Abstract The American razor clam Ensis directus has been a successful non-indigenous invader in the Wadden Sea since the late 1970s. It often shows poorly understood mass mortalities in the winter half-year, which are also known from its native area. During such mass mortalities Ensis directus partly leaves its burrow and, as it is unable to re-burrow, is an easy prey for herring gulls during low tide. During a mass mortality in March 1999, Ensis consumption by herring gulls was studied. Shell fragmentation was achieved by shaking the shell vigorously, not by hammering. This caused characteristic shell fragmentation ranging from small fragments broken from one or both valves near the middle, to both valves broken near the middle, but still connected by the ligament. About one-quarter of the shells remained undamaged. No other predators are known to produce similar Ensis shell fragments. In taphonomic studies the importance of predators in fragmenting shells should be taken into account.