Mineralization and associated fluid migration events in the c. 1500 km2 North Pennine Orefield (NPO) are known to be associated with tectonic activity, but the age of these tectonic events and origins of the base metal sulfide mineralization remain unresolved. New fieldwork in the Alston Block shows that mineralization post-dates a weakly developed phase of north–south shortening consistent with far-field Variscan basin inversion during the late Carboniferous. New observations of field relationships, coupled with microstructural observations and stress inversion analyses, together with Re–Os sulfide geochronology show that the vein-hosted mineralization (apart from barium minerals) was synchronous with a phase of north–south extension and east–west shortening coeval with emplacement of the Whin Sill (c. 297–294 Ma). Thus the development of the NPO was related to an early Permian regional phase of transtensional deformation, mantle-sourced hydrothermal mineralization and magmatism in northern Britain. Previously proposed Mississippi Valley Type models, or alternatives relating mineralization to the influx of Mesozoic brines, can no longer be applied to the development of the NPO in the Alston Block. Our findings also mean that existing models for equivalent base metal sulfide fields worldwide (e.g. Zn–Pb districts of Silesia, Poland and Tennessee, USA) may need to be reassessed.
The world-famous veins and orebodies of the North Pennine Orefield (NPO) have long been considered to be archetypal examples of a Mississippi Valley Type (MVT) deposit (e.g. Halliday et al. 1990, and references therein) and have been exploited since at least the 12th century. The NPO covers an area of c. 1500 km2 and by the time mining activities ceased during the early 20th century, c. 10 × 106 tonnes of ore (Zn, Pb, Ba, Fe, Cu) had been extracted (Dunham 1944, 1990). The orefield lies at the centre of a structural high known as the Alston Block, a c. 40 km wide, fault-bounded horst (Fig. 1a). The block is bounded to the north by the Stublick–Ninety Fathom Fault system, to the south by the Lunedale–Butterknowle Fault system, and to the west by the Pennine Fault system. Although it is generally agreed that mineralization was contemporaneous with tectonic activity in conjunction with fluid migration, the age of these tectonic events and origin of sulfide mineralization remain unresolved. Here we integrate detailed field observations, palaeostress analyses of fault slickenline data and rhenium–osmium (Re–Os) geochronology and geochemistry on vein-hosted pyrite samples to constrain the style and timing of events relating to the genesis of the NPO and the structural evolution of the Alston Block and adjacent regions of northern England.
The Alston Block and the North Pennine batholith
The geological structure of northern England is dominated by features associated with basin formation during the Carboniferous. North–south Early Mississippian (c. 359–335 Ma) rifting is widely recognized (Underhill et al. 1988; Collier 1989) and is characterized by the formation of a series of fault-bounded basins and structural highs. Of these, the Alston Block separates the Northumberland Trough to the north from the Stainmore Trough to the south and is bounded to the west by the post-Carboniferous Pennine escarpment and Vale of Eden basin (Fig. 1a). The Alston Block preserves a 600 m thick sedimentary sequence of Carboniferous cyclothemic sedimentary rocks, which range in age from the Late Mississippian to Pennsylvanian (c. 335–300 Ma age). They lie unconformably upon a basement block of deformed Paleozoic sedimentary and volcanic rocks intruded by the North Pennine batholith (Dunham 1990; c. 399 Ma, Re–Os molybdenite, U–Pb chemical abrasion isotope dilution thermal ionization mass spectrometry (CA-ID-TIMS) zircon; Selby et al. 2008; Kimbell et al. 2010) (Fig. 1a and b). The erosional non-conformity that separates the North Pennine batholith and the Carboniferous strata (Dunham et al. 1961) rules out any direct genetic link between the NPO mineralization and batholith emplacement. The presence of this low-density granitic core ensured that the Alston Block was underlain by relatively buoyant crust during Early Mississippian rifting, forming a prominent fault-bounded structural high (Critchley 1984). This resulted in a Carboniferous cover sequence across the block that is relatively thin compared with those within the surrounding basins (Collier 1989; Chadwick et al. 1995). Rifting was superseded by thermal subsidence during the Late Carboniferous (Bott et al. 1984).
The effects of Late Carboniferous shortening and inversion are well documented throughout the basins surrounding the Alston Block (e.g. Shiells 1963) and have been attributed by some researchers to the far-field effects of the Variscan Orogeny (e.g. Corfield et al. 1996). However, evidence for north–south shortening within the Alston Block has proved to be elusive, leading to suggestions that the underlying North Pennine batholith acted as a shield, protecting the overlying Carboniferous cover sequence from regional compressive stresses (e.g. Critchley 1984). The most obvious evidence of Late Carboniferous inversion is preserved along the southern edge of the Alston Block where the Lunedale Fault (Fig. 1a) has been reactivated as a top-to-the north reverse fault (Cornwell and Wadge 1980; Dunham 1990). Large-scale gentle east–west elongated doming of the Carboniferous sediments, known as the Teesdale Dome (Dunham 1931), has also been interpreted to have formed during the Late Carboniferous owing to Variscan shortening (Dunham 1990).
Early Permian magmatism and the Burtreeford Disturbance
The Late Carboniferous to Early Permian was a time of widespread magmatism across NW Europe (e.g. Timmerman 2004). The main manifestation in northern England is the doleritic Whin Sill Complex (Fig.1a; Francis 1982), dated at 297.4 ± 0.4 Ma (U–Pb baddeleyite; Hamilton and Pearson 2011), which formed during a period of large-scale lithospheric extension. In northern England, the ENE–WSW-trending Holy Island and High Green dykes (Whin Sill feeder dykes) show en-echelon geometries consistent with emplacement during east–west shortening synchronous with broadly north–south extension. This correlates well with the dextral transtensional deformation documented in the Northumberland Basin during the Late Carboniferous–Early Permian, which is considered to be contemporaneous with intrusion of the Whin Sill based on cross-cutting relationships with associated mineral veins (De Paola et al. 2005a).
The Burtreeford Disturbance (Fig. 1b) is a major structural feature of the Alston Block, although, because it is rarely exposed at the surface and has been penetrated by only a very small number of mine workings, it is poorly understood in detail (Dunham 1990). It is a north–south-trending, east-facing monocline, which lies between the Tynehead and Scordale plutons and the larger Weardale pluton of the North Pennine batholith (Fig. 1b). It has an eastward downthrow of up to 150 m and has been interpreted as being active both during and after emplacement of the Whin Sill (Hill and Dunham 1968; Astle 1978; Johnson and Dunham 2001). The Burtreeford Disturbance is proposed to represent a northern continuation of the Dent Line, which is thought to be the surface manifestation of a much deeper ancient Devonian north–south wrench fault zone (Underhill et al. 1988; Woodcock and Rickards 2003). Similar structures exposed in the Lake District (Moseley 1972) are thought to be related to regional sinistral shear during the Acadian Orogeny. During Late Carboniferous–Early Permian inversion, the Dent Line underwent sinistral transpressional reactivation, forming a large monoclinal structure before finally undergoing sinistral transtension during the Early Permian (Underhill et al. 1988; Thomas and Woodcock 2015).
Mineralization of the North Pennine Orefield
The majority of mineralization within the NPO is hosted by the Carboniferous strata. Little is known of any mineralization characteristic of the NPO within the underlying Lower Paleozoic basement rocks, although narrow veins of fluorite, quartz and sulfides are observed in the Rookhope Borehole from the granite of the batholith's Weardale pluton (Dunham et al. 1965). Within the Carboniferous, the NPO deposits are hosted within and related to, if not controlled by, regional faults and fractures in four main orientations: NNW–SSE (‘Cross Veins’), NE–SW (‘Lead Veins’), ENE–WSW and WNW–ESE (‘Quarter Point veins’), with the NNW–SSE set notably lacking significant mineralization (Fig. 1a) (Dunham 1990). In addition to vein-fillings, the mineralization includes numerous strata-bound Pb–Zn–Fe replacement deposits, or ‘flats’, developed in limestone wall rocks in close proximity to mineralized faults. The deposits of the NPO are characterized by an abundance of sulfide ores, dominated by galena and sphalerite, although with local smaller concentrations of chalcopyrite, pyrite, pyrrhotite, marcasite and rare traces of bismuth, cobalt and nickel sulfides. The main gangue minerals are fluorite, quartz (of various forms), barium minerals, abundant siderite and ankerites of various compositions. Calcite, together with small amounts of aragonite, is widespread, although almost invariably in only minor amounts.
Although it is generally agreed that mineralization was contemporaneous with tectonic activity in conjunction with fluid migration, the age of these tectonic events and origin of sulfide mineralization in the NPO has remained enigmatic. A number of different techniques used to date this mineralization have yielded wide-ranging dates that vary between 290 and 149 Ma (e.g. Dunham et al. 1968; Solomon et al. 1971; Shepherd et al. 1982; Dunham 1990; Halliday et al. 1990; Davison et al. 1992). As several of the orefield's vein deposits are hosted in fractures that cross-cut parts of the Whin Sill complex, this has commonly been used to infer that mineralization postdates Whin Sill magmatism (e.g. Dunham 1934, 1990; Cann and Banks 2001). Given that large-scale faults, such as the 90-Fathom Fault System, are also known to offset both the Whin Sill complex and Permian strata (Collier 1989; De Paola et al. 2005b), this could suggest that fault reactivation, and perhaps mineralization, occurred during, or was continuous into the Mesozoic (Cann and Banks 2001).
Perhaps the most conspicuous feature of NPO mineralization is the marked zonal distribution of major constituent minerals, most notably fluorite and barium minerals. Fluorite mineralization occurs within an inner zone, centred above the three westernmost plutons of the North Pennine batholith (Weardale, Tynehead and Scordale); insufficient data exist to infer any relationships with the eastern (Rowlands Gill and Cornsay) plutons, although barium mineralization is abundantly present in several fracture systems above the latter. Barium mineralization occurs almost exclusively outside the fluorite zone (Fig. 1b) and it was this zonal pattern that guided much of the early thinking on the origins and evolution of the field and on the possible presence of a concealed granitic body (Dunham 1934).
Several genetic models have since been put forward for the age and formation of the NPO. Dunham (1983) advocated classifying the NPO as a fluoritic sub-type of the MVT, a concept developed further by Halliday et al. (1990), who suggested that metals were leached from the Carboniferous host rocks at c. 200 Ma (Early Jurassic) by circulating proximal connate fluids. This was based on a range of εNd values consistent with a Carboniferous source mineralizing at 200 Ma, with this age being derived from Rb/Sr isotopic data obtained from fluid inclusions in the Great Sulphur Vein (Fig. 1a; Shepherd et al. 1982). An unusual assemblage of magnetite, silicate minerals and ore minerals including niccolite, galena and sphalerite, associated with the NNW–SSE-trending Teesdale Fault, was interpreted by Young et al. (1985) as a skarn assemblage resulting from the interaction of metal-rich mineralizing fluids with the Whin Sill and its contact rocks very soon after the sill's emplacement and whilst still at temperatures in excess of 500°C. Crowley et al. (1997) presented isotopic evidence for the derivation of at least some of the sulfur in barite from both the NPO and northern Lake District from deeply buried Carboniferous evaporites in the Solway–Northumberland Basin.
More recently, Cann and Banks (2001) proposed an alternative model in which initial deep fluid movement in the granitic basement below the Alston Block was prevented during the Carboniferous by sealing of pre-existing cracks allowing temperatures to rise to 200°C, up to 100°C hotter than the surrounding country rocks. They hypothesized that Late Permian tectonic extension allowed saline waters from the Zechstein Sea to penetrate deep into the basement where they became heated to as much as 200°C. This led to a ‘chimney effect’, which generated concentric zones of increasing temperature fluid and mineralization in the Carboniferous host rocks centred over the batholith buried at depth. Earlier workers, notably Johnson and Dunham (1963), had also proposed a series of ‘emanative centres’ of mineralization, most notably at a triple junction of veins at Groverake Mine in Rookhope where temperatures derived from subsequent fluid inclusion results, together with rare earth element (REE) studies, gave strong support to this model (Ixer et al. 1996). In describing the Great Sulphur Vein of Alston Moor, Dunham (1990) noted that quartz-dominated mineralization gives way at depth to a zone rich in iron and minor copper sulfides and suggested that this reflected a thermal gradient in the upwelling fluids. Very similar changes to vein contents, with a marked increase in iron sulfide mineralization, have subsequently been observed at depth in recent fluorspar workings on the Quarter Point Slitt Vein at Cambokeels Mine in Weardale and similar features were observed in the deepest workings in the Quarter Point Red Vein system at Groverake Mine in Rookhope. More recently, Bouch et al. (2006) have pointed out that the inner boundary of the cooler barium zone does not coincide precisely with the outer boundary of the hotter fluorite zone and that they may represent two distinct and unrelated mineralization events. This suggestion is consistent with the observation that across the NPO the occurrences of fluorite and barium minerals are almost always mutually exclusive. Bott and Smith (2018) have shown, based on thermal conductivity and geophysical modelling, that the North Pennine batholith was unlikely to have been hot enough to generate the chimney effect proposed. Instead, they suggested that alkali magma underplating the batholith, associated with the intrusion of the Whin Sill Complex during the earliest Permian, is the only viable way to account for the observed mineralization.
Many of the uncertainties about the age and genesis of the NPO centre around the issue of the relative and absolute timings of faulting, mineralization and igneous intrusion in the Alston Block. In this paper, we combine detailed field, microstructural and geochemical analyses to address the timing and affinities of the mineralization and assess its relationship to regional magmatism of the Whin Sill Complex in northern England. The present study focuses mainly on relationships observed in the inner fluorite zone where barium minerals are absent. The genesis and structural setting of barium minerals, which are generally late in mineralization sequences outside the fluorite zone in the Alston Block, are not discussed in detail here.
Field and laboratory methods
Fieldwork concentrated on key representative localities in a number of abandoned quarries, stream sections and mine workings identified from previous studies. This work focused on the collection of orientation and kinematic data (faults and fractures, mineralized lineations and slickenlines, shear-sense criteria) and oriented samples of mineralized vein fills and fault rocks for thin section and geochemical analysis. All stereonets shown in this paper are equal-area lower-hemisphere plots.
Stress inversion analysis
Fault-slip slickenline data associated with each of the mineralized fault groups identified in the field were used to carry out a conventional palaeostress inversion analysis (Angelier 1979, 1984; Michael 1984) implemented using MyFault® software following the protocols set out by Holdsworth et al. (2015) and Dichiarante et al. (2020). Importantly, any analysis of this kind is viable only in regions where finite strains are modest and the presence of major fault block rotations can be ruled out. Owing to the small (<2 m) displacements observed along most of the mineralized structures studied, we are confident that regional strain intensities are not large enough to be problematic, and that the degree of rotational strain is negligible (e.g. De Paola et al. 2005a,25b; Dempsey et al. 2014). The use of 3D Mohr circles derived from the data additionally allows an analysis of the geometric relationships between faults and fractures measured in the field relative to the orientation and magnitude of the principal stress axes. This can be used to determine which fault and fracture orientations are most susceptible to failure under given stress and pore-fluid pressure conditions (Alaniz-Alvarez et al. 1998).
Traditionally the relative ages of different deformation events are established using cross-cutting relationships seen in the field and thin section. Although this emphasizes the deformation sequence and gives a relative age, the absolute ages of these events remain unknown in the absence of radiometric dating. Pyrite is commonly enriched with rhenium (Re) so that the 187Re–187Os geochronometer can be used to date mineralization and better constrain the timing of brittle deformation (e.g. Holdsworth et al. 2015, 2020; Dichiarante et al. 2016). Furthermore, the determined 187Os/188Os composition of the sulfide minerals at the time of formation can yield insights into the origins of the fracture-hosted fluids (e.g. Hnatyshin et al. 2015).
For this study, pyrite samples, together with one Whin Sill whole-rock sample, were collected in situ from spatially diverse veins within the Alston Block NPO (locations shown in Fig. 1b). Pyrite samples were crushed to 2 mm grain size with no metal contact and hand-picked before a final crushing to 75–200 µm. Measurement of the abundance of 187Re and 187Os in pyrite samples is obtained by isotope dilution using a mixed 185Re + 190Os tracer solution, which was calibrated against gravimetric standard solutions of normal isotopic composition. Approximately 400 mg of pyrite or 2 g of Whin Sill (previously dissolved in HF and subsequently dried down to facilitate analysis of silica-bound Re and Os) plus tracer solution was digested in a Carius tube with 8 ml of inverse aqua regiaat 220°C for 48 h. Rhenium and osmium were separated and purified by solvent extraction (CHCl3) and micro-distillation (Os) and anion exchange chromatography (Re), and analysed by negative thermal ionization mass spectrometry (NTIMS; Selby et al. 2009). Uncertainties for Re–Os isotopic data and abundances were determined by full error propagation of uncertainties in mass spectrometer measurements, blank abundances and isotopic compositions, spike calibrations, reproducibility of standard Re and Os mass spectrometric values, and weighing uncertainties. Total procedural blanks were monitored during the three batches of samples run for this study. The average blank measurements over the three batches for Re and Os were 1.7 ± 0.08 ppt and 0.06 ± 0.03 ppt, respectively, with an average 187Os/188Os value of 0.28 ± 0.03 (1σ, n = 3).
Structure of the North Pennine Orefield
The main faults, slickenline and ore vein orientations recorded during the present study are shown in Figure 2. As in previous studies, four main regionally pervasive fault orientations are observed: NE–SW (normal, tensile and dextral) (the ‘Lead Veins’ of the miners), ESE–WNW ‘Quarter Point’ (normal, tensile and sinistral), ENE–WSW ‘Quarter Point’ (dextral) and NNW–SSE ‘Cross Veins’ (tensile and dextral, locally sinistral). Field observations of cross-cutting relationships documented below show that within the NPO of the Alston Block there are at least two phases of fault initiation, here termed Phase 1 and 2. The Phase 1 NNW–SSE and NNE–SSW fractures, many of which host vein minerals, are predominantly dextral and sinistral strike-slip structures, respectively, and are associated with contemporaneous north–south tensile fractures (Fig. 2). These fractures and veins are commonly cross-cut by Phase 2 mineralized structures (Fig. 2), especially the ESE–WNW veins. There is localized evidence for a later sinistral and dextral reactivation of the NNW–SSE and NNE–SSW structures, respectively, during Phase 2. With a few local exceptions (e.g. Nenthead, South Tyne Valley), the Phase 1 structures are much less mineralized compared with Phase 2. The bulk of mineralization occurs along Phase 2 ESE–WNW (Quarter Point) and NE–SW (Lead Vein) structures, which represent the largest and most continuous features within the Alston Block. Key surface localities analysed during this study are described below. Although there are many exposures of mineralized veins within the Alston Block, the locations described here were selected based on the variety of structures exposed, how representative they are of the regional deformation history and/or their suitability for stress inversion analysis (i.e. slickenlines well preserved). A map showing the locations, structures and veins in the NPO is given in Figure 1c.
Conjugate faults and cross-cutting relationships
Bollihope Quarry [NY9853235254] (Fig. 3a) displays an exceptionally well-exposed 20 m thick sequence of flat-lying Carboniferous Great Limestone gently folded by several large (80 m wavelength) gentle to open folds with shallowly southward plunging (02/175) hinge lines (Fig. 3b). The folds are cross-cut by mineralized brittle shear fractures, but a definitive relative age relationship is not clear (Fig. 3a). Fracture-hosted mineralization within the quarry is dominated by calcite and fluorite, with minor amounts of quartz, pyrite, goethite and galena (Fig. 3c–f). There are four main fracture sets: ENE–WSW dextral, ESE–WNW sinistral, NNW–SSE dextral and NNE–SSW sinistral (Fig. 3a); where preserved, associated slickenlines are shallowly plunging to subhorizontal (Fig. 3e). Field observations show that the ENE–WSW and WNW–ESE sets are conjugate and consistently cross-cut and offset the NNW–SSE and NNE–SSW sets, which are also conjugate. These are interpreted to represent Phase 2 and Phase 1 structures, respectively. The conjugate relationships for each set are identified based on opposing senses of shear and mutually cross-cutting relationships between the fault pairs. These relationships are representative of those seen across the NPO in the Alston Block; the only exceptions occur in those cases where the Phase 1 faults are locally reactivated during Phase 2 (see below).
Quarter Point veins
The abandoned West Rigg opencut [NY9112239208] (Fig. 4a and b) is located 1 km north of the village of Westgate. The exposures here within the Carboniferous Great Limestone offer an unprecedented opportunity to view an example of the North Pennine vein systems in three dimensions (Fig. 4c–e). The quarry extracted ‘limonitic’ ironstone formed by the supergene alteration of extensive siderite and/or ankerite replacement deposits within the limestone adjacent to the Quarter Point Slitt Vein. Narrow abandoned stopes, formerly worked underground for lead ore, may be seen in the centre of the otherwise barren quartz–fluorite stockwork, which stands as a prominent rib that extends for c. 80 m through the centre of the quarry (Dunham 1990; Bevins et al. 2010). Here the vein strikes on average towards 120°, but internally contains three sets of interconnected shear planes: east–west normal faults, NW–SE sinistral faults and NE–SW dextral faults (Fig. 4b). These slip surfaces are associated with polished and striated surfaces and mineralized breccias (Fig. 4c and d) indicating that fault activity and mineralization were synchronous. The kinematics of these fault sets within the Slitt Vein suggests that the whole system represents a sinistral transtensional brittle shear zone (Fig. 4b). As with almost all NPO veins, no definitive order of mineralization is observed at this location, but large fluorite crystals are commonly overgrown by crusts of euhedral quartz crystals or siderite (Fig. 4e; Dunham 1990). The commonly euhedral forms of the crystals in the vein array suggest that the fluids were often precipitated in open voids probably as a consequence of the extensional or dilatational and relatively near-surface nature of the fault zone deformation (e.g. Woodcock et al. 2014).
The Great Sulphur Vein (GSV) is a 12 km long (at surface), broadly WNW–ESE-trending structure composed of a stockwork of numerous smaller, structurally controlled veins (Dunham 1990). It attains a maximum width of 365 m, but appears to narrow downward and may represent the root zone for the Quarter Point vein system (Bevins et al. 2010). A characteristic feature of the GSV is a marked vertical zonation in which quartz, both as pure ribs and as extensive replacements of limestone, mudstone and sandstone, dominates an upper zone, beneath which there appears to be a more or less continuous sulfide-rich zone in which abundant pyrite, marcasite and pyrrhotite are locally accompanied by chalcopyrite (Dunham 1990). Galena, sphalerite and fluorite are generally scarce, but occur in local concentrations.
A sulfide-rich portion of the GSV is exposed in the River South Tyne near Sir John's Mine at Tynehead [NY76043756]. Here the vein is hosted within the Tynebottom Limestone where metasomatism has resulted in almost complete quartz replacement in areas up to 10 m wide, indicating a significant interaction between the vein-hosted fluids and the Carboniferous wall rocks. An east–west-striking sinistral oblique normal fault exposed below a small waterfall is surrounded by a series of small subvertical veins composed mostly of quartz, with smaller amounts of pyrite and chalcopyrite. These veins range from 10 cm to 1 mm in width, with the larger veins carrying the majority of the sulfides. NE–SW veins are associated with local brecciation and cataclasis whereas associated north–south- or east–west-striking veins are dominated by mode 1 tensile opening.
Regionally, the ESE–WNW (Quarter Point) vein fractures are characterized by abrupt changes of strike. Where the orientation is ESE–WNW, as at West Rigg, they are commonly poorly mineralized or barren. Where they assume an almost east–west orientation, as at Tynehead, they typically carry wide (locally up to >10 m) mineralized orebodies. This is consistent with their sinistral transcurrent displacement, as recognized by Greenwood and Smith (1977) and was an important factor in the successful location and working of major fluorite orebodies at several mines during the twentieth century.
In the bed of the River South Tyne at Garrigill, the ENE–WSW-trending Browngill Vein [NY74364181] is exposed cutting silicified Tynebottom Limestone wall rocks (Dunham 1990). This is a typical example of one of the Lead Veins, which typically contain varying amounts of quartz, galena, pyrite, marcasite, chalcopyrite and sphalerite. The majority of the mineralization at Garrigill occurs within a series of NE–SW-trending veinlets up to 15 cm wide, which are composed primarily of quartz, galena and marcasite. Brecciation of both veins and host rocks is commonly associated with the thicker veins, with small dextral dilatational jogs well preserved along associated smaller veins with the same trend.
The Old Moss Vein is one of several NE–SW-trending veins formerly worked underground from Park Level Mine (now Killhope Lead Mining Museum). It is exposed within the Great Limestone in the bed and north bank of Killhope Burn c. 700 m upstream from the museum [NY82044334]. The vein is here up to 1 m wide and comprises NE–SW-trending bands composed of abundant galena and a little sphalerite in a matrix of dark brown partially oxidized siderite and ankerite. The limestone adjacent to both sides of the vein is replaced for up to around 2 m by dense crystalline ankerite and siderite in which small vugs, locally in bedding-parallel bands, are lined with fluorite, quartz and galena (Dunham 1990; Bevins et al. 2010). No definite sense of shear is preserved here.
The Browngill Vein seen at Garrigill can be traced for c. 5 km eastward from its junction with the NNW–SSE-trending Lee House Well Vein [NY72704140] to Nenthead. Unlike most of the NNW–SSE Phase 1 fractures across the orefield, the numerous members of this set around Nenthead are unusual both for their richly mineralized fillings and for extensive replacement deposits associated with the development of ‘flats’ in the Great Limestone. The absence of both fluorite and barium gangue minerals is a notable feature of these deposits.
Examples of these flats are well exposed in the waterfall in the River Nent [NY78644299] where original bedding, joints, stylolites and some fossils are replaced by hard crystalline ankerite and quartz with abundant galena and sphalerite and minor amounts of pyrite filling small veinlets and vugs within the altered rock. Limestones exposed in the river gorge downstream of the waterfall exhibit numerous vertical NE–SW-trending minor joints, some of which exhibit ankerite and quartz mineralization along NE–SW-trending joints (Dunham 1990; Bevins et al. 2010). The main mineralized structures exposed here are subvertical NW–SE dextral strike-slip faults. A second set of subvertical north–south-trending tensile veins filled by ankerite and minor amounts of galena are consistent with the inferred dextral movement along the adjacent NW–SE faults.
Inversion structures, southern margin of the Alston Block
The Lunedale Fault forms the southern bounding fault of the Alston Block (Fig. 1a and b) and, although outside the ‘fluorite zone’ that is the focus of this study, the structures found therein are of importance for understanding the regional structural history of the North Pennines and its associated mineralization. The main fault is a poorly exposed, steeply southward-dipping, east–west-trending structure with an along-strike length of roughly 20 km (Dunham 1990), which separates the Alston Block from the Stainmore Trough (Fig. 1a inset). The Lunedale Fault and related structures and associated mineralization are exposed at the disused Closehouse Mine [NY85252275] (Fig. 5a). The host lithologies here are Carboniferous limestones and sandstones of the Alston Formation, together with dolerite of the Whin Sill dyke emplaced here within the Lunedale Fault (Dunham 1990; Bevins et al. 2010). Two sets of unmineralized joints trend north–south and east–west and are probably related to the regional set of jointing observed throughout the NPO. The structure of the area is dominated by an c. 100 m wide, east–west-striking anticline (Fig. 5a and b) cross-cut by a series of mostly southward- and subordinate northward-dipping thrust faults that have been infilled by later quartz mineralization (Fig. 5b and c). Slickenlines preserved on the thrust faults indicate a dip-slip reverse shear sense (Fig. 5a) with offsets that are mostly small (<1 m). Slickenline-bearing bedding planes are also common and appear to be related to flexural slip during folding rather than fault motion. To the north of this structure, a c. 20 m wide fault-bounded slice is exposed containing a gently west-plunging anticline–syncline pair (Fig. 5a and b). The bounding faults have shallowly plunging slickenlines consistent with sinistral-oblique reverse movement. To the south of the main fold, outcrop-scale antithentic thrusts and associated anticlines are exposed within the limestone (Fig. 5c).
Closehouse Mine is significant for its exposure of an east–west-striking altered, dolerite dyke thought to be a feeder to the nearby Whin Sill (Fig. 5a; Dunham 1990; Bevins et al. 2010), although the importance of these ‘feeder’ dykes with regard to magmatism and the associated magmatic fluids is now open to some dispute. Robinson (2020) has proposed a emanative centre for the Whin Sill located close to Cow Green Reservoir [NY8136129014] some distance from the horst-bounding structures seen at Closehouse Mine.
Petrology and microstructures
Mineralized fractures (faults, veins) in the NPO range in width from millimetres to metres and in length from 1 m to to many kilometres. The largest of the Quarter Point veins (Slitt Vein, Great Sulphur Vein, Red Vein) are in excess of 10 km long and 10 m wide. Three main styles of mineralized fracture fills are recognized.
Simple tensile or hybrid veins, with slickenlines well developed in strike-slip segments and asymmetric jogs or pull-aparts in more tensile segments, both of which are useful as kinematic indicators. These veins are monomineralic or occasionally bimineralic, with pods of sulfide mineralization intergrown with gangue material (Fig. 6a).
Mode I tensile veins with crack-seal textures that can be either monomineralic or polymineralic with common compositional banding (Fig. 6b).
Breccia (± minor cataclasis) where all phases of mineralization are present intergrown within a brecciated wall rock fill (Fig. 6c). Slickenlines, Riedel shears and the orientation of associated second-order tensile veins are common kinematic indicators (Fig. 6d). In general, clay gouges were not observed in surface exposures, but are very occasionally observed in underground mine workings. This may reflect the poor preservation potential of such fault rocks or may be due to the relatively minor displacements along many of the structures present.
Examination of thin sections and hand specimens collected for this study reveals that, as established by Dunham (1934), fluorite, quartz, galena, sphalerite, pyrite, marcasite, pyrrhotite, siderite, ankerite and chalcopyrite are the dominant minerals within the orefield's central fluorite zone, with barium minerals (e.g. barite, witherite) taking the place of fluorite and quartz in the outer barium zone. Pyrite and marcasite appear to be widespread, although in generally modest amounts, throughout the sampled mineralization, with greater concentrations of these and with the addition of pyrrhotite, chalcopyrite and locally very small amounts of bismuth and cobalt minerals in earlier phases of mineralization. The abundance of iron minerals within these early assemblages (Fig. 6e), together with the widely observed occurrence of iron metasomatism of limestone wall rocks adjacent to vein fractures of all orientations across the orefield, indicates that iron was a significant and major component of the earliest mineralizing fluids. Occurrences of magnetite, of metasomatic origin, recently reported from the contact zone of the Whin Sill in Upper Teesdale (Young 2017), together with the abundance of magnetite within unique nickel-bearing skarn-type mineralization associated with the Teesdale Fault (Young et al. 1985), are further evidence of early iron-rich mineralizing fluids.
Microstructurally, a huge array of vein textures are preserved within the NPO (Fig. 7a–f). Primary crystallization fabrics throughout the orefield include massive veins (Smirnov 1954) and crustiform (Adams 1920), colloform (Rogers 1917), comb (Boyle 1979) and zonal (Smirnov 1954) types; these findings suggest that the surface-exposed veins retain their original textures and chemistry. Crack-seal textures (both syntaxial and antitaxial) are also widely observed (e.g. Fig. 6b). Deformation fabrics within the mineralized faults of the NPO are dominated by the presence of mineralized breccias (Fig. 8a–e). These breccias commonly record multiple deformation and mineralization events where clasts of fractured or brecciated material are incorporated into subsequent veins or breccias of similar composition (e.g. Fig. 8c); in other cases, brecciated mineral fills are cross-cut by compositionally similar veins (Fig. 8b and d). The cyclical nature of these breccias where vein material has been brecciated, healed and then re-brecciated, or cross-cut by further veining, is indicative of syntectonic mineralization following hydrofracturing events. The local preservation of cockade textures and open vugs also suggests that, in some cases, fractures were incompletely sealed and cemented, allowing repeated periods of fluid flow (Frenzel and Woodcock 2014).
Recrystallization (feathery, flamboyant and ghost-sphere; Adams 1920) and replacement textures (ghost-cubes and skeletal crystals; Morgan 1925) are commonly preserved, showing that not all veins have retained their primary mineralogy and fabric (Fig. 9a–c). Fluorite microstructures in particular suggest that significant amounts of remobilization and healing or reprecipitation have occurred; for example, replacement of fluorite by quartz or chalcedony (Young and Hopkirk 2019). Within fluorite crystals, multiple generations of fluid inclusions are observed. These fluid inclusions highlight the presence of growth zoning and pervasive healed microfractures (Fig. 8e). Optical cathodoluminescence (OCL) shows that recrystallization or healing of fluorite breccias is widespread, illustrating that this mineral is especially prone to dissolution and reprecipitation with overgrowth showing perfect optical continuity (Fig. 10a). By contrast, dissolution and precipitation with optical continuity is not observed in calcite crystals, where the textures revealed by OCL are more consistent with those observed using conventional optical microscopy (Fig. 10b).
Stress inversion analyses
Stress inversion analysis was carried out using all data collected from slickenline-bearing faults and fractures of the Alston Block of the NPO. Field observations at locations such as Bollihope Quarry clearly show that there are two sets of structures developed: an earlier set of Phase 1 NNW–SSE and NNE–SSW faults and fractures and a younger cross-cutting population of Phase 2 ENE–WSE and ESE–WNW structures. Misorientations resulting from block rotations and gentle folding in the Alston Block are negligible. A stress inversion analysis of the earlier NNE–SSW and NNW–SSE faults suggests that they are related to north–south shortening in a contractional reverse faulting or transpressional regime (σ3 vertical, Fig. 11a). The younger and more widespread ESE–WNW and ENE–WSW fault sets related to Phase 2 yield north–south extension and east–west shortening consistent with a strike-slip or transtensional regime (σ2 vertical, Fig. 11b). The Mohr circle analysis of the earlier NNE–SSW and NNW–SSE Phase 1 structures (highlighted in green) shows they are highly misoriented, which suggests that in areas where they have been locally reactivated (e.g. Nenthead) elevated pore fluid pressures would have been required locally during mineralization.
The total Re and Os abundances of pyrite range from 3.5 to 228 ppt and from 1 to 45 ppt (Table 1), respectively. The 187Re/188Os and 187Os/188Os ratios range from 0.6 to 97.6 and from 0.12 to 0.63, respectively, with the exception of sample RO572-4_BG5A, which displays 187Re/188Os and 187Os/188Os ratios of 682.2 and 3.7 (Table 1). To account for the uncertainties between the 187Re/188Os and 187Os/188Os data we present the latter with the associated uncertainty correlation value, rho (Ludwig 1980), and the 2σ calculated uncertainties for 187Re/188Os and 187Os/188Os (Table 1). The regression of all the Re–Os data using IsoplotR (Vermeesch 2018) and the 187Re decay constant (λ) of 1.666e−11 ± 5.165e−14 a−1 (Smoliar et al. 1996) yielded a Model 3 Re–Os date of 311.6 ± 19.8 (6.4%) Ma, with an initial 187Os/188Os of 0.15 ± 0.01 (2σ, mean squared weighted deviates (MSWD) = 0.98; Fig. 12a).
The significant uncertainty in the calculated Re–Os date (6.4%) is due to the low total concentrations of Re and Os in the pyrite and the scatter exhibited in the best-fit of the Re–Os data as indicated by the MSWD value of 0.98. Calculation of initial 187Os/188Os ratio at 312 Ma indicates the presence of two outlying samples (CB10 and TH1), which have a slightly more radiogenic composition (0.34 ± 0.11 and 0.38 ± 0.11, respectively; Fig. 12b), that ultimately cause scatter about the line of best-fit of the Re–Os data. Regression of the remaining Re–Os data, excluding CB10 and TH1, yielded a Model 1 Re–Os age of 304 ± 20 (6.5%) Ma with a significantly lower MSWD of 0.14 and an initial 187Os/188Os ratio of 0.15 ± 0.01 (7.9%) (Fig. 12c).
The Re and Os abundances of the Whin Sill sample are 472 ppt and 2 ppt, respectively. The 187Re/188Os and 187Os/188Os ratios are 4754.2 ± 531.5 and 23.193 ± 1.444, respectively. Based on the geochemistry and petrology, the sill is probably mantle-derived (Thorpe and MacDonald 1985); as such an initial 187Os/188Os ratio of 0.12 ± 0.01 was assumed to calculate a model Re–Os date. On the basis of an initial 187Os/188Os ratio of 0.12 ± 0.01 (Permian mantle 187Os/188Os composition calculated from Meisel et al. 1996) a Re–Os date of 290.2 ± 29 Ma was calculated. The latter also indicates that the Os budget in the Whin Sill sample is 99.5% radiogenic 187Os.
A new structural model for the North Pennine Orefield
The four regionally pervasive fault orientations observed within the NPO (Dunham 1990) can be grouped into two broad populations based on observed cross-cutting relationships (Fig. 13a and b): Phase 1 consists of NNW–SSE faults (tensile and mostly dextral) and NNE–SSW faults (sinistral) with associated small-scale north–south-trending (<50 cm wide) tensile veins; Phase 2 consists of ESE–WNW faults (normal, tensile and sinistral) with ENE–WSW faults (dextral and tensile), which are commonly associated with larger (<5 m wide) east–west striking vertical tensile veins.
Stress inversion analyses indicate that the earlier Phase 1 structures are related to north–south shortening, whereas the later Phase 2 structures are related to a superimposed phase of north–south extension and east–west shortening (Fig. 13a and b). The earlier event is consistent with the far-field effects of the Variscan Orogeny during the Late Carboniferous (Warr 2012, and references therein). It led to the sinistrally transpressive inversion of the broadly east–west-striking faults bounding the Alston Block, as evidenced by the reverse faulting and folding observed associated with the Lunedale fault at Closehouse Mine (Fig. 5). It is consistent with an early dextral transpressional movement associated with the Burtreeford Disturbance, dextral shear along the Pennine Fault to the west (Fig. 13a) and also with the late Carboniferous deformation history of the nearby Dent Fault system located further to the south (e.g. Underhill et al. 1988; Woodcock and Rickards 2003). In detail, however, the NNE–SSW shortening in the Alston Block lies c. 40° clockwise of the NNW–SSE Variscan direction determined in the SW part of the Askrigg Block (Thomas and Woodcock 2015). The faults in the latter area display larger displacements relative to those measured during the present study. Thus the difference in the late Carboniferous shortening in these two areas may reflect a partitioning of broadly north–south orogenic shortening strain between block interiors (North Pennine Orefield) and block margins (Dent–Craven faults), possibly with a component of deep basement control.
The later phase of north–south extension and east–west compression is consistent with the regional dextral transtensional regime (De Paola et al. 2005a), which is attributed to reactivation of NE–SW Caledonian structures underlying the Northumberland Basin located immediately to the north of the Alston Block. It is suggested that this deformation was synchronous with emplacement of the c. 297 Ma Whin Sill and associated intrusions based on observed cross-cutting relationships seen along the Northumberland coastline. This later phase may have led to localized compressional reactivation of the Burtreeford Disturbance, coeval with monoclinal folding and sinistral reactivation of the Pennine Fault to the west (Fig. 13b). Sinistral transtensional reactivation of the Dent Line fault system in the Early Permian is also recognized south of the Alston Block (Underhill et al. 1988).
The age and origins of the metalliferous fluids
The Re–Os pyrite data (excluding CB10 and TH1) of the North Pennine Orefield yield a date (304 ± 20 Ma) that overlaps within uncertainty with the timing of emplacement and cooling of the mantle-sourced Whin Sill (U–Pb CA-ID-TIMS baddeleyite, 297.4 ± 0.4 Ma; Thorpe and MacDonald 1985; Hamilton and Pearson 2011). This temporal relationship may indicate that the NPO sulfide mineralization has a direct genetic link to the Whin Sill complex. The Whin Sill as the progenitor of sulfide mineralization of the NPO is further supported by the similarity in the initial 187Os/188Os composition of the Whin Sill (c. 0.13) and pyrite (c. 0.15) (this study).
Considering the temporal and genetic link of the Whin Sill to the NPO mineralization the initial 187Os/188Os (Osi) compositions of pyrite calculated at 297.4 Ma exhibit two distinct populations, Group 1 with a weighted average Osi of 0.147 ± 0.010 (MSWD = 0.18; S3, SJM2, S1 and S2) and Group 2 with a slightly more radiogenic weighted average Osi of 0.345 ± 0.030 (MSWD = 0.31; BG5A, TH1 and 496CB10). Sample NHM1b possesses an intermediate Osi of 0.226 ± 0.04 (Fig. 14a).
The Re–Os data of Group 1 and Group 2 yield Model 1 Re–Os ages of 293.5 ± 20.1 Ma (MSWD = 0.57, Osi = 0.152 ± 0.006; Fig. 14b) and 294.8 ± 14.9 Ma (MSWD = 0.19, Osi = 0.366 ± 0.047; Fig. 14c), respectively. The unradiogenic Os nature of the pyrite coupled with the c. 294 Ma age strongly supports that Os and by inference ore metals and fluids were derived from the magmatism associated with the Whin Sill Complex. The Re–Os data further illustrate that fluids migrating from the Zechstein Sea (Permian), or simply leaching from the surrounding Carboniferous host rocks and underlying basement (Paleozoic) are all unlikely sources as these would lead to much more radiogenic levels of Osi≥ 0.6. However, the more radiogenic Osi of Group 2 pyrite and sample NHM1b may represent a slightly more evolved mantle fluid and/or minor inheritance from the surrounding host rocks.
Reported Sm–Nd fluorite data from throughout the NPO were interpreted by Halliday et al. (1990) to define no definitive age, but were interpreted to suggest that mineralization occurred between the Carboniferous and Jurassic. The Sm–Nd fluorite data from the Slitt, Groverake and Ferneygill veins collectively yield an errorchron (MSWD = 32) indicating a Late Cretaceous age (Fig.15a). The scatter about the best-fit line is largely caused by the Sm–Nd fluorite data of the Groverake and Ferneygill veins, which independently show considerable scatter in 147Sm/144Nd–143Nd/144Nd space. Thus, they do not provide any meaningful chronological constraints (Halliday et al. 1990).
Eleven of the 20 fluorite samples (eight of 11 from the Slitt vein, two of four from the Groverake vein and one of five from the Ferneygill vein) possess similar initial 143Nd/144Nd compositions at c. 295 Ma (the Re–Os age, see above; Table 2). Collectively, the Sm–Nd data for the 11 samples define a Model 3 age of 291.0 ± 39.0 Ma (initial 143Nd/144Nd = 0.511757 ± 59, with the scatter defined by a variation in the initial 143Nd/144Nd of 0.000028 ± 17 (Fig. 15b). Considering only the Sm–Nd data from the Slitt vein, which roughly corresponds to sample CB10 from Cambokeels of this study, with similar initial 143Nd/144Nd at 295 Ma, a Model 1 Sm–Nd age of 293.6 ± 15.7 Ma (MSWD = 5.5) is obtained. Although the best-fit of the Sm–Nd data exhibits some scatter, the age is within uncertainty of both the sulfide mineralization reported in this study and the emplacement of the Whin Sill (Hamilton and Pearson 2011). This is further supported by a Model 3 computation given the degree of scatter about a Model 1 best-fit line to the Sm–Nd data (MSWD = 5.5), which suggests that the deviated scatter is due to geological variations rather than just analytical uncertainty. A Model 3 calculation suggests that the scatter is caused by variation in the initial 143Nd/144Nd of 0.000029 ± 18 (age = 291.5 ± 46.7 Ma; initial 143Nd/144Nd = 0.511758 ± 69) (Fig. 15c).
The nominal agreement of the Sm–Nd fluorite and Re–Os pyrite chronology suggests a penecontemporaneous relationship with the emplacement of the Whin Sill. Recalculating the εNd for the fluorite, the Whin Sill and the Carboniferous sedimentary rocks (Table 2) at 291.5 Ma, yields values of −9 to −10 for the fluorite, 1.5 for the Whin Sill and −9.8 for the Carboniferous host rocks, which supports a genetic model that invokes leaching of metals from the Carboniferous sedimentary host rocks (Halliday et al. 1990; Kraemer et al. 2019). This is somewhat at odds with the Os data from the sulfides, but could account for the more radiogenic Os signature observed in Group 2 pyrites (which include sample CB10 from Cambokeels) where interaction with the host rocks and fluid evolution is likely to have occurred.
Alkali magma underplating of the North Pennine batholith associated with the intrusion of the Whin Sill Complex during the earliest Permian has been proposed as the only viable way to account for the observed mineralization (Bott and Smith 2018). This proposal is further supported by REE data from fluorite of the NPO, which display a large europium anomaly indicating that fluorite from this region must have experienced temperatures >250°C (Kraemer et al. 2019). This anomaly is absent from the mineralogically similar Askrigg Block and the South Pennine Orefield (Fig. 1a inset) located 40 km and 120 km to the south of the NPO, respectively. The local presence of exotic minerals in the early stages of mineralization in the NPO of the Alston Block alone, such as bismuthinite (Bi2S3), synchysite (CaREE(CO3)F2), argentopentlandite (Ag(FeNi)8S8), pyrrhotite, cubanite, cosalite (Pb2Bi2S5), tungsten-bearing cassiterite, monazite, xenotime, adularia, niccolite and magnetite (Young et al. 1985; Ixer et al. 1996), has been ascribed to non-‘MVT’ style mineralization with tentative links to Whin Sill magmatism.
The role of the Burtreeford Disturbance
Recent analysis of the metamorphism associated with the Whin Sill (Robinson 2020) has questioned the traditional view that the Whin Sill magma ascended along feeder dykes located at the edge of the Alston Block. These studies have shown that contact metamorphism, forming an assemblage of grossular garnet, epidote, clinopyroxene, hedenbergite, prehnite and datolite, is thickest (up to 20 m) towards the centre of the Alston Block, suggesting that an ascending Whin Sill magma and associated high-temperature fluids were focused in this area close to the Burtreeford Disturbance.
The Whin Sill is also emplaced as a small laccolithic mass at Cowshill, where the Breckonsike Vein occupies the Burtreeford structure for a surface strike length of c. 2 km adjacent to which extensive metasomatic replacements of the Great Limestone by siderite and/or ankerite occur. Two other major mineralized structures diverge from the eastern side of the Burtreeford Disturbance at Cowshill. The NE–SW-trending Burtree Pasture Vein was extensively mined here for both lead and fluorspar. About 4 km to the NE this vein unites with the triple junction of the Red, Greencleugh and Groverake veins of the Red Vein Quarter Point set at Groverake in the Rookhope Valley (Fig. 1c). Although not known to carry significant mineralization in the near-surface strata in the interval between Cowshill and Groverake, this vein could conceivably have channelled mineralizing fluids at depth from the Burtreeford Disturbance towards the Groverake junction, which Dunham (1990) suggested to be a major emanative centre of mineralization, a model for which fluid inclusion and REE data give strong support (Smith 1974; Greenwood and Smith 1977). It is also significant that the roughly ESE–WNW Sedling Vein, at the western extremity of the Slitt Vein Quarter Point system, also originates from the eastern side of the Burtreeford Disturbance at Cowshill. The possibility that this too could have acted as a significant channel for mineralizing fluids from the Burtreeford structure is consistent with speculation on the role of Quarter Point veins as important feeders for mineralization.
At Allenheads, c. 4 km north of Cowshill, a complex of rich lead-bearing veins and associated ‘flat’ deposits in the Great Limestone connect with the eastern side of the Burtreeford Disturbance. All were worked at Allenheads Mine, the largest and most productive of the orefield's lead mines. Although Dunham (1990, p 167) recorded an underground driveage through the disturbance, no mineralization was encountered and the limited contemporary evidence was interpreted as indicating that the Allenheads veins terminated against the disturbance. The apparent absence of mineralization within the disturbance here may be due to the driveage being within beds above the Great Limestone that are typically unfavourable to mineralization. It is possible that the Allenheads deposits, together with those associated with their eastward continuation as the Red Vein Quarter Point system of the Rookhope Valley may, at least in part, have been fed via the Burtreeford Disturbance.
Thus there are a number of lines of evidence to suggest that the Burtreeford Disturbance, or a deep-rooted basement fault at depth that underlies it, acted as a significant conduit for both ascending magma associated with the Whin Sill complex and mineralizing fluids (Fig. 13b). The latter were then channelled away from the monocline into strike-slip related dilatational jogs and associated tensile veins of the ENE–WSW Lead Vein set and in particular the ESE–WNW Quarter Point vein set within the Alston Block.
Mineralization in the Cross Vein sets
Mineralization associated with Phase 1 NNW–SSE-trending ‘Cross Veins’ is generally sparse compared with that within Phase 2 fractures but there are two significant exceptions. First, the Leehouse Well–Sir John's Vein system of the South Tyne Valley exhibits significant mineralization at several points along its c. 10 km strike length. The galena is characterized by substantially higher silver concentrations than are normal for the NPO and the variety of copper sulfides, together with small amounts of bismuth, cobalt, nickel minerals and native silver have been interpreted as evidence of an early high-temperature phase of mineralization (Ixer et al. 1996; Fairbairn et al. 2020).
The second exception is the Nenthead area, where abundant lead–zinc–iron mineralization is present (see above). Although the higher temperature assemblages and more exotic metal content of the Leehouse Well–Sir John's vein assemblages have not been reported from Nenthead, this may be due to the current level of exposure. The deposits seen in the South Tyne Valley occur in much lower horizons within the Carboniferous succession than those of Nenthead, where it is conceivable that similar assemblages may be present at depth; traces of both nickel and cobalt supergene minerals have been reported here (Bridges and Young 1985).
New field and microstructural observations presented here suggest that the faults, fractures and mineralization of the Alston Block of the NPO record two distinct phases of deformation. During Phase 1, which is suggested to have occurred during the Late Carboniferous as a result of the far-field effects of the Variscan Orogeny, north–south shortening and basin inversion occurred, leading to folding and thrusting along the margins of the Alston Block (Fig. 13a). Phase 2 deformation was regionally coeval with Whin Sill magmatism at c. 297 Ma and the main phases of mineralization of the NPO in the Alston Block. This broad contemporaneity has been demonstrated by Re–Os analyses, which suggest that mineralization occurred at c. 294 Ma, and supported by recalculation of existing Sm–Nd fluorite data. This Early Permian event involved north–south lithospheric extension and east–west compression (Fig. 13b) and appears to be related to regional dextral transtensional reactivation of deep-seated NE–SW Caledonian basement structures as recognized in the adjacent Northumberland Basin (De Paola et al. 2005a). The North Pennine Orefield appears to be centred on the Burtreeford Disturbance, which may correspond to a deep-seated Caledonian structure in the basement that acted as a conduit for ascending metalliferous fluids in the earliest Permian.
The Re–Os isotopic analysis of the sulfide mineralization indicates that it is probably genetically linked to the primitive mantle source that gave rise to the Whin Sill magmatism. Previous interpretations of the NPO of the Alston Block as an MVT, or being caused by the influx of Zechstein seawater, although understandable given the obvious interactions with sedimentary host rocks during emplacement, are now thought to be incorrect. Based on the findings presented here, it is suggested that the NPO of the Alston Block should be regarded as having formed as a mantle magmatism associated F-rich deposit. The new genetic model proposed here suggests that the Alston Block is distinct from its southern neighbour, the Askrigg Block, where mineralization is less diverse, is associated with lower temperatures and seems to lack any clear link to mantle-derived fluids (e.g. Bau et al. 2003; Kraemer et al. 2019). This implies that the Alston and Askrigg blocks are genetically distinct and should be treated as two separate orefields.
It is significant that fluorine-associated orefields have been presumed to result from MVT mineralization in several other deposits across Europe and North Africa (e.g. Munoz et al. 1994, 1999; Subías and Fernández-Nieto 1995; Subías et al. 1998; Boiron et al. 2010; Souissi et al. 2010; Dill et al. 2011; Kraemer et al. 2019). It is now apparent that an important part of one of the supposedly archetypal examples is most probably related to mantle-sourced magmatism and fluorine-rich hydrothermal fluids and is therefore not a classic MVT. Reappraisal of other similar orefields worldwide may now be required.
Thanks go to I. Chaplin for the preparation of thin sections for this project. Many thanks to reviewers Nigel Woodcock and Anonymous for their very helpful and constructive comments.
EDD: data curation (lead), formal analysis (equal), investigation (lead), writing – original draft (equal); REH: conceptualization (lead), funding acquisition (lead), investigation (supporting), methodology (supporting), writing – original draft (equal), writing – review & editing (lead); DS: formal analysis (equal), investigation (supporting), methodology (lead), writing – review & editing (supporting); AB: formal analysis (supporting), investigation (supporting); BY: conceptualization (supporting), investigation (supporting), writing – review & editing (supporting); CLC: investigation (supporting), methodology (supporting)
This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
All data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article.
Scientific editing by John MacDonald