E. Buchner & M. Schmieder reply: In their discussion, El Goresy & Schmidt (2019) question the analytical methods of Buchner & Schmieder (2017) that were applied to obtain geochemical results from coatings on shatter cone surfaces from the Steinheim Basin impact structure in Germany. Furthermore, they disagree with some of the interpretations in that article. In our opinion, most points of criticism stated by El Goresy & Schmidt (2019) arose from an overinterpretation of the conclusions presented in our article.

The authors criticise that Buchner & Schmieder (2017) analysed Fe2O...

You do not currently have access to this article.