Martian gullies and their Earth analogues: introduction
Published:January 01, 2019
- Chapter PDF
Susan J. Conway, Tjalling de Haas, Tanya N. Harrison, Paul A. Carling, Jonathan Carrivick, 2019. "Martian gullies and their Earth analogues: introduction", Martian Gullies and their Earth Analogues, S. J. Conway, J. L. Carrivick, P. A. Carling, T. de Haas, T.N. Harrison
Download citation file:
Martian gullies are widespread landforms in the mid-latitudes of Mars. When the first reports of these kilometre-scale features were published in 2000, they were controversially hailed as a sign of recent flows of liquid water on the surface of Mars. This supposition was contrary to our understanding of recent environmental conditions on Mars, under which water should not exist in its liquid form. In response to their discovery, researchers proposed a wide range of scenarios to explain this apparent paradox, including scenarios driven by CO2, climate change or the presence of a liquid water aquifer. This Special Publication is a collection of papers arising from the topics discussed at the Second International Workshop on Martian Gullies held at the Geological Society, London. A review paper opens the Special Publication and thereafter the papers are presented under three themes: Martian remote sensing, Earth analogues and laboratory simulations. This Special Publication establishes the state of the art in Martian gully research, presents the latest observations and interpretations of the present-day activity and long-term evolution of Martian gullies, explores the role of Earth analogues, highlights novel experimental work and identifies future avenues of research. The importance of gullies as a potential marker of habitable environments on Mars underlines their importance in framing space exploration programmes.
The First International Workshop on Martian Gullies, the ‘Workshop on Martian Gullies: Theories and Tests’, was held on 4–5 February 2008 at the Lunar and Planetary Institute in Houston, Texas, USA. Its purpose was to bring together researchers examining gullies (Malin & Edgett 2000) and to discuss progress with respect to the various hypotheses in circulation. At that time, the formation of gullies (Fig. 1) by top-down melting under a past climate regime was favoured over the aquifer theory. Hypotheses involving dry processes, including CO2-supported flows, had been gradually abandoned due to dissimilarities with dry processes on the Moon and Earth. Two major discoveries disturbed this consensus after the workshop: (1) the realization that present-day Martian gullies were active during winter, when water is highly unlikely to be present in its liquid form, and that the activity could not simply be attributed to dry mass wasting (e.g. Dundas et al. 2015), which re-established dry processes as a candidate for forming Martian gullies; and (2) the discovery of recurring slope lineae, which are active at the present day and were initially linked to the seepage of liquid water (McEwen et al. 2011). These recurring slope lineae reanimated the dry v. wet gully formation debate.
This Special Publication came together as a result of the Second International Workshop on Martian Gullies, entitled ‘Martian Gullies and their Earth Analogues’, held at the Geological Society in London during the Geological Society’s Year of Water. The aim of the workshop was to revisit the debate on the formation of Martian gullies in the light of new research and new data gathered since the last workshop. Martian gullies (Fig. 1) remain a highly attractive and dynamic research topic because of their potential as indicators of liquid water on the surface of Mars and elsewhere (e.g. Scully et al. 2015). Water is the principal ingredient for life and finding evidence for it drives the exploration programmes of national space agencies, such as the famous ‘Follow the Water’ slogan of the National Aeronautical and Space Administration and the ambitious ExoMars programme of the European Space Agency. The importance of gullies in space exploration is highlighted by the fact that gullies are explicitly mentioned in the Findings of the Mars Special Regions Science Analysis Group White Paper, which lists Martian ‘special regions’ where visiting spacecraft need to take additional precautions because ‘terrestrial organisms are likely to propagate, or a region which is interpreted to have a high potential for the existence of extant Martian life forms’ (COSPAR 2002, 2005 – see summary in Rettberg et al. 2015; NASA 2005). The possibility of liquid water forming gullies on Mars has enormous implications for the climate and history of Mars and how they are recorded in its rocks, the alteration of rocks and meteorites from Mars and the availability of resources for human habitation. Understanding Martian gullies could therefore be important not only for our understanding of the planet, but also in the design of future space missions and the selection of landing sites.
This Special Publication represents a cross-section of the work presented at the Second International Workshop on Martian Gullies. It opens with a review paper (P467-18-129C5Conway et al. 2018c) summarizing the research performed to date on Martian gullies and an assessment of the issues that need to be resolved to progress our understanding of these controversial landforms. This initial paper deals with the three major points of discussion that arose at the workshop: (1) terminology; (2) our understanding of sediment transport by fluids, including CO2; and (3) the usefulness and limits of Earth analogues in studying Martian gullies. The book is then split into three major sections: Martian remote sensing, Earth analogues and laboratory simulations.
Martian remote sensing
This is the longest section of the Special Publication and is representative of the approaches used in the community studying Martian gullies. The latest results on the present-day activity of Martian gullies, including constraints on the timing and frequency of activity, are covered by four papers (P467-18-129C12Dundas et al. 2017; P467-18-129C10Diniega et al. 2017; P467-18-129C20Jouannic et al. 2018; P467-18-129C27Pasquon et al. 2018). P467-18-129C12Dundas et al. (2017) present an overview of gully activity and posit that CO2 sublimation processes drive present-day activity. The other three papers focus on the activity of gullies on dunes on Mars. This activity is shown to be annual and seasonal and is probably linked to the action of CO2, but with the possibility of water action left open in some cases. As a counterpoint to recent activity, the timing of the formation of gullies in the last few million Mars years was also discussed at the workshop and is reported by P467-18-129C8de Haas et al. (2017), who suggest that water may have been the preferred candidate for the formation of gullies in the (recent) past. Papers are also presented covering the analyses of remote sensing data and provide new constraints for the development of gully formation models, including global topographic data (P467-18-129C2Conway et al. 2017), thermal inertia (P467-18-129C15Harrison et al. 2017), landform assemblages (P467-18-129C32Soare et al. 2018) and a detailed hydrological analysis of topographic data (P467-18-129C14Gulick et al. 2018). These papers lead to the conclusion that water is the most likely agent producing Martian gullies, particularly in the light of new modelling work that leverages such results (Conway et al. 2018b).
The Earth analogues presented at the workshop and included in this Special Publication include Antarctic water flows in Victoria Land (P467-18-129C17Hauber et al. 2018) and the McMurdo Dry Valleys (P467-18-129C9Dickson et al. 2017) and Himalayan debris flows generated by snowmelt (P467-18-129C31Sinha et al. 2018). The Earth analogues discussed at the meeting, but not included in this book, were submarine landforms (Gales et al. 2012), gullies in Meteor Crater, dune processes in Egypt and alluvial fans in Svalbard (Hauber et al. 2011) (Fig. 2). These analogues contribute significantly to our understanding of the processes and environmental constraints under which such landscape features can form and aid in formulating hypotheses that can be tested via Martian or laboratory studies.
Small-scale Earth analogues, provided by laboratory simulations of the processes that could form Martian gullies, were also a notable topic of the workshop. Laboratory simulation papers are presented here on understanding sediment transport by CO2 sublimation (P467-18-129C33Sylvest et al. 2018), metastable water (P467-18-129C18Herny et al. 2018) and slush flows (P467-18-129C1Auld & Dixon 2017) – all potential processes for forming and modifying Martian gullies. Experiments with sliding CO2 blocks were also presented at the workshop, but these have been published elsewhere (McKeown et al. 2017). These blocks are thought to be an active agent in the formation of the ‘linear’ gullies found on dunes, a peculiar sub-type of Martian gullies.
Discussion and conclusions
This Special Publication contains a cross-section of the latest work on Martian gullies. The subjects presented at the workshop, but not encapsulated by the papers within this Special Publication, include: the implications of global climate model results for the formation of Martian gullies, which have been seminal in establishing the obliquity paradigm (Costard et al. 2002) and bolstering the CO2 hypothesis (Pilorget & Forget 2016); numerical modelling of the flows that form Martian gullies (Pelletier et al. 2008; Mangeney et al. 2010); the role of dry processes, including wind and dust, in gully formation and modification (Treiman 2003; De Haas et al. 2015); the spectral identification of volatiles and minerals at active gully sites (Vincendon 2015); the reporting of controversial equatorial Martian gullies (McEwen et al. 2018); and the link between the generation of recurring slope lineae and gullies and gullies as a landform within a paraglacial time series (Jawin et al. 2018; Conway et al. 2018a). The breadth of the topics covered in this Special Publication, at the workshop and in the wider literature attest to a continuing interest in these familiar, yet enigmatic, landforms. This Special Publication provides a key reference to those new to the field as well as inspiration for future research, because it:
establishes the state of the art in the field in the initial review paper (P467-18-129C5Conway et al. 2018c), identifying knowledge gaps and future avenues of research;
presents the most up-to-date observational data of Martian gullies from remote sensing and provides the latest interpretations of these data;
describes a range of terrestrial analogues as potential processes and environmental analogues, which aid in formulating and testing hypotheses about the formation and modification of Martian gullies; and
presents novel laboratory simulations giving insights into the dynamics of potential gully-forming processes, observations that are inaccessible via remote sensing.
We thank David Hodgson for reviewing this editorial. The production of this Special Publication was facilitated by the support afforded to the editors by the following agencies: SJC was supported by the French Space Agency CNES through her work related to the HiRISE project; and TdH was funded by the Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research via Rubicon Grant 019.153LW.002. We thank our sponsors, the Geological Society of London, for hosting the 2015 workshop. The British Geophysical Association, the British Society for Geomorphology, the European Association of Geoscientists and Engineers, the European Geosciences Union and the Royal Astronomical Society all provided financial support. The support of the International Association of Geomorphologists and the International Association of Sedimentologists enabled the presence of four students at the workshop.
Martian Gullies and their Earth Analogues
CONTAINS OPEN ACCESS
Gullies on Mars resemble terrestrial gullies involved in the transport of abundant material down steep slopes by liquid water. However, liquid water should not be stable at the Martian surface. The articles in this volume present the two main opposing theories for Martian gully formation: climate-driven melting of surficial water-ice deposits and seasonal dry-ice sublimation. The evidence presented ranges from remote-sensing observations, to experimental simulations, to comparison with Earth analogues. The opposing hypotheses imply either that Mars has been unusually wet in the last few million years or that it has remained a cold dry desert – both with profound implications for understanding the water budget of Mars and its habitability. The debate questions the limits of remote-sensing data and how we interpret active processes on extra-terrestrial planetary surfaces, even beyond those on Mars, as summarized by the review paper at the beginning of the book.