Abstract Paleozoic reefs were first identified by James Hall (1862) in the Silurian rocks of the American Midwest. Scientifically, they were crucial in defining ancient reefs, documenting the early history of this marine ecosystem, and interpreting regional stratigraphy, palaeogeography and palaeoecology. Schoonmaker Reef in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin, is historically the most significant of these structures, as the first to be correctly identified as a ‘coral’ reef by exhibiting the transition between a reef mound and the surrounding seafloor. After nearly two hundred years of quarrying, Thornton Reef in Thornton, Illinois, is next in importance as it displays an unequalled three-dimensional exposure, demonstrating the impact of Silurian climate change on reef development. Silurian reefs were discovered and studied only through stone industry quarrying. Extensive nineteenth-century fossil collecting by local naturalists was also a key component in reef studies. These reefs are also an important part of the region's geoheritage, comprising elements of its economy, history, education and scenic landscape. Recognizing their scientific and historical importance, some reefs were part of geoconservation projects and are protected sites. However, other reefs and irreplaceable reef fossil collections need further initiatives to preserve the scientific value and historical legacy of these relatively small geological features.

Abstract Rodinia break-up with late Ediacaran rifting defined a NE Laurentia triple junction (New York Promontory–Ottawa–Bonnechere aulacogen (OBA)–Quebec Reentrant). Rifting persisted to c. 510 Ma. The oldest passive-margin shelf units (Forestdale Marble and Moosalamoo Phyllite) underlie a sandstone (Cheshire) commonly regarded as the oldest passive unit. Late Dyeran–Middle Cambrian rifting led to the oldest OBa sedimentation and formed the Franklin Basin (NW Vermont). Cambrian–Darriwillian shelf–slope facies are linked eustatically – not Taconic Orogeny onset. Onlap and shelf carbonates are coeval with black slope mud; and lowstand shelf unconformities with green, oxic slope mud. Early–middle Dyeran eustatic change defined slope units: (1) Browns Pond Formation dysoxic–anoxic (d–a) interval with debrite cap (Holcombville Member, new); (2) Middle Granville Formation Oxic Interval (new); and (3) lower Hatch Hill Formation d–a interval. Our analysis leads to two controversial conclusions: (i) the existence of the Dashwoods and other micro-continental blocks due to hyperextension is not supported by cover sequences linking Laurentia to proposed Dashwoods areas (i.e. Green Mountains) and an arc origin of the type Dashwoods; and (ii) ‘Hawke Bay Event(s)’, widely interpreted as Cambrian global regressive event(s), is a local highstand systems tract facies with shelf sand bypass onto the Hatch Hill Formation slope in its NE Laurentia type region.