Serpentinite matrix mélange represents a significant, if less common, component of many accretionary complexes. There are two principal hypotheses for the origin of serpentinite mélange: (1) formation on the seafloor in a fracture zone–transform fault setting, and (2) formation within a subduction zone with mixing of rocks derived from both the upper and lower plates. The first hypothesis requires that the sheared serpentinite matrix be derived from hydrated abyssal peridotites and that the block assemblage consist exclusively of oceanic rocks (abyssal peridotites, oceanic basalts, and pelagic sediments). The second hypothesis implies that the sheared serpentinite matrix is derived from hydrated...