Abstract This is a short personal essay on geological field mapping, mostly ‘hard-rock’, with my views, prejudices and conclusions based upon 67 years in geology and 65 field seasons, variably in Western Ireland, Newfoundland, New York and New England, California, Turkey, Tibet, New Zealand, Australia and South Africa. I have also seen a lot of geology in most of the rest of the world with the exception of Antarctica, Siberia and most oceanic islands.

Abstract The Taconian–Grampian tract was characterized by a diachronous collision of a north-facing oceanic arc–forearc terrane and associated backarc basins with an irregular Laurentian margin with hyperextended segments. Hyperextension produced outboard continental terranes, separated by exhumed subcontinental mantle from the inboard margin. The exhumed mantle facilitated continued subduction of the extended margin after it had entered the trench. Enhanced slab-rollback resulted in spreading in lenticular backarc basins, which gradually transitioned along-strike into extensional arcs where rollback was less. Obduction of the oceanic elements onto the irregular Laurentian margin was followed by diachronous slab breakoff and a subduction polarity reversal, such that south- and north-dipping subduction zones locally were coeval along-strike. The polarity flip changed the convergence obliquity from dextral to sinistral and was accompanied by shallowing of the subducting slab near the end of the Middle Ordovician. Strike-slip movements locally juxtaposed segments where tectonic events occurred at different times, producing conflicting relationships. Slab breakoff produced punctuated magmatism, largely driven by mantle-derived melts, and drove and/or enhanced metamorphism in the overlying and enveloping crustal rocks. Boninite was generated episodically over a time span of 32 myr; the oldest Cambrian phase in the Lushs Bight Oceanic Tract (LBOT) and correlatives was associated with subduction initiation.

ABSTRACT Tectonic models for arc-continent collision can be overly complex where, for example, diachronous sedimentation and deformation along a single plate boundary are attributed to separate tectonic events. Furthermore, continuous sedimentation in a single basin recording a diachronous collision along a plate margin makes it difficult to use classical unconformable relationships to date an orogenic phase. In this chapter, we describe the Ordovician South Mayo Trough of western Ireland, a remarkable example of such a basin. It originated in the late Cambrian–Early Ordovician as a Laurentia-facing oceanic forearc basin to the Lough Nafooey arc. This arc was split by a spreading ridge to form a trench-trench-ridge triple junction at the trench. The basin remained below sea level during Grampian/Taconic arc-continent collision and, following subduction flip, received sediment from an active continental margin. Sedimentation ended during Late Ordovician Mayoian “Andean”-style shortening, broadly coeval with a marked fall in global sea level. These major tectonic events are traced through the nature of the detritus and volcanism in this basin, which is preserved in a mega-syncline. The Grampian orogen is not recorded as a regional unconformity, but as a sudden influx of juvenile metamorphic detritus in a conformable sequence.

Abstract In the first application of the developing plate tectonic theory to the pre-Pangaea world 50 years ago, attempting to explain the origin of the Paleozoic Appalachian–Caledonian orogen, J. Tuzo Wilson asked the question: ‘Did the Atlantic close and then reopen?’. This question formed the basis of the concept of the Wilson cycle: ocean basins opening and closing to form a collisional mountain chain. The accordion-like motion of the continents bordering the Atlantic envisioned by Wilson in the 1960s, with proto-Appalachian Laurentia separating from Europe and Africa during the early Paleozoic in almost exactly the same position that it subsequently returned during the late Paleozoic amalgamation of Pangaea, now seems an unlikely scenario. We integrate the Paleozoic history of the continents bordering the present day basin of the North Atlantic Ocean with that of the southern continents to develop a radically revised picture of the classic Wilson cycle The concept of ocean basins opening and closing is retained, but the process we envisage also involves thousands of kilometres of mainly dextral motion parallel with the margins of the opposing Laurentia and Gondwanaland continents, as well as complex and prolonged tectonic interaction across an often narrow ocean basin, rather than the single collision suggested by Wilson.

Extract Sir Archibald Geikie (1835–1924) was a formidable and authoritarian figure who played a central part in British geology in Victorian and Edwardian times. He was a protégé of Sir Roderick Impey Murchison and became Professor of Geology at the University of Edinburgh (1871), Director of the Geological Survey of Scotland (1871) and Director-General of the Geological Survey of Great Britain (1882), a position that he held with stern, but kindly, attention to his staff until his retirement to Haslemere in 1901. He was a prolific writer of both biographies of his mentors and a huge number of books and papers on a wide variety of geological topics. His rather long-winded and self-congratulatory autobiography (Geikie 1924) was published in the year of his death. His principal hobby was as a proficient sketcher and water colourist, mostly of scenes of geological interest, many of which adorn and illustrate his published works. Geikie had a powerful influence on Victorian and Edwardian geology and was rewarded by many honours, including Fellow of the Royal Society (1864), a knighthood (1891) and the Order of Merit (1914).

The main conclusion of this paper is that some form of plate tectonics started at ca. 3.0 Ga or possibly as early as 3.1 Ga., and that, since then, plate tectonics has steadily become dominant over plumes as a mechanism of heat loss. Modern plate tectonics started at ca. 0.6 Ga. The volume history of the continental crust is one of fast Early Archean growth to generate a, probably, globally continuous crust, then a growth, probably exceeded or balanced, long-term, by crustal return to the mantle reservoir.