Earliest microbial trace fossils in Archaean pillow lavas under scrutiny: new micro-X-ray absorption near-edge spectroscopy, metamorphic and morphological constraints
Eugene G. Grosch, Manuel Muñoz, Olivier Mathon, Nicola McLoughlin, 2017. "Earliest microbial trace fossils in Archaean pillow lavas under scrutiny: new micro-X-ray absorption near-edge spectroscopy, metamorphic and morphological constraints", Earth System Evolution and Early Life: A Celebration of the Work of Martin Brasier, A. T. Brasier, D. McIlroy, N. McLoughlin
Download citation file:
Filament-shaped titanite microtextures in early Archaean (c. 3.47 Ga) metabasalts from the Barberton Greenstone Belt of South Africa have been argued to represent Earth’s oldest microbial trace fossils, but petrological data on the environmental conditions that led to the formation of these microtextures are sparse. We present here new metamorphic constraints on the equilibrium mineral assemblage containing the titanite microtextures, together with Fe speciation redox variations in the chlorite matrix surrounding the microtextures and morphospace analysis of the microtextures to test their biogenicity. Thermodynamic phase diagram modelling using a calculated rock microdomain composition indicated that the titanite mineral assemblage is stable at temperature conditions of T=240–360°C. The high-resolution quantitative mapping results combined with micro-X-ray absorption near-edge spectroscopy at the Fe K-edge in chlorite revealed that the titanite microtextures are located in low-temperature, high XFe3+ chlorite bands, veins and microdomains, supporting an origin as abiotic, retrograde mineral cooling textures. These new data, combined with a late c. 2.9 Ga U–Pb date for the titanite, are incompatible with the existing biological model, which invokes microbial micro-tunnel formation followed by titanite ‘infilling’ and preservation in the early Archaean sub-seafloor. The continuum of titanite morphologies reported herein indicates that titanite morphology cannot be used as reliable evidence in support of a biogenic origin in these metavolcanic rocks. It is proposed that the titanite microtextures of purported biogenic origin from other greenstone belts, such as the Pilbara Craton of Western Australia, also deserve to be scrutinized by high-resolution petrological investigations.
Supplementary material: Representative electron microprobe analyses of retrograde minerals and µXANES spectra and corresponding fitted pre-edge peaks for all spot analyses are available at https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.c.3498465
Figures & Tables
This volume in memory of Professor Martin Brasier, which has many of his unfinished works, summarizes recent progress in some of the hottest topics in palaeobiology including cellular preservation of early microbial life and early evolution of macroscopic animal life, encompassing the Ediacara biota. The papers focus on how to decipher evidence for early life, which requires exceptional preservation, employment of state-of-the-art techniques and also an understanding gleaned from Phanerozoic lagerstätte and modern analogues. The papers also apply Martin’s MOFAOTYOF principle (my oldest fossils are older than your oldest fossils), requiring an integrated approach to understanding fossils. The adoption of the null-hypothesis that all putative traces of life are abiotic until proven otherwise, and the consideration of putative fossils within their spatial context, characterized the work of Martin Brasier, as is well demonstrated by the papers in this volume.