Abstract The effects of dynamic recrystallization on the deformation mechanisms and rheology of olivine aggregates in the laboratory and the lithosphere are reviewed in this paper. The low-strain rheology of olivine is well documented; however, deformation in the lithosphere often involves large strains. Large strain experiments show that recrystallization can result in both hardening and softening during deformation. Moderate strain softening in experimental shear and torsion can be explained by the operation of dislocation-accommodated grain boundary sliding in bands of fine recrystallized grains. Data on the temperature dependence of recrystallized grain size are needed to extrapolate the effects of dynamic recrystallization to the lithosphere. Theories of dynamic recrystallization suggest that grain size is strongly stress dependent and moderately temperature dependent. A re-analysis of experimental grain size data indicates that the recrystallized grain size is temperature independent for olivine aggregates with low water content (<300 ppm H/Si). Rheological regime maps have been constructed for the lithospheric mantle. The maps suggest that grain size sensitive power law creep, involving both grain boundary sliding and dislocation creep, will produce strong strain softening, greater than found so far in experimental studies, in dry and wet lithosphere shear zones.

Abstract There is abundant field and microstructural evidence for localization of deformation in alpine- and ophiolite-type mantle massifs. On the basis of field relationships and microstructures we recognize two types of tectonite shear zones (medium- to coarse- and fine-grained), as well as two types of mylonitic shear zones (anhydrous and hydrous peridotite mylonites). In tectonite shear zones, softening processes responsible for localization are probably melt-related weakening in the medium to coarse tectonites and a change in limiting slip system in the fine-grained tectonites. In peridotite mylonites, the most likely cause for softening and localization is a change in dominant deformation mechanism from dislocation to grain size sensitive creep. Microstructural and petrological study of mylonite rocks reveals that reactions, either continuous net-transfer reactions (anhydrous and hydrous) or melt-rock reactions, play a key role in the formation of fine-grained material that promotes grain size sensitive creep. These reactions occur over a broad range of pressure-temperature conditions encompassing a large part of the lithospheric upper mantle. We conclude that mantle shear zones are widespread and that they reduce the (bulk) strength of the lithosphere significantly.