ABSTRACT The Appalachian Mountains expose one of the most-studied orogenic belts in the world. However, metamorphic pressure-temperature-time (P-T-t) paths for reconstructing the tectonic history are largely lacking for the southernmost end of the orogen. In this contribution, we describe select field locations in a rough transect across the orogen from Ducktown, Tennessee, to Goldville, Alabama. Metamorphic rocks from nine locations are described and analyzed in order to construct quantitative P-T-t paths, utilizing isochemical phase diagram sections and garnet Sm-Nd ages. P-T-t paths and garnet Sm-Nd ages for migmatitic garnet sillimanite schist document high-grade 460–411 Ma metamorphism extending south from Winding Stair Gap to Standing Indian in the Blue Ridge of North Carolina. In the Alabama Blue Ridge, Wedowee Group rocks were metamorphosed at biotite to staurolite zone, with only local areas of higher-temperature metamorphism. The Wedowee Group is flanked by higher-grade rocks of the Ashland Supergroup and Emuckfaw Group to the northwest and southeast, respectively. Garnet ages between ca. 357 and 319 Ma indicate that garnet growth was Neoacadian to early Alleghanian in the Blue Ridge of Alabama. The P-T-t paths for these rocks are compatible with crustal thickening during garnet growth.

ABSTRACT The eastern Great Smoky Mountains basement complex consists of the following components: (1) ca. 1350–1325 Ma orthogneiss and mafic xenoliths that represent some of the oldest crust in Appalachian Grenville massifs (similar to “pre-Grenville” basement components in the Adirondack, Green Mountain, Hudson Highland, and Shenandoah massifs); (2) ca. 1150 Ma augen orthogneisses and granitic orthogneisses correlating with the Shawinigan phase of Grenville magmatism; and (3) paragneisses (cover rocks) that have either pre- or syn-Grenville (i.e., Mesoproterozoic) versus post-Grenville (Neoproterozoic) depositional ages, and that experienced Taconian metamorphism and migmatization. Mesoproterozoic paragneisses contain major zircon age modes that require a component of Proterozoic crust in the source region. The Neoproterozoic paragneisses exhibit the archetypical “Grenville doublet” in detrital zircon age distributions that matches the age distribution of Ottawan and Shawinigan magmatic/metamorphic events in eastern Laurentia. Most zircon U-Pb age systematics exhibit variable lead loss interpreted to result from high-grade Taconian (ca. 450 Ma) regional metamorphism and migmatization. Neodymium mantle model ages (T DM) for ortho- and paragneisses range from 1.8 to 1.6 Ga, indicating that all rocks were derived from recycling of Proterozoic crust (i.e., they are not juvenile), which is consistent with Proterozoic detrital zircon ages in pre- to syn-Grenville paragneisses. Lead isotope compositions confirm the presence of an exotic (Amazonian) crustal component in the source region for the protoliths of the pre-Grenville orthogneisses and xenoliths, and that this exotic component was incorporated to varying degrees in the evolution of the basement complex. The oldest age component may represent an Amazonian pre-Grenville analog to the ca. 1.35 Ga native Laurentian crust present in Adirondack and northern Appalachian basement massifs.

ABSTRACT The southern Appalachian orogen is a Paleozoic accretionary-collisional orogen that formed as the result of three Paleozoic orogenies, Taconic, Acadian and Neoacadian, and Alleghanian orogenies. The Blue Ridge–Piedmont megathrust sheet exposes various crystalline terranes of the Blue Ridge and Inner Piedmont that record the different effects of these orogenies. The western Blue Ridge is the Neoproterozoic to Ordovician Laurentian margin. Constructed on Mesoproterozoic basement, 1.2–1.0 Ga, the western Blue Ridge transitions from two rifting events at ca. 750 Ma and ca. 565 Ma to an Early Cambrian passive margin and then carbonate bank. The Hayesville fault marks the Taconic suture and separates the western Blue Ridge from distal peri-Laurentian terranes of the central and eastern Blue Ridge, which are the Cartoogechaye, Cowrock, Dahlonega gold belt, and Tugaloo terranes. The central and eastern Blue Ridge terranes are dominantly clastic in composition, intruded by Ordovician to Mississippian granitoids, and contain ultramafic and mafic rocks, suggesting deposition on oceanic crust. These terranes accreted to the western Blue Ridge during the Taconic orogeny at 462–448 Ma, resulting in metamorphism dated with SHRIMP (sensitive high-resolution ion microprobe) U-Pb ages of metamorphic zircon. The Inner Piedmont, which is separated from the Blue Ridge by the Brevard fault zone, experienced upper amphibolite, sillimanite I and higher-grade ­metamorphism during the Acadian and Neoacadian orogenies, 395–345 Ma. These events also affected the eastern Blue Ridge, and parts of the western Blue Ridge. The Acadian and Neoacadian orogeny is the result of the oblique collision and accretion of the peri-Gondwanan Carolina superterrane overriding the Inner Piedmont. During this collision, the Inner Piedmont was a forced mid-crustal orogenic channel that flowed NW-, W-, and SW-directed from underneath the Carolina superterrane. The Alleghanian orogeny thrust these terranes northwestward as part of the Blue Ridge–Piedmont megathrust sheet during the collision of Gondwana (Africa) and the formation of Pangea.

ABSTRACT The southern Appalachian western Blue Ridge preserves a Mesoproterozoic and mid-Paleozoic basement and Neoproterozoic to Ordovician rift-to-drift sequence that is metamorphosed up to sillimanite grade and dissected by northwest-directed thrust faults resulting from several Paleozoic orogenic events. Despite a number of persistent controversies regarding the age of some western Blue Ridge units, and the nature and extent of multiple Paleozoic deformational/metamorphic events, synthesis of several multidisciplinary data sets (detailed geologic mapping, geochronology and thermochronology, stable-isotope chemostratigraphy) suggests that the western Blue Ridge likely records the effects of two discrete orogenic events. The earlier Taconic (470–440 Ma) event involved a progression from open folding and emplacement of the Greenbrier–Rabbit Creek and Dunn Creek thrust sheets as a foreland fold-and-thrust to low-grade hinterland system (D 1A), followed by deep burial (>31 km), pervasive folding of the earlier-formed fault surfaces, and widespread Barrovian metamorphism (D 1B). Because this high-grade (D 1B) metamorphic event is recorded in Ordovician Mineral Bluff Group turbidites, this unit must have been deposited prior to peak orogenesis, possibly as a foreland basin or wedge-top unit in front of and/or above the developing fold-and-thrust belt. The later Alleghanian (325–265 Ma) event involved widespread northwest-directed brittle thrusting and folding related to emplacement of the Great Smoky thrust sheet (D 2 ; hanging wall of the Blue Ridge– Piedmont thrust). Mid-Paleozoic 40 Ar/ 39 Ar muscovite ages from western Blue Ridge samples likely record post-Taconic cooling (hornblende and some muscovite 40 Ar/ 39 Ar ages) and/or Alleghanian thrust-related exhumation and cooling (ca. 325 Ma muscovite 40 Ar/ 39 Ar and 300–270 Ma zircon fission-track ages), as opposed to resulting from a discrete Neoacadian thermal-deformational event. The lack of evidence for a discrete Neoacadian event further implies that all deformation recorded in the Silurian–Mississippian(?) Maggies Mill–Citico Formation must be Alleghanian. We interpret this structurally isolated sequence to have been derived from the footwall of the Great Smoky fault as an orphan slice that was subsequently breached through the Great Smoky hanging wall along the out-of-sequence Maggies Mill thrust.

ABSTRACT Ion microprobe U-Pb zircon rim ages from 39 samples from across the accreted terranes of the central Blue Ridge, eastward across the Inner Piedmont, delimit the timing and spatial extent of superposed metamorphism in the southern Appalachian orogen. Metamorphic zircon rims are 10–40 µm wide, mostly unzoned, and dark gray to black or bright white in cathodoluminescence, and truncate and/or embay interior oscillatory zoning. Black unzoned and rounded or ovoid-shaped metamorphic zircon morphologies also occur. Th/U values range from 0.01 to 1.4, with the majority of ratios less than 0.1. Results of 206 Pb/ 238 U ages, ±2% discordant, range from 481 to 305 Ma. Clustering within these data reveals that the Blue Ridge and Inner Piedmont terranes were affected by three tectonothermal events: (1) 462–448 Ma (Taconic); (2) 395–340 Ma (Acadian and Neoacadian); and (3) 335–322 Ma, related to the early phase of the Alleghanian orogeny. By combining zircon rim ages with metamorphic isograds and other published isotopic ages, we identify the thermal architecture of the southern Appalachian orogen: juxtaposed and superposed metamorphic domains have younger ages to the east related to the marginward addition of terranes, and these domains can serve as a proxy to delimit terrane accretion. Most 462–448 Ma ages occur in the western and central Blue Ridge and define a continuous progression from greenschist to granulite facies that identifies the intact Taconic core. The extent of 462–448 Ma metamorphism indicates that the central Blue Ridge and Tugaloo terranes were accreted to the western Blue Ridge during the Taconic orogeny. Zircon rim ages in the Inner Piedmont span almost 100 m.y., with peaks at 395–385, 376–340, and 335–322 Ma, and delimit the Acadian-Neoacadian and Alleghanian metamorphic core. The timing and distribution of metamorphism in the Inner Piedmont are consistent with the Devonian to Mississippian oblique collision of the Carolina superterrane, followed by an early phase of Alleghanian metamorphism at 335–322 Ma (temperature >500 °C). The eastern Blue Ridge contains evidence of three possible tectonothermal events: ~460 Ma, 376–340 Ma, and ~335 Ma. All of the crystalline terranes of the Blue Ridge–Piedmont megathrust sheet were affected by Alleghanian metamorphism and deformation.

ABSTRACT The timing and kinematics of Paleozoic peri-Gondwanan terrane accretion along the southern and central Appalachian margin have long been debated. The Silurian–Devonian Concord plutonic suite intruded the western flank of the Carolina superterrane, suggesting east-dipping subduction of ocean crust beneath the Carolina superterrane just prior to accretion, based on Devonian–Mississippian plutonism and metamorphism in the adjacent Laurentian terranes. Geochemical and isotopic data support a subduction-related origin for the Concord plutonic suite, and our geochronologic data reveal the main pulse of plutonism occurred ca. 405 Ma. Our new sensitive high-resolution ion microprobe (SHRIMP) geochronologic data identify a suite of mafic plutons from the Carolinas to central Georgia that also belong to the Concord suite. These gabbros have U-Pb zircon ages of 372 ± 2 Ma (Gladesville contact aureole), 386 ± 5.7 Ma (Buffalo), 403.8 ± 3.7 Ma (Highway 200), 404.9 ± 6.9 Ma (Mecklenburg), and 416 ± 6.9 Ma (Calhoun Falls). The Ogden Gabbro has a U-Pb age from baddeleyite of 411.91 ± 0.25 Ma. In this study, we identified a previously unrecognized Alleghanian (Pennsylvanian) gabbro suite with U-Pb zircon ages of 308.2 ± 6.2 Ma (Farmington), 311 ± 6.2 Ma (Dutchman’s Creek), and 311 ± 6.5 Ma (Mount Carmel). These gabbros should henceforth not be included in the Concord suite. The ages of Concord suite plutons slightly predate the main phase of plutonism in the Cat Square terrane to the west, which we suggest represents the product of B-type subduction of ocean crust beneath the Carolina superterrane between 415 and 400 Ma. Arc-related magmatism terminated because of the switch to A-type subduction of the eastern Laurentian margin. Prograde upper-amphibolite- to granulite-facies metamorphism, wholesale migmatization, and extensive anatectic plutonism in the eastern Inner Piedmont occurred from Late Devonian into Mississippian time, shortly after cessation of Concord plutonic suite plutonism, which also supports this proposed model. These data, combined with the timing and geometry of foreland clastic wedges, provide compelling support for Devonian–Mississippian accretion of the Carolina superterrane via dextral transpressive obduction above the eastern Laurentian margin.

ABSTRACT The Brevard fault zone is one of the largest faults in the Appalachians, extending from Alabama to Virginia. It had a very complex history of movement and reactivation, with three movement episodes: (1) Acadian-Neoacadian (403–345 Ma) movement accompanying the thermal peak of metamorphism and deformation with dextral, southwest-directed emplacement of the Inner Piedmont; (2) ductile dextral reactivation during the early Alleghanian (~280 Ma) under lower-greenschist-facies conditions; and (3) brittle dip-slip reactivation during the late Alleghanian (260 Ma?). The Brevard is comparable to other large faults with polyphase movement in other orogens worldwide, for example, the Periadriatic line in the Alps. Two types of far-traveled, fault-bounded horses have been identified in the Brevard fault zone in the Carolinas: (1) metasedimentary and granitoid horses located along the southeastern margin of the Alleghanian retrogressive ductile dextral Brevard fault zone in North and South Carolina; and (2) limestone/dolostone horses located along the brittle, late Alleghanian Rosman thrust, the contact between Blue Ridge and Brevard fault zone rocks in North and South Carolina. Field, stratigraphic, petrographic, and Sr-isotope data suggest the carbonate horses may be derived from Valley and Ridge carbonates in the Blue Ridge–Piedmont megathrust sheet footwall. The horses of metasedimentary and granitoid rocks occur along faults that cut klippen of the southwest-directed Inner Piedmont Acadian-Neoacadian Alto (Six Mile) allochthon. New laser ablation– inductively coupled plasma–mass spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS) U-Pb zircon analyses from the metasedimentary mylonite component yield a detrital zircon suite dominated by 600 and 500 Ma zircons, and a second zircon population ranging from 2100 to 1300 Ma, with essentially no Grenvillian zircons, suggesting a peri-Gondwanan provenance. The granitoid component has a sensitive high-resolution ion microprobe (SHRIMP) age of 421 ± 14 Ma, similar to the ~430 Ma plutonic suite in northern Virginia and Maryland—a prominent component of the Cat Square terrane detrital zircon suite in the Carolinas. Peri-Gondwanan Neoproterozoic to Cambrian Avalon–Carolina superterrane rocks are nowhere in contact with the Brevard fault zone at present erosion level. While these far-traveled metasedimentary and granitoid horses may have originated several hundred kilometers farther northeast in the central Appalachians, they could alternatively be remnants of Avalon–Carolina superterrane rocks that once formed the tectonic lid of the southwest-directed Neoacadian–early Alleghanian (Late Devonian–early Mississippian) orogenic channel formed during north-to-south zippered accretion of Avalon–Carolina. The remnant fossil subduction zone survives as the central Piedmont suture. Avalon–Carolina terrane rocks would have once covered the Inner Piedmont (and easternmost Blue Ridge) to depths of >20 km, and have since been eroded. Data from these two suites of horses provide additional insights into the mid- to late Paleozoic history and kinematics of the Brevard fault zone, Inner Piedmont, and Avalon–Carolina superterrane. It was six men of Indostan To learning much inclined, Who went to see the Elephant (Though all of them were blind), That each by observation Might satisfy his mind. … And so these men of Indostan Disputed loud and long, Each in his own opinion Exceeding stiff and strong, Though each was partly in the right, And all were in the wrong. —John Godfrey Saxe (1816–1887) “The Blind Men and the Elephant”