In his Discussion of the paper by Dill et al.(2007), Romer (2008) proposes an alternative explanation for U-Pb data of limonite enclosed in Pliocene torbernite. According to Romer (2008), limonite formed shortly after Carboniferous columbite and its U-Pb system was perturbed by the loss of intermediate daughters from the 238U decay series subsequent to their dislocation near to grain boundaries by α-recoil. The 206Pb/238U and 207Pb/235U ages >300 Ma are explained by U-loss in limonite during torbernite formation. In the model advocated by Romer (2008), both processes in...

First Page Preview

First page PDF preview
You do not currently have access to this article.