Outcrop-behind Outcrop (Quarry): Multiscale Characterization of the Woodford Gas Shale, Oklahoma
Roger M. Slatt, Nichole Buckner, Abousleiman Younane, Rafael Sierra, Paul R. Philp, Andrea Miceli-Romero, Romina Portas, Neal O’Brien, Minh Tran, Robert Davis, Timothy Wawrzyniec, 2012. "Outcrop-behind Outcrop (Quarry): Multiscale Characterization of the Woodford Gas Shale, Oklahoma", Shale Reservoirs—Giant Resources for the 21st Century, J. A. Breyer
Download citation file:
An outcrop-behind outcrop study was conducted in and adjacent to a 300 × 100 × 16 m (980 × 330 × 50 ft) quarry of the gas-producing Woodford Shale to structurally/stratigraphically characterize it from the pore to subregional scales using a variety of techniques.
Strata around quarry walls were described and correlated to a 64 m (210 ft) long continuous core drilled 150 m (500 ft) back from the quarry wall and almost to the Woodford-Hunton unconformity. Borehole logs obtained include neutron and density porosity (NPHI and DPHI) logs, and logs from Elemental Capture Spectroscopy (ECS™), Combinable Magnetic Resonance (CMR-Plus™), Fullbore Formation MicroImager (FMI™), and sonic scanner (Modular Sonic Imaging Platform, or MSIP™)—all manufactured by Schlumberger.
The strata around the quarry are horizontally bedded. Borehole logs were used to identify a basic threefold subdivision into an upper relatively porous quartzose interval; a middle, more clay-rich, and less porous interval; and a lower interval of intermediate quartz-clay content. These intervals correspond to the informally named upper, middle, and lower Woodford. Detailed core and quarry wall description revealed several types of finely laminated lithofacies, with varying amounts of total organic carbon (TOC). The FMI log revealed a much greater degree of variability in laminations than can be readily seen with the naked eye. Organic geochemistry and biomarkers are closely tied to these lithofacies and record cyclic variations in oxic-anoxic depositional environments, which correspond to relative sea level fall-rise cycles. At the scanning electron microscopy scale, microfractures and microchannels are common and provide tortuous pathways for gas (and oil) migration through the shales.
Based on FMI and core analysis, fracture density is much greater in the upper quartzose lithofacies than in the lower, more clay-rich lithofacies. A laser imaging detection and ranging (LIDAR) survey around the quarry walls documented two near-vertical fracture trends in the quartzose lithofacies: one striking N85°E with spacings of 1.2 m (4 ft) and the other striking N45°E related to the present stress field. The FMI analysis only imaged the latter fracture set.
Both log-derived and laboratory-tested geomechanical property measurements documented a significant relationship between shale fabric (laminations and preferred clay-particle orientation) and rock strength, and a secondary relationship to mineral composition. Porosity and microfractures or microchannels also appear to influence rock strength.
This integrated study has provided insight into the causal relations among Woodford properties at a variety of scales. In particular, a stratigraphic (vertical) segregation of lithofacies can be related to cyclic variations in depositional environments. The resulting stratified zones exhibit variations in their hydrocarbon source and reservoir (fracturable) potential. Such information and predictive capability can be valuable for improved targeted horizontal drilling into enriched source rock and/or readily fracturable reservoir rock in the Woodford and perhaps other gas shales.
Figures & Tables
Shale Reservoirs—Giant Resources for the 21st Century
In the early 1970s, most exploration geologists in the United States considered subeconomic or marginally economic petroleum resources such as coalbed methane, shale gas, and tight-gas sands as unconventional resources (Law and Curtis, 2002). Tax incentives and federally funded research beginning in the late 1970s helped make these resources economically viable in the last two decades of the 20th century. Economics aside, two important geologic attributes characterize most unconventional petroleum resources (Law and Curtis, 2002). Conventional petroleum systems are buoyancy-driven accumulations found in structural or stratigraphic traps, whereas most unconventional systems exist independent of a water column and are generally not found in structural or stratigraphic traps.
Shale reservoirs are not new. The first commercial hydrocarbon production in the United States was from a well drilled in 1821 in a shale gas reservoir. By 2000, more than 28,000 wells had been drilled in shale gas reservoirs. Rising gas prices and technological advancements in horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing associated with the development of the Barnett Shale led to a boom in shale gas development in the early years of the 21st century. Now the exploitation of shale reservoirs is turning to natural gas liquids, condensate, and oil. Far from being isotropic and homogeneous, as once naively envisioned, shale reservoirs are complexly layered accumulations of fine-grained sediment. Geologic variation on scales ranging from that of stratal architecture to that of lamination within individual beds must be understood in order to locate and exploid areas of higher production within shale reservoirs. Shale reservoirs remain largely geologic plays - notmerely lease plays or strictly engineering plays made possible by improvements in drilling and completion technology.