We are pleased that R. Mazumder has given our paper (Eriksson and Simpson, 2000) careful scrutiny and below we address and clarify the misconceptions raised in his commentary.

...

First, Mazumder claims that removal of the semidiurnal signature should reduce the spectral analysis peak at around 13 (Eriksson and Simpson, 2000, Fig. 5) to 6–7. This would be the case if a complete semidiurnal record was preserved throughout the Moodies sandwave deposit. This is not the case nor was such a claim made in our paper in reference to the data set shown in Figure 3A (...

First Page Preview

First page PDF preview
First page PDF preview
You do not currently have access to this article.