ABSTRACT The North American Cordillera experienced significant and varied tectonism during the Triassic to Paleogene time interval. Herein, we highlight selected questions and controversies that remain at this time. First, we describe two tectonic processes that have hindered interpretations of the evolution of the orogen: (1) strike-slip systems with poorly resolved displacement; and (2) the closing of ocean basins of uncertain size, origin, and mechanism of closure. Next, we divide the orogen into southern, central, and northern segments to discuss selected controversies relevant to each area. Controversies/questions from the southern segment include: What is the origin of cryptic transform faults (Mojave-Sonora megashear vs. California Coahuila transform fault)? Is the Nazas an arc or a continental rift province? What is the Arperos basin (Guerrero terrane), and did its closure produce the Mexican fold-and-thrust belt? How may inherited basement control patterns of deformation during subduction? Controversies/questions from the central segment include: Can steeply dipping mantle anomalies be reconciled with geology? What caused high-flux events in the Sierra Nevada batholith? What is the origin of the North American Cordilleran anatectic belt? How does the Idaho segment of the orogen connect to the north and south? Controversies/questions from the northern segment include: How do we solve the Baja–British Columbia problem? How big and what kind of basin was the Early Cretaceous lost ocean basin? What connections can be found between Arctic geology and Cordilleran geology in Alaska? How do the Cretaceous tectonic events in the Arctic and northern Alaska connect with the Cordilleran Cretaceous events? What caused the Eocene tectonic transitions seen throughout the northern Cordillera? By addressing these questions along the length of the Cordillera, we hope to highlight common problems and facilitate productive discussion on the development of these features.

ABSTRACT Two main tectonic scenarios have been proposed for the area corresponding to the Guerrero terrane in western Mexico. The first model suggests that the Guerrero terrane was an allochthonous volcanic arc developed over oceanic substrate, which was accreted to nuclear Mexico. The second tectonic model proposes that the Guerrero terrane was a para-autochthonous volcanic arc developed over continental crust, which was rifted during the extensional phase of the Arperos back-arc basin and then tectonically attached to nuclear Mexico. Based on U-Pb geochronology and Hf isotope analyses of detrital zircon grains extracted from Mesozoic sedimentary successions of the Guerrero terrane and western nuclear Mexico, this study provides new evidence to support the interpretation that the Late Jurassic–Early Cretaceous Guerrero terrane was built above a pre–Late Jurassic continentally sourced basement. Hf isotopic signatures of detrital zircon from Late Jurassic–Early Cretaceous sedimentary rocks of the Guerrero terrane range from –14 to +13 and display depleted mantle model ages (T DMc , using a mean crustal value of 176 Lu/ 177 Hf = 0.015) between ca. 2.0 and 0.3 Ga, indicating provenance from both pre–Late Jurassic basement and juvenile crustal components. The most juvenile magmas were formed during the earliest Cretaceous extensional phase, which resulted in the formation of the Arperos basin. Additionally, the negative ε Hf (t) values are consistent with recycling of Proterozoic and Paleozoic continental materials in Mesozoic magmas.

The Mesozoic Peninsular Ranges batholith, part of a long-lived Cordilleran subduction orogen, is located at a critical juncture at the southwest corner of cratonal North America. The batholith is divided into northern and southern segments that differ in their evolution. In this paper, we focus on the more poorly understood southern Peninsular Ranges batholith, south of the Agua Blanca fault at ~31.5°N latitude, and we compare its evolution with the better-known northern Peninsular Ranges batholith. Adding our new insights to previous work, our present understanding of the geologic history of the Peninsular Ranges consists of the following: (1) stronger connections between the Paleozoic passive-margin rocks in the eastern Peninsular Ranges batholith and similar assemblages in Sonora, Mexico, to the east and the Sierra Nevada batholith to the north that were originally proposed by earlier workers; (2) continuity of the Triassic–Jurassic accretionary prism and forearc basin assemblage from the northern Peninsular Ranges batholith through the southern Peninsular Ranges batholith; (3) possible synchronous subduction of an ocean ridge or ridge transform along the Peninsular Ranges batholith in late Middle Jurassic time; (4) continuity of the Early Cretaceous Santiago Peak continental arc from the northern Peninsular Ranges batholith along the entire margin, including the southern Peninsular Ranges batholith; (5) development of the Alisitos oceanic arc in Jurassic and possibly Triassic time, much earlier than originally thought; and (6) removal of part of the Santiago Peak assemblage in the southern Peninsular Ranges batholith during collision of the Alisitos terrane in latest Early Cretaceous time.

In southwestern Mexico, Late Cretaceous to Early Tertiary deformation has been generally associated with the Laramide orogeny of the Cordillera. Several alternative models consider the deformation to result from the accretion of the Guerrero terrane, formed by the Zihuatanejo, Arcelia, and Teloloapan intraoceanic island arcs, to the continental margin of the North American plate. Here, we present a detailed geologic and structural study and new 40 Ar/ 39 Ar and U-Pb ages for a broad region in the central-eastern part of the Guerrero terrane that allow the accretion model to be tested. In the Huetamo–Ciudad Altamirano part of the region, an almost complete Cretaceous-Paleogene succession records the transition from an early Cretaceous shallow-marine environment to continental conditions that began in Santonian times, followed by the development of a major continental Eocene magmatic arc. Folding of the marine and transitional successions signifies a shortening episode between the late Cenomanian and the Santonian, and a subsequent, out-of-sequence, coaxial refolding event in Maastrichtian-Paleocene time amplified the previous structures. A major left-lateral shear zone postdates the contractional deformation, and it passively controlled the geographic distribution of Eocene silicic volcanism. Minor transcurrent faulting followed. Our results indicate that the Huetamo–Ciudad Altamirano region, which has been considered part of the Zihuatanejo subterrane, was in proximity to a continent during most of the Mesozoic. We found continental recycled material at various stratigraphic levels of the Huetamo Cretaceous succession and Grenvillian inherited ages in zircons from the ca. 120 Ma Placeres del Oro pluton. More importantly, detrital zircon ages from the pre-Cretaceous basement of the Huetamo succession (Tzitzio metaflysch) and the pre–Early Jurassic basement of the Arcelia subterrane (Tejupilco suite) yield very similar Late Permian and Ordovician age peaks. These ages are typical of the Acatlán complex, onto which the Guerrero terrane has been proposed to have been accreted in the Late Cretaceous. Similarly, Paleozoic and Precambrian ages are reported in detrital zircons from the volcano-sedimentary successions of the Zihuatanejo, Arcelia, and Teloloapan subterranes. Models considering this part of the Guerrero terrane as having formed by intraoceanic island arcs separated by one or more subduction zones cannot explain the ubiquitous presence of older continental material in the Mesozoic succession. We favor a model in which most of the Guerrero terrane consisted of autochthonous or parautochthonous units deposited on the thinned continental margin of the North American plate and where the Mesozoic magmatic and sedimentary record is explained in the framework of an enduring west-facing migrating arc and related extensional backarc and forearc basins. The results presented here exclude the accretion of allochthonous terranes as the cause for Laramide deformation and require an alternative driving force to explain the generation of the Late Cretaceous–early Tertiary shortening and shearing on the southern margin of the North American plate.

The Guerrero Composite Terrane of western Mexico is the second largest terrane in North America. Mostly characterized by submarine volcanism and formed by five terranes, the Guerrero records vast and complex subduction-related processes influenced by major translation and rifting. It is composed of the Teloloapan, Guanajuato, Arcelia, Tahue, and Zihuatanejo Terranes. The Teloloapan Terrane is made up of Lower Cretaceous island-arc (IA) andesitic to basaltic submarine lava flows, interbedded with limestone and shallow-marine volcaniclastic rocks. The Guanajuato and Arcelia Terranes are characterized by Lower Cretaceous supra-subduction ophiolite successions formed by deep-marine volcanic and sedimentary rocks with mid-oceanic-ridge basalt (MORB), oceanic-island basalt (OIB), and island-arc basalt (IAB) signatures. These two terranes are placed between the continent and the more evolved arc assemblages of the Zihuatanejo Terrane. The Tahue Terrane is composed of Paleozoic accreted arc and eugeoclinal sedimentary rocks, Triassic rift-related metaigneous rocks, and overlain unconformably by pillow basalts, limestone, and volcaniclastic rocks. The Zihuatanejo Terrane was formed by Triassic ocean-flank to ocean-floor assemblages accreted in Early Jurassic time (subduction complexes). The subduction complexes are overlain by Middle Jurassic–evolved volcanic arc rocks, which are in turn unconformably overlain by Early and Late Cretaceous subaerial and marine arc-related volcano-sedimentary assemblages. Mesozoic stratigraphy at the paleocontinental margin of Mexico (Oaxaquia and Mixteca Terranes) is formed by Triassic submarine fan turbidites accreted during Early Jurassic time; Middle Jurassic–evolved volcanic arc rocks are unconformably covered by a Late Jurassic to Cretaceous calcareous platform. Six stages in the tectonic evolution are proposed on the basis of the stratigraphic and deformational events recorded in western Mexico: (1) A passive or rifting margin developed along the western margin of continental Mexico throughout the Triassic. A thick siliciclastic turbiditic succession of the Potosi Submarine Fan was accumulated on the paleo-continental shelf-slope and extended to the west in a marginal oceanic basin. (2) Subduction began in the Early Jurassic, and the turbidites of the Potosi Fan with slivers of the oceanic crust were accreted, forming a wide subduction prism. (3) Exhumation of the accretionary prism and development of a Middle Jurassic continental arc onto the paleo-continental margin (Oaxaquia and Mixteca Terrane) took place, and also in the Zihuatanejo Terrane. (4) Intra-arc strike-slip faulting and rifting of the Middle Jurassic continental arc took place along with migration of the subduction toward the west and development of a calcareous platform in Oaxaquia and the Mixteca Terrane (continental Mexico). (5) Drifting of the previously accreted Tahue and Zihuatanejo Terranes formed a series of marginal arc-backarc systems, or one continuously drifting arc with intra-arc and backarc basins during Early to middle Cretaceous time. (6) Deformation of the arc assemblages, and development of Santonian to Maastrichtian foreland and other basins, date the final amalgamation of the Guerrero Composite Terrane with the continental margin.