all the ISA (2.72 mM ISA equivalent to 16.1 mM C) was consumed after about 21 days (Fig. 3a). After c. 14 days there was a strong smell of sulfide, confirming microbial sulfate-reducing activity and the experiment turned from beige to a grey/black colour which was indicative of the formation of iron-sulfide phases. This was accompanied by the steady depletion of sulfate in the cultures (Fig. 3b). About 40% of the carbon from the ISA was converted to acetate, which was metabolized after the ISA had been depleted (Fig. 3c), presumably via sulfate reduction, with another 0.85 mM sulfate reduced over this time. The pH of this sulfate-reducing experiment remained stable at c. 7, and the turbidity also fell from OD600nm = 0.49 to 0.40. Given the geochemical profiles noted in this experiment, it is likely that both ISA and fermentation products from ISA were used as electron donors for sulfate reduction. Methane was detected (2.8% of the headspace after an extended incubation period of 200 days), but at lower levels than noted in the Fe(III)-reducing cultures.
Finally, the fermentative pathways that were implied in the Fe(III)- and sulfate-reducing cultures, were explored in the no electron acceptor control experiment. Here, after an initial lag of about seven days, ISAwas degraded efficiently and depleted after about 21 days, despite the absence of an added electron acceptor (apart from the CO2 added in the headspace of the bottles). Of the c. 16.3 mM C added as ISA, about 54% (8.1 mM C) was converted into VFAs, of which 4.7 mM C was converted to acetate and 3.2 mM to n-butyrate, and smaller amounts to formate and propionate (Fig. 3e). Besides the fermentation of ISA to VFAs, larger quantities of methane were detected in comparison to all other experiments. Especially after the time point of ISA depletion, relatively high amounts of methane were formed, resulting in about 25% CH4 of the headspace volume after 96 days which increased only slightly after another 100 days of incubation by 4% (Fig. 4), even though it still represented a small fraction of the total carbon metabolized. The main metabolic driving force in this incubation was clearly fermentation, while it is possible that methanogenesis could become more pronounced after long incubation times.
Attempts were made to monitor microbial growth by quantifying changes in turbidity, used successfully in previous studies on ISA biodegradation before (e.g. Strand et al., 1986; Bassil et al., 2014), but in all experiments increases in turbidity were minimal, and in many cases fell over time, in some experiments by up to 70%. Interestingly, the turbidity of the sterile controls remained stable. Microscopic analyses, using the Hoechst 33342 dye to identify microbial cells, demonstrated that aggregates varying in size, and of up to 100 μm in diameter, formed in the microbiologically active experiments. These were surrounded by viable planktonic rod-shaped cells of ~2–4 μm long (data not shown), which were clearly external to the aggregates and floating or actively moving in the medium.
The clumping noted in these experiments makes the accurate measurement of microbial growth by turbidity impossible. However, DNA profiling experiments were used to identify key changes in the microbial communities that dominated under the biogeochemical conditions imposed. Rarefaction curves (Fig. 5a) showed a dramatic decrease in microbial diversity, from the raw sediment sample (>500 species), to the oxic samples incubated for 21 days (just over 100 species), while the anaerobic cultures contained only ~50–100 discrete gene sequences. Such a change in relative microbial abundance is common when selective conditions are imposed in microcosm experiments, for example with the addition of ISA as an electron donor, and an excess of electron acceptor, such as nitrate or Fe(III) under anoxic conditions (e.g. Thorpe et al., 2012; Williamson et al., 2013, Bassil et al., 2014). Figure 5b shows the broad phylogenetic affiliations of the organisms detected. In the sediment inoculum no single species from these broad phylogenetic groups comprised more than 3% of the sequences detected. However, after 21 days incubation under aerobic conditions, when the ISA had been degraded fully, the microbial community was dominated by a Betaproteobacterium most closely related (97% sequence match) to Hydrogenophaga palleronii (Willems et al., 1989), a Gram-negative bacterium known to use hydrogen as an energy source, and also to oxidize organics (presumably ISA in this case) with oxygen as the TEA. In contrast, bacteria implicated in ISA degradation in the nitrate-reducing cultures included close relatives to known Betaproteobacteria (>98% sequence homology), including a member of the Comamonadaceae (34% of sequences detected) and a close relative of Rhodoferax ferrireducens (15% of sequences).
The microbial community in the Fe(III)-reducing culture at 21 days was dominated by a novel organism most closely related (96% sequence match) to an uncultured organism in the Gram-positive class Clostridia (83% of genes detected). Interestingly, organisms most closely related to known Fe(III)-reducers were in low relative abundance (e.g. <1% of species affiliated with Fe(III)-reducing Geobacter species (Lovley et al., 1987; Lloyd, 2003) at 21 days. By day 50, this culture was dominated (40% of sequences) by a close relative (99% sequence similarity) to Dechlorosoma suillum, a perchlorate-reducing Betaproteobacterium. The selection for organisms not normally associated with the reduction of insoluble Fe(III) oxyhydroxide, may be due to the inclusion of the strong chelating agent ISA, in these experiments which could change dramatically the bioavailability of Fe(III), and hence the mechanism of reduction. It is also possible that Fe(III) reduction could have been linked directly to co-factor regeneration associated with fermentation of ISA.
It should be noted that the majority of the microbial community in the fermentation experiments (‘no added electron acceptor’), were also affiliated with Gram-positive Clostridia. In sharp contrast, the sulfate-reducing cultures were dominated by organisms well known to respire sulfate at neutral pH; approximately 50% of the community was affiliated with the Deltaproteobacterium Desulfovibrio idahonensis after 21 and 50 days, and the role of this organism in ISA biodegradation clearly warrants investigation.
In this study, we have confirmed that the microbial degradation of ISA occurs under a range of biogeochemical conditions at circumneutral pH, representative of the geosphere surrounding a potential GDF. In keeping with a previous study conducted at pH 10 (Bassil et al., 2014) microorganisms were shown to degrade ISA under aerobic, nitrate-, and Fe(III)-reducing conditions. However, in this study, ISA was also degraded under sulfate-reducing conditions, in sharp contrast to the high-pH system, where the diminishing energy yield under alkaline conditions prevented measurable sulfate reduction over the time-scale of the experiments. The precise mechanisms of ISA degradation in these pH 7 experimental systems clearly warrant further attention, including fermentative pathways implicated in the Fe(III)- and sulfate-reducing experiments, in addition to direct coupling of ISA oxidation to anaerobic metabolism, e.g. during nitrate reduction. Subsequent conversion of the initial ISA degradation products to methane was also confirmed in these experiments, and the addition of electron acceptors that could compete with microbially derived CO2 during methanogenesis (i.e. nitrate, Fe(III) and sulfate) had a dramatic impact on the yield of methane. The impact of a range of biogeochemical processes on the end products of ISA biodegradation is clearly an area where further research would be valuable, as is the controlling role of microbial metabolism on the mobility of priority radionuclides during ISA metabolism, especially in sulfidic systems. Sulfate-reduction may eventually dominate in and around a GDF, as sulfate in cements and groundwaters can be present at around 9 mM in brackish saline waters, and up to 50 mM in other UK groundwaters (Metcalfe et al., 2007), resulting in the formation of poorly soluble sulfide phases that could immobilize a broad range of radionuclides.
This work was supported by the Radioactive Waste Management (RWM). We would like to thank Alastair Bewsher and Paul Lythgoe (The University of Manchester) for analytical support.