MANFRED MENNING, DIETER WEYER, IMMO WENDT, NICHOLAS J. RILEY, VLADIMIR I. DAVYDOV; Discussion on high-precision 40Ar/39Ar spectrum dating on sanidine from the Donets Basin, Ukraine: evidence for correlation problems in the Upper Carboniferous : Journal, Vol. 156, 1999, 527–533. Journal of the Geological Society ; 158 (4): 733–736. doi: https://doi.org/10.1144/jgs.158.4.733
Download citation file:
Scientific editing by Ray Burgess.
Manfred Menning, Dieter Weyer, Immo Wendt, Nicholas J. Riley & Vladimir I. Davydov write: Hess et al. (1999, p. 528) investigated ‘about one dozen rock samples from coal tonsteins’ from the Donets Basin for Ar/Ar sanidine dating. ‘Unfortunately, only one proved could be dated isotopically. All other samples contain no chronometer minerals that which were (1) of primary volcanic origin and (2) unaffected by secondary alterations’. The datable sample has an age of 305.5±1.5 Ma (±1σ without the age errors of the monitors) using sanidines for high-precision Ar/Ar spectrum dating. However, the expected age is...