The Permian marine-terrestrial system of the North China block provides an exceptional window into the evolution of northern temperate ecosystems during the critical transition from icehouse to greenhouse following the late Paleozoic ice age (LPIA). Despite many studies on its rich hydrocarbon reserves and climate-sensitive fossil flora, uncertain temporal constraints and correlations have hampered a thorough understanding of the records of geologic, biologic, and climatic change from the North China block. We present a new chronostratigraphy based on high-precision U-Pb chemical abrasion–isotope dilution–thermal ionization mass spectrometry (CA-ID-TIMS) geochronology of tuffs from a near-complete latest Carboniferous–Permian succession in North China. The results indicate that the predominance of continental red beds, climate aridification, and the disappearance of coals and characteristic tropical flora were well under way during the Cisuralian (Early Permian) in the North China block, significantly earlier than previously thought. A nearly 20 m.y. hiatus spanning the early Kungurian to the mid-Guadalupian (or later) is revealed in the northern North China block to have close temporal and spatial associations with the closure and/or subduction of the Paleo-Asian Ocean and its related tectonic convergence. This long hiatus was concomitant with the prominent loss of the highly diverse and abundant Cathaysian floras and the widespread invasion of the monotonous Angaran floras under arid climate conditions in the North China block. Similarities in the floral and climate shift histories between Euramerica and North China suggest that aside from the regional tectonic controls and continental movement, extensive volcanism during the Cisuralian may have played a major role in the global warming and aridification in the aftermath of the LPIA.
The North China block occupied northerly tropical to subtropical paleolatitudes (Boucot et al., 2013), marginal to the Paleo-Asian Ocean (PAO), during the critical Cisuralian (298.9– 273.0) transitions from an icehouse to a greenhouse world (Fig. 1). The late Carboniferous to Permian marine and marginal-marine to terrestrial sequences in North China preserve highly diverse and abundant plant fossils in addition to their significant economic hydrocarbon resources (Yang et al., 2005; Wang, 2010; Liu et al., 2015). These characteristics provide a unique opportunity to investigate the interactions among terrestrial biotic evolution, regional tectonics, and global climate change during a critical period of geologic history. However, poor constraints on age and correlation have hampered a deep understanding of those events in the North China block. In the absence of diagnostic marine fossils from key intervals, stratigraphic correlation within and beyond North China has relied on uncalibrated palynostratigraphy and phytostratigraphy (Wang, 2010; Liu et al., 2015) and magnetostratigraphy (Embleton et al., 1996). Detrital zircon geochronology by U-Pb in situ analyses from Permian volcaniclastic sandstones (e.g., Zhu et al., 2014; Yang et al., 2017) generally lacked the necessary precision or stratigraphic range to place reliable constraints on depositional ages.
We report high-precision U-Pb zircon geochronology by the chemical abrasion–isotope dilution–thermal ionization mass spectrometry (CA-ID-TIMS) method focused on bentonitic tuffs from the Permian succession in North China. The results necessitate fundamental revisions to the traditional Permian terrestrial depositional history and chronostratigraphy of the North China block and provide a new timeline and important insights for the history of continental collision, floral turnovers, and paleoclimate change as recorded in the North China block.
STRATIGRAPHY AND GEOLOGIC SETTING
Paleozoic epicontinental deposition in the North China block was interrupted by a long period of craton-wide non-deposition and/or erosion from the Late Ordovician to late Carboniferous (Yang et al., 2005). A late Carboniferous marine transgression led to the deposition of the Penchi Formation, overlain by the Carboniferous– Permian Taiyuan Formation, in shallow-marine and tidal-flat environments. The latter consists of alternating marine limestone and shale along with extensive coal seams that transition upward into lagoonal-swamp and shoreline deposits. The overlying Permian successions are predominated by fluvial-deltaic deposits with coal interbeds of the Shansi and Lower Shihhotse Formations, whereas the Upper Shihhotse Formation marks a transition into mottled purple-red, fluvial and shallow-lacustrine mudstone, siltstone, and intercalated channel sandstone without coals (Yang et al., 2005). The overlying Sunjiagou Formation, which was deposited in a fluvial environment, is composed of typical red beds interbedded with stream channel-fill sandstone (Liu et al., 2015). Carboniferous–Permian basin evolution in North China was largely controlled by convergent tectonics during the closure of the PAO along the northern margin of the North China block (Zhu et al., 2014).
The age and regional correlation of the Penchi and Taiyuan Formations have been well constrained by fusuline and conodont fossils from their marine strata (see the Supplemental Material1) as well as new U-Pb CA-ID-TIMS geochronology from the subsurface of southeastern North China (Yang et al., 2020). However, the correlation of the Permian succession above the Taiyuan Formation has long been a subject of debate. The Shansi and Lower Shihhotse Formations were roughly assigned to the Cisuralian, the Upper Shihhotse Formation to the Guadalupian (273.0–259.5 Ma), and the Sunjiagou Formation to the Lopingian (259.5–251.9 Ma) in the classic area of Shanxi Province in North China, based on fossil plant and palynological analyses (Wang, 2010; Liu et al., 2015).
Limited tuff zircon geochronology by in situ techniques previously resulted in U-Pb age estimates of 293.0 ± 2.5 Ma for the Shansi Formation (Yang et al., 2014), 290.1 ± 5.8 Ma for a northerly correlative of the Taiyuan and/ or Shansi Formations (Cope et al., 2005), and 296 ± 4 Ma for a presumed correlative unit of the Lower and Upper Shihhotse Formations (Zhang et al., 2007). These data have been unable to resolve outstanding Permian chronostratigraphic issues in North China (see the Supplemental Material for a complete review).
METHODS AND RESULTS
We collected 11 bentonitic tuff and tuffaceous mudstone samples from the Palougou, Qiaotou, and Sigou sections in Shanxi Province, northern North China (Fig. 1), for U-Pb geochronology by the CA-ID-TIMS method. These samples encompass the middle Taiyuan to basal Sunjiagou Formations. The weighted mean 206Pb/238U dates of the analyzed zircons along with a Bayesian interpolation algorithm are used to construct a statistically robust chronostratigraphic framework for the Permian succession of North China, from which the ages of lithostratigraphic boundaries, floral changes, and climate proxies can be extrapolated. Detailed descriptions of the stratigraphy, tuff samples, U-Pb analytical procedures, data reduction, age interpretation, reliability, and Bayesian modeling are provided in the Supplemental Material. The U-Pb geochronological results are summarized in Table 1.
A set of five new weighted mean 206Pb/238U dates from bentonites of the Palougou section forms the basis of a Bayesian age-stratigraphic model, which for the first time provides a near-complete temporal calibration for the Permian system of North China (Fig. 2; Fig. S5 in the Supplemental Material). The Carboniferous-Permian boundary is precisely constrained at a major coal seam immediately below the dated tuff bed NC-3, based on the marine boundary calibration from the southern Ural Mountains (Russia) (Ramezani et al., 2007) and consistent with its biostratigraphic placement in the Taiyuan Formation (see the Supplemental Material). Results from the Qiaotou section provides a direct correlation of the major Asselian (298.9–293.5 Ma) coal seams (Shansi Formation) to the Palougou section (Figs. S1 and S5). The new chronostratigraphy assigns the interval from the upper Taiyuan Formation to the top of the Lower Shihhotse Formation to Asselian, whereas the Upper Shihhotse Formation coincides with the latest Asselian to early Kungurian (283.5–273.0 Ma) in northern North China. This is in sharp contrast to previous assignments of the Upper Shihhotse Formation to Guadalupian–early Lopingian time (e.g., Stevens et al., 2011; Liu et al., 2015). A previously reported occurrence of the mid-Guadalupian Illawarra geomagnetic polarity reversal from the Upper Shihhotse Formation (Embleton et al., 1996) is not supported by our geochronology. Instead, the possibility of multiple Cisuralian normal polarities during the long Kiaman reverse polarity superchron (Hounslow and Balabanov, 2018) should be investigated. The Sunjiagou Formation in Baode was constrained to younger than ca. 269 Ma by detrital zircon ages and to Lopingian by integrated biostratigraphic data (Zhu et al., 2019), which is consistent with our date from the Sigou section.
Our new geochronology reveals a ∼20 m.y. hiatus during the Cisuralian-Guadalupian transition in the northern North China block. Excluding one upper Upper Shihhotse Formation sample (BD-2) suspected of being compromised by young detrital contamination (see section S3.2 in the Supplemental Material), our age model constrains the hiatus to between the topmost Upper Shihhotse Formation date of 280.98 ± 0.11 Ma and the youngest analyzed Sunjiagou Formation zircon of 261.75 ± 0.29 Ma (Fig. 2). A critical evaluation of existing in situ U-Pb detrital zircon geochronology substantiates a similar hiatus in the Permian successions of North China, although its duration may vary as a function of proximity to the collisional zone in the north of the North China block (Fig. S3; Table S2). Paleosols in the upper half of the Upper Shihhotse Formation may account for minor hiatuses before the single major unconformity associated with the basal channel (conglomeratic) sandstone of the overlying Sunjiagou Formation (Fig. S2). An analogous unconformity has also been reported from correlative Permian successions in eastern Xinjiang (Yang et al., 2010) and Inner Mongolia (Tang and Yan, 1993). These areas constituted the southern margins of the PAO, the middle segment of which underwent tectonic convergence (uplift and erosion) associated with subduction generating arc-continent and retroarc fold-thrust deformation or ocean closure leading to continental collision (ca. 280–265 Ma: Zhao et al., 2018; Xiao et al. 2018).
A highly diverse Cathaysian flora and extensive coal deposits preserved in the Taiyuan and Shansi Formations indicate a humid climate (Wang, 2010). The climate became more arid from the late Asselian with the increase of xerophytic plants and decrease of coal deposits in the upper Shansi Formation (Liu et al., 2015). The early main groups of gymnosperms (e.g., early ginkgoaleans and conifers) evolved afterward (Fig. 2; Wang, 2010). A notable change to a more arid condition occurs across the major unconformity, which separates the upper Upper Shihhotse Formation subhumid paleosols containing abundant flora from overlying Sunjiagou Formation aeolian sandstone, carbonate breccias, and gypsum with few plant fossils. Aridification trends and analogous fossil-poor red beds have also been recorded in middle to low paleo-latitudes during the Cisuralian to Guadalupian, concomitant with deglaciation of the late Paleozoic ice age (LPIA) and surge of atmospheric CO2 (Tabor and Poulsen, 2008; Boucot et al., 2013; Schneider et al., 2019; Soreghan et al., 2019; Richey et al., 2020), except for Tethyan archipelagos where the ocean may have modulated climate (Figs. 2 and 3).
Northward continental drift into a subtropical or temperate arid climatic zone (Rees et al., 1999; Tabor and Poulsen, 2008) and/or a regional rain-shadow effect caused by orographic uplift associated with tectonic convergence (Cope et al., 2005) may have contributed to the late Asselian to Guadalupian aridification in the North China block. However, these regional effects do not explain a global-scale climate transition at this time. An increase in atmospheric CO2 has long been considered the major driving force for the demise of the LPIA and subsequent global aridification, presumably due to elevated surface temperature and evaporation, which thus reduced soil moisture and the source of continental convective precipitation (Poulsen et al., 2007; Peyser and Poulsen, 2008). The surge in atmospheric CO2 was probably related to extensive large igneous province (LIP) volcanism during the Cisuralian (e.g., Skagerrak-Centered LIP, Panjal Traps, Tarim LIP; Torsvik et al., 2008; Xu et al., 2014; Shellnutt, 2018; Fig. 1A), as suggested by the coincidence between LIPs and pCO2 excursions (Fig. 2). The moderate increases of pCO2 in between may have been associated with widespread wildfires (Yan et al., 2016). Furthermore, the warming phases associated with high pCO2 were indicated by low δ13Corg values from Permo-Carboniferous coals in North China (Zhang et al., 1999), significant retreat of the LPIA (Soreghan et al., 2019), stronger terrestrial chemical weathering (Yang et al., 2014, 2020, and references therein), and interglacial intervals in Australia (Garbelli et al., 2019). Thus, frequent and extensive volcanism during the Cisuralian may have been responsible for reducing effects of the LPIA and global aridification under such CO2-forced climate conditions.
The major floral disappearances in the topmost Upper Shihhotse Formation had previously been attributed to the late Capitanian Emeishan LIP (Bond et al., 2010; Stevens et al., 2011). Our new geochronology questions that scenario and instead indicates a temporal coincidence with the convergent tectonics of the PAO and the third phase of the Tarim LIP during the Kungurian (Xu et al., 2014). Both convergent tectonics and extensive volcanism may have profoundly influenced the local environments and climate, which in turn led to floral extinction at the top of the Upper Shihhotse Formation and possibly the Olson's gap of tetrapods from the late Cisuralian to the middle Guadalupian (Lucas, 2018). Progressive contraction (closure) of the central to eastern segment of the PAO during the Permian (to Early Triassic) (Eizenhöfer and Zhao, 2018) provided a pathway for the widespread invasion of Angaran flora to the North China block, as recorded in the lower Sunjiagou Formation (Wang, 2010). We interpret the abrupt floral disappearances at the top of the Upper Shihhotse Formation as an extinction event, but further work is needed to rule out the possibility that it is an artifact of stratigraphic truncation associated with the sub-Sunjiagou unconformity.
New high-precision U-Pb geochronology necessitates major revisions to the temporal framework for the Permian terrestrial system in North China. The Upper Shihhotse Formation spans the latest Asselian to the early Kungurian, as opposed to its previous Wordian to Wuchiapingian age assignments. A major depositional gap during the late Cisuralian to Guadalupian in the northern North China block may have been caused by convergent tectonics associated with the closure and/or subduction of the PAO. The great loss of highly diverse and abundant Cathay-sian floras and the widespread invasion of the Angaran floras under arid climate conditions in the North China block happened during the late Cisuralian to Guadalupian, but its exact timing is uncertain due to the long hiatus. The Cisuralian global aridification may have been associated with extensive LIP volcanism and the rise of atmospheric CO2 in the waning stages of the LPIA.
Mark Schmitz and Vladimir Davydov joined in an earlier field trip to North China. This research is supported by the Strategic Priority Research Programs of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (grants XDB18000000 and XDB26000000). Wan Yang is partially supported by the U.S. National Science Foundation (grant EAR 1714749). We thank Isabella Bennett for expeditious zircon separation at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. We thank anonymous reviewers for their comments that improved the manuscript.